3 ms·
The fact that wealthier countries and people have fewer children is truly one of the great paradoxes of the human condition, from a biology point of view. I've
by jerf 13y ago
The fact that wealthier countries and people have fewer children is truly one of the great paradoxes of the human condition, from a biology point of view. I've occasionally wondered if it isn't a partial solution to the Fermi paradox. Rich humans have fewer children for many reasons, the most interesting one to my comment here being that on the "numerous vs. expensive offspring" spectrum, primates & humans have basically gone all the way to the "expensive" side, hard, and we continue to make children ever more de facto expensive in various ways.
Every other biological sample we have says increased resources leads to increased reproduction; suppose humans really do have a very bizarre, very unusual biological niche here and indeed most species really do fall into an uncontrollable Malthusian trap because they don't go all the way to the "expensive" side, and end up getting crowded out by the "numerous". I mean, it is not as if this is some sort of conscious choice we have made to contain our population, it just happened, which in some sense is why it works. If it were anything less than nearly universal, it wouldn't be able to save us. Nor, abstractly, is the Malthusian argument that bad... its only flaw is that it is observationally wrong (for population), and reality trumps theory, no matter how pretty the theory.
- lnanek2 13y agoI don't understand why you think it is a paradox. If a family is poor, without good health care for example, then more children will die or fail and it will hurt the family harder. Their employment is also more likely to be manual labor based where children quickly supplement their capabilities (e.g. farming, retail). It's simple economics.
- jerf 13y ago"More resources -> less reproduction" has, to the best of my knowledge, one example in the entire animal kingdom: Us. You're looking at the reasons, which are also interesting, but the next layer of abstraction down from the point I'm making. (Though I'm not sure you're not explaining why poor people have fewer (surviving) children, which is the opposite of the data....)
- AnimalMuppet 13y agoI think that you and jerf are talking different languages. You're saying that, economically, this makes perfect sense. And you're right. But jerf is saying that, in Darwinist terms, this makes no sense at all. And he's also right.
- ecolololology 13y agoA useful term here is "r/K selection". You can look at species on a continuum from "r selection" (quick reproduction and growth at the expense of competitive advantage) to "K selection" (slow/expensive reproduction, but better at competing for resources). Whales and elephants, as well as humans, are good examples of K-selected organisms.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoIt turns out that if you want a species to completely take over the world (ie: build civilizations), extreme K-selection works better, because civilized beings can avoid increasingly large subsets of the normal disasters that wipe out r-selected creatures. Consider what happens to rabbits, say, in famine conditions: the population is decimated. Now consider what happens to humans nowadays: we ship in food from somewhere else. For an alternative view, consider that the most important invention we ever came up with for beating Malthus was probably birth control. The genes keep doing their thing, but you don't end up getting babies out of it, which exerts an even further pressure towards K-selection: parents decide when to birth children according preparedness for the K-strategy lifestyle they themselves live. Of course, that does leave you with the problem of how to have a heavily K-strategizing civilized society deal with deliberately r-strategizing sub-populations. But this is a very rare problem that tends to sort itself out via economic recession long before it reaches Malthusian crisis proportions.