3 ms·
> then this means that people who’s labor income will lie between $0 and $20k will have no incentive to work. This is called begging the question.
by pessimizer 13y ago
> then this means that people who’s labor income will lie between $0 and $20k will have no incentive to work.
This is called begging the question.
- jessaustin 13y agoAre you referring to the implicit assumption that consumption is the primary incentive for a person to work? That's pretty non-controversial among economists, but if you're a philosopher or something you can certainly argue the point. Anyway, that assumption about consumption is really only the premise of TFA. The sentence you quote is the implication of that premise and some statistics. Argue with the premise, argue with the statistics, argue with the implication if you want, but I just don't see the circularity here.