4 ms·
Actually, my problem with conspiracy theorists is that a whole lot of them do believe in Jewish Bolshevism/Zionist Occupied Government nonsense. And I'm Jewish
by eli_gottlieb 13y ago
Actually, my problem with conspiracy theorists is that a whole lot of them do believe in Jewish Bolshevism/Zionist Occupied Government nonsense. And I'm Jewish: the result is that every time some nutter shoots up a community center, the real reason is because he never got the mental-health care he needed, but the proximate reason is that "not loons" conspiracy theorists told him we were holding Evil League of Evil meetings there.
- PavlovsCat 13y ago> the proximate reason is that "not loons" conspiracy theorists told him we were holding Evil League of Evil meetings there. The post you replied to made it pretty clear that those are to be considered loons. Conflating legitimate concerns and crazyness is exactly what needs to stop.
- vacri 13y agoYou couldn't ask for a more textbook version of No True Scotsman. "Don't stigmatise conspiracy theorists, because the ones who attack places on the theory that there's a conspiracy going on... they aren't really conspiracy theorists!"
- PavlovsCat 13y agoHuh. I didn't say they're not conspiracy theorists, did I? That's putting words in my mouth I never said, in other words a strawman. Labeling anyone and everyone as "conspiracy theorist" because they are talking about a conspiracy doesn't make them all the same, that makes as much sense as treating all humans like serial killers because Charles Manson was a human, too. Is realizing how silly that is a No True Scotsman, too? Please. To use big words, too, this is orders of magnitude below the standard of HN. When drug dealers, who conspired to deal drugs, are busted, does that make the police "conspiracy theorists"? Why not, since they technically are? Because more often than not, that label is used to lump legitimate concerns together with kooky ones.
- vezzy-fnord 13y agoAll the people I've seen who spout nonsense about ZOG are white nationalists or part of some other extremist group. White supremacists, Illuminati buffs and then the legitimate political conspiracy researchers are three very separate leagues of their own, despite all being under the collective classification as "conspiracy theorists". Much in the same way radical feminists, postmodern feminists and legitimate women's rights/feminist activists are three different leagues, despite all being unified under feminism.
- eli_gottlieb 13y ago> All the people I've seen who spout nonsense about ZOG are white nationalists or part of some other extremist group. And the ones I've seen are part of the International Socialist Organization and the Green Party. Strange how you apparently can't escape racism just by getting away from the far-right.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoI've run into those folk as well, and they also usually believe in chem-trails, crystal healing, that all tech is from aliens doing deals with the government and that we never went to the moon. I think someone must have left a copy of the 'Protocols' bullshit in a squat once when there was a lot of acid around.