6 ms·
Yay, more villifying "Wall Street" and fueling the "Wall Street vs. Main Street" fire, and suggesting that it's somehow noble or good to not want to be rich. I
by mindcrime 13y ago
Yay, more villifying "Wall Street" and fueling the "Wall Street vs. Main Street" fire, and suggesting that it's somehow noble or good to not want to be rich.
I think everybody should want to be rich.
I've tried poverty and in my opinion - it sucks. It sucks big, steaming donkey balls.
The desire to make more money, to improve one's "lot in life" and to succeed, this is a Good Thing. Because a few assholes go too far in some ways, or do bad things along the path, does not change the fundamentals.
You can be rich and unhappy, or poor and unhappy. Given a choice, if I'm going to be unhappy, I'd rather at least be rich.
No one should feel any need to apologize or feel guilty about wanting to make money, even lots of money. If you want to be a fucking billionaire, go become a billionaire. Just feel guilty if you lie, or cheat or steal, or otherwise do unethical things to get there. And remember that having more money doesn't make you a better person, or intrinsically more valuable.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gjm11 13y agoI don't really disagree, but: You write as if the only options are "rich" and "poor". It's possible for the following two things both to be true: (1) Being poor sucks big, steaming donkey balls. (2) Being rich (as opposed to not-poor) is, for one reason or another, not a wise thing to aim for. As it happens, I think #2 isn't correct, because given the way the world is (a) being rich is the only way to be reasonably well assured of never being poor, and (b) there are a whole lot of people in the world who are desperately poor, and if you care at all about them then you have a use for an unlimited quantity of money, namely sending it their way. But in a less messed-up world, I think it would be eminently reasonable not to have a strong preference for being rich over merely comfortably off, and if the former takes a lot more work or risk than the latter then it would be reasonable not to bother.
- mindcrime 13y agoI don't really disagree, but: You write as if the only options are "rich" and "poor". True... in the name of brevity, and perhaps out of haste, I did generalize a bit. And the two points I mean to emphasize are: 1. Being poor sucks (I think we can all agree on this) and 2. There's nothing intrinsically wrong with wanting to be rich, even "dirty, rotten, filthy stinking rich". In the case of (2), I posit that the desire itself is fine, but the actions you take to try and achieve that end, may or may not be noble, just, good, or ethical.
- gjm11 13y agoI'm uncertain about the strong form of your #2, for the following reason. Suppose you desire to be a billionaire (and stay one -- it's not that you want to get $1B so that you can give most of it away to deserving recipients, or use it to lobby governments to improve the world). In particular, you would prefer to have $1B than to have $0.5B in your hands and $0.5B transferred to the world's poorest people. The thing is, half a billion dollars can do a lot of good. A typical estimate is that you can save a life (i.e., something like a life's worth of quality-adjusted life-years) for a few thousand dollars, if you're happy for it to be a life in what used to be called the "third world" and if you take care to put the money where it can be used most effectively. Let's be conservative and suppose it's $10k/life. So our hypothetical would-be billionaire would rather have $1B than have $0.5B and (5e8/1e4) = 50,000 Africans' lives saved. I'm sure it's very nice to be a billionaire, but damn. Something like this sort of prioritization of one's own welfare applies to pretty much all of us, of course -- would you rather have a car or save a life? would you rather have a slightly larger house or save ten lives? etc. And maybe this means we're all monsters. But, so far as I can tell, the difference in personal well-being between having a billion dollars and having half that is really small, and the difference that money could make to the lives of others is really large, and it does seem extra-specially monstrous to prefer that really small difference to saving tens of thousands of lives. So I really do think there's something morally iffy about a very strong desire to be dirty, rotten, filthy stinking rich, in a way that there isn't about a desire to be merely rich. Wanting to have, say, $10M seems to me morally quite a different sort of thing from wanting to have $1B. Of course if you want to have $1B and then give most of it away then, please, go for it. As long as you select the recipients of your largesse with some care. Likewise if you have other plans for your billion that involve having beneficial billion-dollar-sized impacts on the world. Fund important scientific research, bribe politicians to do things you think are valuable, whatever. What strikes me as problematic is wanting to have and keep all that money. You don't need it that badly. Really, you don't. ("You" above, of course, doesn't mean you personally.) [EDITED to add one more remark (because the above wasn't long enough already). I'm assuming that "want" means something like "seriously intend, to the best of your ability" rather than just "find yourself with some sort of desire". People want all kinds of things and that doesn't have much moral significance until they start actually trying to get them.]
