5 ms·
It's an excellent piece. I'll admit to being a bit confused by the assertion, however: > "letting children die now so they don’t starve later—doesn’t actually
by crazygringo 13y ago
It's an excellent piece. I'll admit to being a bit confused by the assertion, however:
> "letting children die now so they don’t starve later—doesn’t actually work, thank goodness. It may be counterintuitive, but the countries with the most deaths have among the fastest-growing populations in the world. This is because the women in these countries tend to have the most births, too."
I spent five months in Kenya, and a couple weeks with the Samburu tribe during a drought. All their animals were dead, piled up, because there were no more leaves to eat. We were driving a caravan of food to distribute in the region, since otherwise the people would have been next. And the dilemma was explained to me clearly: we can't just let people die. But it means we have to send food aid all the time now, unlike decades ago, because the population is simply larger than the land can support, except in its best years, and it makes the people essentially permanently dependent on outside aid.
So I'll admit to being stumped by what Melinda Gates means when she says that overpopulation isn't the result of aid. Simply asserting that "countries with the most deaths have among the fastest-growing populations in the world" doesn't explain anything -- it's just a correlation, and might very well be due to the fact that such countries already receive the most food aid, for example.
I'm certainly not arguing that I am against, or that anyone should be against, food aid. But I am utterly unconvinced by Melissa Gates saying that "saving lives leads to overpopulation" is a myth -- she doesn't substantiate it, and it seems like the weakest part of the whole post. It all depends on how you define overpopulation, but I just don't see it yet. Of course, rising income and education lowers birth rates in the future, but that doesn't change the simple fact that, at low levels of income and education, more food aid directly results in more people, which is often more than traditional local practices and agriculture can reliably and sustainably support.
- chime 13y agoI think it is important to distinguish between the different method of aids and different causes of deaths here. Let: P1 = % of human population who live in tribes and will die in droughts P2 = % of human population who are children, live in villages/urban areas, and will die without vaccinations/medicine M1 = Multiplier for P1 (to replace the tribal people who died of hunger) M2 = Multiplier for P2 (to replace the children who died due to lack of medication) If we give food to P1 and medicine to P2, the population will be: 100% If we don't do anything, Earth's population will be: 100% - P1 - P2 + M1xP1 + M2xP2 So basically if M1 or M2 are > 1, the population due to P1 or P2 will rise. M1 might be 0 if the entire tribe dies out. But it could be > 0 if another tribe now takes over the land. M2 is most likely > 1, even as much as 3-4 depending on the location as the letter pointed out. This letter was primarily addressing P2 population. Sir David Attenborough has spoken out against foreign food aid for P1.
- caublestone 13y ago"When children are well-nourished, fully vaccinated, and treated for common illnesses like diarrhea, malaria, and pneumonia, the future gets a lot more predictable. Parents start making decisions based on the reasonable expectation that their children will live." The data seems to support the notion that healthier lives for children leads to a decrease in birth rate and family size. The size of the children population decreases as the overall quality of life for them improves because parents don't shotgun approach procreation. Also, from the piece, millions of women are unaware of contraceptives so as education increases so does the use of contraceptives.
- XorNot 13y agoThe point is that it's not like famines stop happening once a suitable number of people die. People keep reproducing, famines keep happening - the population bounces each time. If you cut all food-aid, then you just set the boundary lower - and you know, condemn a bunch of people to a painful death. You don't solve the underlying problems - and it's worth nothing that this type of population bounce is very much the historical normal for human civilizations. Our ability to organize and plan is what alleviated it - and we were thorough since granary-like enterprises can be found in the ruins of every previous human civilization that has ever existed.
- nostromo 13y agoIt seems they could have the causation arrow exactly backwards. Alternate hypothesis: Countries with fewer children have more resources to put towards those children. The Gates Foundation is super smart, so I'm hopeful they've seen enough data to consider and refute this.
- alphydan 13y agoA good place to start for an overview on the research on that causation is Hans Rosling, http://www.nooventures.org/hans-rosling-on-global-population-growth http://www.nooventures.org/hans-rosling-on-global-population... and http://www.gapminder.org/ http://www.gapminder.org/
- shas3 13y agoThe plural of your anecdote is not data that contradict the Gates' assertions. What is meant by 'population larger than the land can support'? The requirement 'land can support' is valid for communities which rely on subsistence farming. But the very fact that your caravan went there with food means that they have other sources than just 'land'. Now, if in a few years, when their population has critical mass, it becomes commercially feasible for a company to truck food there and sell it, then the problem is solved. So your anecdote, or even a systematic study of just subsistence-farming communities cannot be used to contradict the Gates' association.
