5 ms·
> What happened to the surplussed workers? They found other jobs. When one industry needs few workers, another always takes up the slack. I've heard this princ
by SideburnsOfDoom 13y ago
> What happened to the surplussed workers?
They found other jobs. When one industry needs few workers, another always takes up the slack. I've heard this principle stated in different ways in different places over the years.
But is it a iron law of nature, or just a thing that goes on until it doesn't?
If it will eventually stop (and I think this is likely), how would you tell when it is going to stop? Would you notice if it is already happening? What does the current situation resemble?
I have posed this question before ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6853359 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6853359 ) No definitive answer yet.
- TeMPOraL 13y ago> But is it a iron law of nature, or just a thing that goes on until it doesn't? Of course it's not a law of nature. I don't understand the way of thinking that leads to considering this (or Moore's law, to bring up another particularly common example) as a law. Inductive reasoning, "it has always been like this, thus it always will be" is not science. One needs to understand casual relationships that give rise to the supposed "law" before asserting that future will look like the past. I don't think that looking at particular industries being automated is very helpful. I'd like to propose a different model: let's put available jobs in a continuum from low-skill to high-skill (in creativity/cognitive load) jobs. In this model we see how technology continues to automate-away lower-skill jobs, climbing up the hill of difficulty. In the past, surplussed workers could find other jobs, because the way we automated things was also low-skill; therefore for every lost trade, new ones were created in its place. But the same technological progress that allows us to automate more and more difficult jobs is upgrading the process of automation. There are less and less low-skill jobs produced per low-skill job automated, and the moment we reach the point when this ratio (automated/new) is > 1, surplussed workers will be increasingly unable to get themselves employed. (Mind you, this is not inductive reasoning, there is a good casual model underneath explaining why this is happening, but I think it's obvious enough that I don't need to elaborate on it now). There's one type of jobs that are, and I believe will be for some time, exempt from the "march of progress" - jobs that require human element. Those are jobs like receptionists in hotels, doctors, psychologists - who we can connect with on emotional/trust based level. I'd personally bet that those jobs are safer than, say, tech sector, which will get automated away eventually if the progress continues.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y ago> Inductive reasoning, "it has always been like this, thus it always will be" is not science. No. But it often seems to pass for economics.
- TeMPOraL 13y agoWell, we can clearly see how good are the predictions made by this field ;).
- VLM 13y ago"because the way we automated things was also low-skill" When you make the low skilled unemployed, you can fill the prisons with them. Even hire some mid skilled folks to keep an eye on them. What you do with an excess of mid to high skill level people is a mystery, we have no historical record to copy. You can put some in prison, but the prisons are already full and expensive, so need a new path. SSDI is getting too expensive. We seem to be trying, "Let them eat cake". Hmm I wonder via historical analogy what could possibly go wrong with that?
- TeMPOraL 13y ago> When you make the low skilled unemployed, you can fill the prisons with them. Even hire some mid skilled folks to keep an eye on them. Until we realize that automated machine gun turrets are better at the job. > We seem to be trying, "Let them eat cake". Hmm I wonder via historical analogy what could possibly go wrong with that? Well, it's going to be a bloody mess if we let this trend continue the way it is going now. Note that we, the "high-skill job sector" people, won't be shielded from the effects in any way. Our jobs might be safe for a long time, but there might come a point soon, when all our low-skill family members and friends are suddenly without a job and are depending on us for food and shelter. So we can't turn our backs on the issue; the worst-case scenario will hit us hard anyway.
- VLM 13y ago"Our jobs might be safe for a long time" Or maybe not. Not to drop the docs but my current employer depends on median joe 6 pack sending us a couple bucks a month and our revenues have dropped more or less in tandem with median joe 6 pack's permanently declining household income. (edited to add, its hilarious reading the financial press doing everything they can to come up with an explanation for our declining revenue other than "Americans are becoming poorer". It must be the internet. Oh wait we actually make money off how we use it, um it must be fuel prices. Err whoops we don't actually use fuel. Well, it must be bad astrological symbols or something. Anything other than admitting failure of the economic system, J6P has less money = we have less revenue) If you think about the likely effects of the 1% having all the money and everyone else having to barter or do without, some fields like some financial sectors wouldn't have much impact, whereas providers of entertainment, food, and medical care for J6P would be utterly annihilated. Doesn't matter how highly skilled the last employed IT worker was before he got downsized along with everyone else.
- xixi77 13y agoAs long as human beings are able to produce anything of value, jobs won't go away, and why would that ever stop being the case? There is a plenty of work to be done: take, e.g., personal help industry as an example of a field that used to be huge until very recently everywhere, is still huge around the world, but is so far a source of fairly little employment in US/Europe.
- SideburnsOfDoom 13y ago> As long as human beings are able to produce anything of value, jobs won't go away, and why would that ever stop being the case? That's not a proof. That is the "surely" argument https://medium.com/science-and-technology/83dacb1fe14c https://medium.com/science-and-technology/83dacb1fe14c It's possible that this is the case, but I'm very sceptical of it. It produces some absurd results eventually: http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/07/can-economic-growth-last/ http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/07/can-economic-gro... Another trusim from economics: "If something cannot go on forever, it will stop"
- xixi77 13y agoBut, I am not actually appealing to common sense here -- that would make me no better than the "no infinite growth in finite world" people. So, are you suggesting that people will no longer be able to be of any value to others at some point in the future? Or that, despite them being able to produce such value, there would be no demand for their time? Why? I've seen that link btw. For some reason people in physics are particularly susceptible to thinking that they can understand economics better than economists do. They are quite wrong about that :)
- xixi77 13y ago(was thinking of this as I was driving this morning) -- actually all the argumentation in that article, iirc, is essentially an inverted pyramid that all rests on one point: "there is a natural limit on the ratio of the $$ value of food production to that of the rest of the economy". This is clearly a "surely" argument (it is not being supported by anything other than his intuition), and a pretty bad one at that -- for example, we've seen agricultural employment collapse from ~90% to ~2% of the population, and the process continues, despite farming subsidies and other conscious attempts to slow it down.