- ItendToDisagree 13y agoAs has been stated... The derivatives trading business was a prime culprit for the crash of 2008 so I think it is fair to say that some lying, cheating, stealing went on and the subsection of finance the author was involved in was complacent in it. Also being rich vs poor, and Wall St vs Main Street, are not the same thing by any stretch of the imagination. You can become rich without working in finance. And you can hate Wall St's culture and also be rich. I don't think that all the people who are pissed about the financial crisis are poor or that they think being poor is noble. That seems like a pretty false dichotomy. Being poor does truly suck! I think the main issue the author is pointing out is how ignoble it is to be unhappy with a 2mil bonus for a job that really isn't that important in the big scheme of things. 2mil is a lot of money for the vast majority of people and bitching about it just makes you out to be an asshole. If that is a cultural issue with that section of finance then that seems like a legitimate concern.
- mindcrime 13y agoAs has been stated... The derivatives trading business was a prime culprit for the crash of 2008 so I think it is fair to say that some lying, cheating, stealing went on and the subsection of finance the author was involved in was complacent in it. Yes that's been stated, but I wouldn't say that it's been proven. There are a LOT of theories about what did and didn't happen as part of the 2008 financial crisis and in the run-up to it. For a take (from an insider) that may be a bit different from some of what has been said elsewhere, read John A. Allison's The Financial Crisis And The Free-Market Cure. Not saying Allison's take is 100% correct, but I just want to point out there are are certainly different points of view on that crisis. I don't think that all the people who are pissed about the financial crisis are poor or that they think being poor is noble. Fair enough. I didn't read TFA as being mainly about the 2008 crisis specifically, but that could be a mistake on my part. I do tend to generalize a bit as well. I think the main issue the author is pointing out is how ignoble it is to be unhappy with a 2mil bonus for a job that really isn't that important in the big scheme of things. 2mil is a lot of money for the vast majority of people and bitching about it just makes you out to be an asshole. I can (and do) agree that complaining about a $2MM bonus makes you something of an asshole, especially from some points-of-view. I think what bothers me about these articles is the implicit suggestion that "something ought to be done", which leads to the idea of more regulations, more laws, more rules, more restrictions, etc., which I believe - by and large - are counter-productive. Again, see the John Allison book... if one buys his angle (and I mostly do), there's a strong argument there that it was government policy and the behaviour of government regulators, things dating back to the LBJ era, if not earlier, that ultimately led to the 2008 crisis. Anything that reads as an argument for more government involvement evokes something of a visceral reaction from me, since I am a proponent of laissez-faire. It also frustrates me when I see people seemingly painting a picture of "wall street VS main street". I don't think that's accurate at all, and I think it's an unhealthy attitude. "Wall Street" and "Main Street" are just different views of the same system. The people of "main street" can certainly leverage capital markets to build wealth... you don't have to be a bigshot wall-street insider to do that. And, in fact, many pension funds, university endowments, etc., are heavily invested in "Wall Street" which means that many people ultimately do benefit from growth in the markets, even if they aren't day-trading or investing as individuals. Of coure I'm not saying that everybody on Wall Street is perfect, or faultless or anything. I just think it would be better if everybody saw Wall Street as something they can take part in and benefit from, not as some mythical enemy.