- thwest 13y agoOverpopulation can also result from simple trade. NYC and generally the entire US eastern seaboard are overpopulated by your definition.
- dredmorbius 13y agoOr virtually all of the Persian Gulf. Some of the fastest-growing populations, in what's empty desert without even sufficient water for cities let alone agriculture. The economist's answer is that these regions have economic outputs (financial wizardry, advanced manufacturing, tourism, oil) which the rest of the world wants, and the rest of the world (which in the case of the Atlantic seaboard is largely the US's own inland agricultural regions -- breadbasket to the world) is willing to exchange its agricultural produce for those goods. There's a difference between economic self-sufficiency and ecological self-sufficiency. Arguments can be made over which is preferable. Comparative advantage means that the economic argument leads to greater overall population and productivity, sustainability means the ecological argument leads to greater sustainability. There's also that little matter that agriculture has largely transformed into a factory system for converting petrochemical energy to food energy via modest sunlight inputs.
- bcoates 13y agoWorrying about ecological self-sufficiency and sustainability at a smaller than planetwide scale is essentially throwing away the entire advantage of how much our massive global logistics network has shrunk the world in recent decades.
- dredmorbius 13y agoRelying on the massive global logistics network to support massively nonequilibrium populations in highly infertile land is counting on a patently unsustainable level of resource use to create a massive risk. It's one thing to have local shortfalls of food or water of a few percent which can be satisfied with largely local imports of a few hundred kilometers (say, Germany, which is roughly 90% self-sufficient for food production). It's quite another to require massive imports of food and fresh water. Economic efficiency is directly opposed to sustainability and risk.
- bcoates 13y agoI think the idea is that food aid isn't just being given out on its own but as part of a development strategy. I agree that just giving food isn't enough, and it's wrong to pretend that the drought is the problem and not the practices that resulted in a population dependent on favorable weather to live. Hopefully, we feed the people now so that starving to death isn't their top worry, and societies with food security are more stable societies that can make improvements in other ways (on their own, or with help) which eventually lead to prosperity and independence. Manhattan has more population than the land can support--the Manhattanites are entirely dependent on delivered food to survive, and have been for many generations. It's hopefully a permanent situation. Nobody worries about it because they've reached a place of development where they can just buy the food shipments instead of getting charity.
- ekm2 13y ago: we can't just let people die. But it means we have to send food aid all the time now, unlike decades ago, because the population is simply larger than the land can support, except in its best years, and it makes the people essentially permanently dependent on outside aid. It is worth noting that the Samburu tribe is one of the smallest and live in the least sparsely populated area with the worst rainfall conditions.Central and Western Kenya are heavily populated and do not need food caravans to survive. Basically, the problem you talk about has more do with the political complication of wealth distribution than with overpopulation.
- brc 13y agoPeople need food aid not because they are in a drought, but because they can't trade with the people who have the food. Solve that problem, and you solve the food problem. Lots of people live in inhospitable, drought stricken countries at a population level that the land itself could never support. The key is in trade. The people have to develop something they can trade for food to escape from food aid.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bane 13y agoIf they trade labor for food, they can move out of the drought stricken areas into more food productive ones.
- pravda 13y agoThe (late) great Sam Kinison gave the solution to world hunger over 20 years ago: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P0q4o58pKwA#t=64 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P0q4o58pKwA#t=64
- Kliment 13y agoSorry if you're trying to be funny, but that is disgusting.
- chrismonsanto 13y ago"Don't send them food, move them out of the desert where nothing grows" might not be funny, it might not be accurate, but one could hardly call it disgusting...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- clarky07 13y agoNo offense, but did you read the article? The point is that when children stop dying, parents stop having so many children. When the mortality rate goes down, the birth rate does too. Parents want to have X kids. If Y kids are likely to die, parents must have at least X+Y kids to get what they want. That, combined with a general lack of knowledge/access about/to contraceptives means population growth. Make it so that kids stop dying and parents stop having the Y+ part of the equation. Educate and give access to contraceptives and you complete the puzzle. Contrary to popular belief</sarcasm>, women don't want to spend their entire lives being pregnant.
- noselasd 13y agoAnd here's some data about what's happened to the world (not so much "why", but "what") http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RUwS1uAdUcI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RUwS1uAdUcI