3 ms·
> The iPod is an example of a prettily designed product that felt good in your hand, but that clearly made working with music "more complicated and difficult."
by mikestew 13y ago
> The iPod is an example of a prettily designed product that felt good in your hand, but that clearly made working with music "more complicated and difficult."
Interesting, because the first iPods I bought for my wife and I were specifically to address the fact that everything else on the market that I tried at the time was a pain in the ass to use. I found the first-gen iPod Nanos in conjunction with iTunes to be the opposite of "more complicated and difficult". "Worst of breed"? I can name a half dozen examples that were far worse than anything Apple has ever produced. Obviously YMMV.
> I think that the lesson from iPod example would be: Marketing matters.
I often read the "it's all marketing" screeds as "a lot of people like this thing, and I don't. I am bothered by this fact. Therefore the only reason the sheep buy them is marketing." Could be that the sheep truly find that it's a way to trim their wool that suits them better.
- pessimizer 13y agoDoesn't have anything to do with "sheep." It has to do with availability and expertise. People aren't aware of every product that can fulfill their wants (availability), and sometimes don't even have a want until they have already been exposed to a particular product. They also frequently don't have the expertise to effectively differentiate the products that they are aware of. It works the same whether the product is good or terrible. >I often read the "it's all marketing" screeds as "a lot of people like this thing, and I don't. I am bothered by this fact. Therefore the only reason the sheep buy them is marketing." Could be that the sheep truly find that it's a way to trim their wool that suits them better. This is more a screed than anything I've said. I don't care if you use an iPod. >"Worst of breed"? I can name a half dozen examples that were far worse than anything Apple has ever produced. You're right - it was a bit of an exaggeration. Microsoft's "PlaysForSure" cert was nearly as bad, and all of Sony's lines were garbage (IMO.) What I mean to say is that there was never a point when you couldn't find a $50 player that offered a far better UX than an iPod.
- mikestew 13y agoThanks for the expansion. I took your comment as another "iPod sucks, blah, blah, all marketing" type. Obviously the problem lies in my knee-jerk reactions. :-) > You're right - it was a bit of an exaggeration. Microsoft's "PlaysForSure" cert was nearly as bad, and all of Sony's lines were garbage (IMO.) Aaaand, you hit on the top two candidates for "Why Did mikestew Buy an iPod?" MSFT's offering was broken from the start, and later yanked (buh-bye, music!), and the company that brought you the original Walkman obviously lost their magic. But of the $50 players, I never found one worth keeping. Maybe I just never learned about them, hence making your point of "marketing matters". :-)
- Domenic_S 13y agoYou're either trolling or not old enough to remember what the portable player scene was like in 2001. Burned CDs on portable cd walkmans were the norm. Minidisc was high tech. 2/4GB of onboard memory + expansion slot was typical. "Anti-skip protection" was still a feature worth mentioning. The iPod's storage capacity was massive in comparison to nearly everything else. The firewire connection made uploading huge amounts of music crazy-fast in comparison to the old USB connections other players were using. Look at digital players of the same vintage -- stupid complicated interfaces & displays -- the clickwheel was a revolution in UX. So much so that it remains, largely unchanged, on all but touchscreen ipods.
- pessimizer 13y agoThere were plenty of fairly high-capacity mp3 players around before the iPod came out, and I was 25 in 2001; a target market for them. >the clickwheel was a revolution in UX I guess. It's pretty, at least. >So much so that it remains, largely unchanged, on all but touchscreen ipods. That isn't revolution, that's branding. The product had a single differentiating feature, and they've maintained it. And iTunes was a revolution in awful, unnecessary experiences that one can have with a computer.