- king_jester 13y ago> The desire to make more money, to improve one's "lot in life" and to succeed, this is a Good Thing. One of the key points of this essay is that making more money doesn't necessarily improve one's quality of life. The author clearly talks about at age 25 being financially secure and wealthy, so his pursuit of additional wealth wasn't really about an increase in quality of life. > You can be rich and unhappy, or poor and unhappy. Given a choice, if I'm going to be unhappy, I'd rather at least be rich. Wealth and class aren't about binary choices. There are levels of income that are wholly satisfactory for an individual's life that still classify that person as not rich. > No one should feel any need to apologize or feel guilty about wanting to make money, even lots of money. If you want to be a fucking billionaire, go become a billionaire. Just feel guilty if you lie, or cheat or steal, or otherwise do unethical things to get there. Is it even possible to be a billionaire without exploiting others? Even if so, is it right that you can be a billionaire while there are more empty homes each night in the US than the homeless population? Is it right that you can safely eat anything you like while others have to make sacrifices and choices because of political cuts to SNAP? The answer is clearly no. In this way, pursuing money for wealth's sake is unethical.
- ItendToDisagree 13y agoThat is an interesting question about being a billionaire without exploiting anyone. I'm genuinely curious about that. Not that I think being a Billionaire automatically makes you an asshole. I'm just curious if that is possible just from a logistical standpoint. Somewhere along the line someone gets screwed right?
- hershel 13y ago> billionaire without exploiting anyone. Some social science guys would say that this is true for every business - since you're operating in an exploiting system(capitalism) ,someone is bound to get exploited.
- WalterBright 13y agoOld Soviet joke: Under capitalism, man exploits man. Under socialism, it's the other way around.
- VMG 13y agoIt's also strange that this kind of hate is specifically focused on Wall Street types, much less so than against the Elon Musks, Steve Jobs's and Bill Gates's of the world, which could also easily be described as fanatical and addicted to wealth and success.
- nmodu 13y agoI think you're missing one of the author's implicit underlying messages. Wealth is awesome; no doubt about it. But, as you are accumulating wealth, are you simultaneously creating value? Personal wealth and value creation don't always go hand-in-hand. Also, as the author (and commenters) pointed out, this isn't a reflection of all of Finance. Stocks, bonds, future, options and other derivatives are essential for growth. We will always need ways to finance investment and tools to manage the accompanying risk. The author was saying that he was getting rich by trading credit default swaps (and probably synthetic CDOs), which -ultimately- played the largest role in destroying massive amounts of value post-2008 because of the sheer volume at which they were being traded (and because the securities that the CDSs were insuring were backed by subprime loans). Honestly though, you don't have to know much about the 2008 crash to recognize the weakness of your argument. Elon Musk, Steve Jobs and Bill Gates may be (or may have been) addicted to wealth and success. But they accumulated wealth by creating innovative products. The same could not be said of the typical fixed-income trader circa 2007.
- tommydiaz 13y agoI think the problem being addressed in the article is not about wanting to be rich, but rather the question "how much is enough?" For example, in the movie "Wallstreet", Gordon Gecko gets asked this same question, but he can never truly answer it. If a man who gets to his position, makes millions of dollars, and has the mental capacity to make a ton of business decisions daily, can't answer this simple question- that's definitely a problem. Surely, for the average person $1.5 million is considered "rich". To keep making money for the sake of making money, is clearly an addiction, which (as mentioned in the article) is supported by our culture of excess.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- pyrrhotech 13y agoI agree with you, I just don't think it's fair that these assholes on wall street can make 4 million dollar bonuses at age 30 for getting lucky with gambling other people's money. I think it's great for everyone to have the desire for wealth, as long as you are making your money in an honest, value-producing way. I don't think derivatives hedge fund gamblers are honestly earning their pay. The only thing that can stop them is financial education of the public. The stats show, year after year, that the vast majority of hedge funds lag the market---and get paid massive fees to do so. Someone has to be paying for these bonuses, and that someone is you--if you buy mutual funds or other high-fee actively managed funds. That's why I boycott even my 401k as there aren't any passive index funds for me to choose.
- CreakyParrot 13y agoYay, more villifying "Wall Street" and fueling the "Wall Street vs. Main Street" fire, and suggesting that it's somehow noble or good to not want to be rich. It's somehow noble or good to not want to be rich after you've become so, is the cliché.