3 ms·
A more likely outcome is the price will not rise a penny until those at the bottom who cannot survive legally at that income disappear from the market, either v
by VLM 13y ago
A more likely outcome is the price will not rise a penny until those at the bottom who cannot survive legally at that income disappear from the market, either via medical reasons induced by poverty, or because they've entered the prison industrial complex via crime.
A race to the bottom is never as much fun as it sounds.
- nickff 13y agoWas the industrial revolution the beginning of a race to the bottom, or the first step from agrarian poverty to modern prosperity?
- ItendToDisagree 13y agoFor a great many people a 'race to the bottom' scenario can easily be posited. Especially for those who are exploited to make the super cheap products (particularly electronics) everyone prosperous is supposed to enjoy. Someone is always going to be getting screwed in the name of ever increasing growth/profits and ever declining costs. That is until we reach a sweet Sci-Fi robots doing all the work scenario! :)
- VLM 13y agoThere is a peculiar history revisionist outlook that farmers were fired and then lacking any opportunity to farm, they moved to a factory. Sometimes this happened. Usually not. Reality, as anyone who is related to a farmer knows, farming is very hard work and a factory job is generally better. They were upgrading, not getting downsized. Also modern prosperity only came after labor riots where lots of people suffered intensely and died in strike violence. Obviously a lot more violence is on the way, which I think sucks. Unfortunately that seems to be the only way things actually get fixed. History shows some really awful stuff has been done in the name of "gotta do whatcha gotta do to feed the family". So... go ahead, push a couple tens of millions of desperate people into a corner, what could possibly go wrong? I mean, its not like the US populace is extremely heavily armed, or has a cultural predisposition to consider violence as entertainment, or has what boils down to a martyr as a religious symbol...
- ItendToDisagree 13y agoI seem to remember a famous rapper named Upton Sinclair who talked about this sort of thing and its effect on lower class workers. "It's like a Jungle sometimes. It makes me wonder how I keep from going under."
- maerF0x0 13y agoThey also could disappear from that market because they will find something else to do. If (in my mind, when) Robots and software drive the price of labor to the equivalent electrical cost (kind of like bit coin mining), I think people will do that which only people can: Arts, entertainment, atheletics, science and the like. We will let the automated work force do the dangerous work, the menial work, the boring work and will only do that which we want to do.
- VLM 13y ago"will only do that which we want to do." That would be awesome if food, water, housing, entertainment, clothing, and health care were free. Those are only available now to people still in the rapidly shrinking money based economic system. A more likely outcome than doing what they want to do, is death or revolution (or both, historically they usually work as a team)
- maerF0x0 13y agoan additional possible outcome is a paradigm shift w/o revolution. As more people become unemployed, destitute etc, they will command a greater amount of democratic power (votes). Additional forces bringing the products towards free are: 1) If all the consumers are poor, the capitalist/business owner will need to reduce the price of goods in order to maximize the total value of sales (better to sell 100 widgets at $1 each than 1 at $50 each), because the automated labor force has (presumably) a low operating cost they can bring the price down to the cost of materials + electricity. 2) Because the business owner doesnt mix his own labor with the goods, he/she has little claim on the product (Locke's labor theory of property) .