8 ms·
the price over a mass amount of units (say 100,000 units) This almost made me laugh out loud. Exactly how many kettles does the author think sells each year? M
by vacri 13y ago
the price over a mass amount of units (say 100,000 units)
This almost made me laugh out loud. Exactly how many kettles does the author think sells each year? Multiply by models and again by manufacturers, and you're talking millions of kettles. Even if you consider that one model will last multiple years, manufacturers don't buy supply batches that last for years. Some industries go in the extreme other direction - the local car industry got its stock-on-shelf lifetime down to 48 minutes from part arriving to part being screwed into car.
Similarly, retail markup is generally 20-50% of the final cost. If you think this is too high (it really isn't) then I suggest you use your new formula to undercut the existing market and disrupt away. Other significant costs are transport and wholesalers (who aren't always the manufacturers). Kettles are bulky items that consume a lot of space in storage and transport. On top of all this, every party involved in the transaction is entitled to make some profit, and not just work for costs. There's also regulatory compliance, things like the CE mark.
Looking at an item and stating that the price shouldn't be more than parts + amortised kickback to the designers is naievity, plain and simple.
- chewxy 13y agoI thought that markup was implicitly accepted in blog. I of course do not think that the price should be just the cost of the parts. In fact, I did mention that the fact that both $10 kettles and $39 kettles exist implies that there is some form of price discrimination. The difference in price is the additional markup that the manufacturer can get away with. As I mentioned, my marginal utility does not increase with the markup - a $39 kettle gives me the same utility as a $10 kettle. As for 100,000 units, yeah, that was probably a mistake. Australia only has 22 million people. No idea why I arbitrarily picked 100,000.
- vacri 13y agoYeah, I read through in more detail and saw that lurking towards the end. Just came back to edit, perhaps delete the comment but it's already replied-to. :) The costings at the end are off. Testing is much less that $5/unit for these kind of things, for example. Usually you'll have a common testbench across all products - it'll be much lower per unit, and not tied to a particular model. Also, retailers aren't the only ones in the pricing process - as I say above, wholesalers/distributors and transport also get figured into the cost. It all adds up. Marketing costs are mostly borne by the retailer portion of the price, as the wholesale channel marketing is much more limited and cost-effective (no tv or radio spots, print one catalogue and you're fine for a quarter/year, run a more niche website only for retailers, etc) The Australia-limited market thing is less of an issue - a kettle will have a market wider than this. But kettles generally last a long time, and there are hundreds of models out there. Though to honest, after a friend's horror story of one day finding a cockroach in her kettle that had been boiled white, I'm much keener on glass kettles now...
- gojomo 13y agoSame utility? Not if you fear your $10 plastic kettle so much that, after a single circuit-breaker throw, you have to discard it! Never mind the $39 kettle. Totaled over ten years, the $150 kettle's seemingly-tiny advantages in reliability, capacity, features, and style over the $10 kettle can be worth way more than its $140 price premium.
- thatthatis 13y agoSay 10% of American households and 80% of British households buy electric tea kettles that last exactly 10 years each. That's 10 million total market in the US (100 x .1) and about 16 million in the UK (~20 x .8). So 26 million total market with a level 1/10th per year or 2.6 million kettles per year. At 100k run per year per manufacturer, the market can then support 26 different models easily. On the second point, It seemed that he was adding the 2x retail markup into his figures. If you'd followed the link on amazon, you'd see that $90 was market down from about $200. Sometimes it's best to ask "what would you have to believe for this to be right" before you tear into someone for faulty analysis. All of his number easily pass my smoke tests.
- teamonkey 13y agoComing from the UK I can't believe that only 80% of households own an electric kettle. The idea of going to someone's house and not finding a kettle seems genuinely ludicrous. Not just houses - almost every break room of every business will have one. Of course, they cost quite a bit less on average in the UK.
- rgbrenner 13y agoYou just described coffee makers in the US. Tea kettles on the other hand... can't recall ever seeing one in real life.
- petercooper 13y agoMaybe the other 20% own non-electric kettles, like us, or have one-touch boiling water systems, like my parents. When our last electric kettle blew up 3-4 years ago, we decided to go with a good, old fashioned metal kettle that we use on the hob. Works well, doesn't ever break, and even makes it a bit more of an 'event' to put the kettle on as you get all the boiling sounds, the whistle going off, etc. My parents, on the other hand, have a thing that produces boiling water at the touch a button so they just use that to dump water into their mugs instead. Either way, an electric kettle is far from the only solution .
- 13y ago
- newman314 13y agoDo you have a source for the part about 48mins from part arrival to installation? I find that data point fascinating and would like to learn more about how this is pulled off.