2 ms·
No. Only for one-dimensional systems can classical systems approximate quantum ones to arbitrary accuracy. The resulting technique is known as DMRG. (Although t
by selimthegrim 13y ago
No. Only for one-dimensional systems can classical systems approximate quantum ones to arbitrary accuracy. The resulting technique is known as DMRG. (Although there is some crazy 12-dimensional corner case with adiabatic quantum computation I recall hearing about [1], it's totally irrelevant to most simulation in general and especially the sort you are talking about, unless you know of a classical way to find the ground state of all 1-D spin glasses, in which case there are a lot of people at UCSB who would be very excited to talk to you.)
[1] http://arxiv.org/abs/0705.4077 http://arxiv.org/abs/0705.4077
- dnautics 13y agoAre you sure you're not confusing "exact solutions" for iterative approximation?
- selimthegrim 13y agoI am aware of Krysta Svore's work at MSR [1][2] (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhW3Sen9TVY http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fhW3Sen9TVY) that might be what you are describing, but those "classical" methods certainly do not work on all systems and with arbitrary accuracy. And the iterative approximations do not converge for more complex systems in the lifetime of the universe, nor do we have enough computing power to do so. She is predicting ground state structure, certainly not say excited states where geometry and Berry phase effects and non-adiabaticity come into play. [1] http://research.microsoft.com/apps/video/default.aspx?id=177462 http://research.microsoft.com/apps/video/default.aspx?id=177... [2] http://research.microsoft.com/apps/video/default.aspx?id=177458 http://research.microsoft.com/apps/video/default.aspx?id=177...
- dnautics 13y ago> And the iterative approximations do not converge for more complex systems in the lifetime of the universe I'm not arguing computational efficiency, here. Just "possibility". For the most part, say, a chemist like me (if I even resorted to a computational package) would do one or a handful of rounds, take a look, and say, 'that's good enough for me'. In the end, on the scale of things like microtubules, a first order approximation of whatever 'quantum effect' needs to be accounted for will probably suffice because randomness from just about everything else (e.g. brownian motion) will drown things in the noise.
- undoware 13y agoSimulating a quantum system in a classical mechanical system may be possible in a limited sense, for trivial problems, but certainly not at speed. It's straight up P v NP. You will boil an ocean to watch any nontrivial simulation crawl frame by frame. But you wander off that point and return to the 'wet-and-noisy' argument he addresses explicitly in the abstract. Let's call it the Argument from Noise, or AfM. Again, if you read the abstract, you'll see K explains how this new discovery makes moot the AfM (but not rebut it, as a rebuttal or refutation requires an argument; making moot merely requires a contradicting observation. E.g. if the cops have a watertight argument for how, why when and where X murdered Y, it's moot if 100 reliable witnesses report X was playing acoustic folk-rock at a nearby cafe at the time.)