3 ms·
Plagiarism checking software exists. Universities use it all the time. Surely, with a relatively narrow corpus of work like poetry, this is a trivial problem to
by onion2k 13y ago
Plagiarism checking software exists. Universities use it all the time. Surely, with a relatively narrow corpus of work like poetry, this is a trivial problem to solve.
- danso 13y agoApparently the poetry field may rely on more rudimentary detection methods and so there's probably still a lot of low-hanging fruit http://rochfordstreetreview.com/2013/09/20/f-for-fake-poetry-and-plagiarism/ http://rochfordstreetreview.com/2013/09/20/f-for-fake-poetry... > According to media reports one of the judges, Anthony Lawrence, became suspicious and, with the help of another judge (M T C Cronin) started googling lines from Slattery’s poem. They discovered that about four-fifths of the lines appeared to be the work of other poets.
- TeMPOraL 13y ago> Plagiarism checking software exists. Universities use it all the time. From what my university professor told me (and some student friends of mine, who had their works checked by such software on regular basis), plagiarism checking software is mostly a joke (or a scam, depending on how you look at it), and is bought so that the university can tell that they are "employing best available methods of plagiarism-protection" when applying for government money. At least, this is how it works in Poland.
- michaelt 13y agoPlagarism detection software like Turnitin certainly catches some people, based on my experience sitting next to someone who used it at a major university. If anything it produced too many false positives. I don't know how big their corpus of poems is though.
- Tycho 13y agoLook at it like this: you could catch many instances of undergraduate plagiarism if you a) google searched passages of submitted essays/disertations and b) cross-checked all submitted papers against each other (including previous years). Anyone can do this with no special tools, but systems like Turnitin automate the process. So I don't see how it could be a joke/scam (maybe if it's outrageously expensive). It also has other features like making sure students have used citations/references correctly.
- TeMPOraL 13y agoMethod a) is a very weak check and also is either slow, or will likely make Google ban you for trying to DDoS them. Method b) is what, AFAIK, such software usually does, and from what I heard it generates tons of false positives and is generally annoying. A student friend of mine told me about how much trouble she and her year has with the anti-plagiarism system her university uses; basically citing things or using the same reference material (and thus having similar references section) is enough to mark your thesis as plagiarism. They have a ruthlessly enforced threshold of "plagiarism %" you need to stay below, and from what she says, it's incredibly difficult to do so even when writing completely original work.
- Tycho 13y agoMethod A is not really a weak check, it's bound to catch tons of cheating students, it's just tedious for staff to perform. Sounds like your friend's school is misusing the tool. Seeing that students are all using the same references is pretty interesting information, as long as you don't leap to conclusions. Likewise, seeing that someone is not citing references properly may not be evidence of plagiarism but nevertheless it's good for students to adhere to reference standards. When I used Turnitin I had to keep below a certain percentge of 'quoted' text. I found this slightly annoying but I could easily avoid it by replacing a quotation with my own summary + a citation. It's just a stylistic choice that is being enforced through the system. Also, no % of plagiarism should be acceptable - beyond the residual/accidental amount you get from coincidental phrasings.
- aestra 13y agoInterestingly when I was in high school (back in the somewhat early(ish) days of the web) we had an assignment in some English class to do some kind of writing and then copy it and distribute it to the class and read it aloud. This didn't have to be typed, almost everyone did it hand written, just had to be photocopied. I don't remember the topic of the writing at all. Someone handed out a paper that looked excellent, I read it before he read it aloud, and I didn't believe he wrote it. It was too good and seemed above something a high schooler would write. I changed my mind and believe he wrote it when he read it aloud because the way he read it, he owned it. He read it just like it was something he wrote himself. After he was done the teacher said "that was good, but you didn't write this, you downloaded this from the Internet." She didn't ask him, she didn't check, she just publicly accused him. He looked shocked and said "No I didn't!" where she just kept insisting he did without any proof whatsoever except that the paper was just good. She may have just blindly failed him on the assignment. Off topic but other student in this assignment handed out another paper which was full of misspellings and grammatical errors. Absolutely chock full of them, to the point you could hardly read it. After she read it, the teacher said "there's a lot of misspellings" to which she protested "my computer doesn't have spellcheck." She really thought this was a legitimate excuse, in English class. Like not having spellcheck excuses you from 1) proofreading and 2) picking up and old fashioned paper dictionary.
- robmclarty 13y agoFunny. I had a similar experience myself in art class in high school. The assignment was to take a photo from a magazine and reproduce its likeness with pencil and paper. I must have just had good shape and spacial recognition because the drawing I made just happened to be approximately the same size and proportions of the magazine photo I was using as reference and, so, the teacher accused me of simply tracing it. I got a zero on the assignment and was accused of being a hack in front of all my peers even though I drew it freehand, from sight (the way we were instructed). IMHO there's too much emphasis placed on doing things the "right" way and not enough on actually getting things done. Even if I did simply trace the photo, I still would have had a learning experience, engaging pencil, hand, and paper and understanding a bit more about how they work (to me, the purpose of the assignment). Regardless of how a thing is made, if it actually gets made and gets into other people's heads and gives them an experience worth having, I think it has done its job. I took up my dispute with the vice-principle along with my parents and redid the assignment on thick, opaque card-stock (that couldn't possibly be used to trace through) and reproduced another photo with just as much accuracy. I went on to attend art school and win illustration awards despite my horrible experiences with art in high school, but I worry that another student might have abandoned their pursuit of art and deprived the world of their creativity, given such negative feedback. I feel we all need to lighten up a bit.