3 ms·
I recently bought two Green drives for my NAS not knowing the difference. Do your research :). Having said that, the NAS is working out pretty well so far with
by IgorPartola 13y ago
I recently bought two Green drives for my NAS not knowing the difference. Do your research :).
Having said that, the NAS is working out pretty well so far with ZFS running on top of them.
- frenchman_in_ny 13y agoI bought 3 Green 2.5TB drives for a Synology NAS that's lightly used -- and all 3 have had SMART failures in the ~18 months that I've owned them. WD just sent me a refurb'ed Green 3TB drive, let's see if it holds out better. I wish I had had access to this data before buying the Greens...
- dpe82 13y agoI've had 4 Green 3TB drives in a raidZ for less than a year. First few months were great, then I had to replace two of them a couple months ago due to data errors and another just started failing so today (literally as I write this) I'm replacing the other two. Don't use Greens for anything that's on and could be active 24/7. The aggressive load cycling kills them.
- erkkie 13y agoLike others have mentioned, please make sure you're using wdidle to regulate head parking. Also might wanna read this http://forums.freenas.org/threads/western-digital-red-with-tler-vs-green-with-wdidle-set-to-disabled-drives.11280/ http://forums.freenas.org/threads/western-digital-red-with-t... . Greens are dangerous in a NAS context so make sure you have backups.
- IgorPartola 13y agoOdd. The link you posted directly contradicts your point. It says that Reds are at that time unproven and that the Greens are the way to go for ZFS. Basically it is saying that ZFS does not require TLER so that part is not an issue. On top of that it is saying that the Green drives are both common and well tested.
- erkkie 13y agoI think I read it slightly differently then, the gist was that if wdidle is properly used, the drives "should" be equivalent (since they supposedly share the same hardware, just different firmware). Reds are made for a NAS context, greens are not. You may or may not make the difference go away by using wdidle. This does make greens inherently dangerous (when compared to reds).