4 ms·
>we built our own approximation of the Nest Learning Thermostat in one day — and we’ve open sourced everything. In this process, we’ve come to respect the incre
by pessimizer 13y ago
>we built our own approximation of the Nest Learning Thermostat in one day — and we’ve open sourced everything. In this process, we’ve come to respect the incredible technical challenges that Nest has solved while also coming to understand how much the game has changed since they first started.
I missed the technical challenges - this seems trivial, and exactly how easy that I would imagine it to be. The only challenge that I see is figuring that people would want a thermostat controlled by a phone app.
Since that's been figured out, I'm going to be very surprised if within 2 years 10 vendors don't have $50 versions sold at Wal-Mart, and there aren't 2-3 different open source software stacks competing to support a few of them.
- tunesmith 13y agoI always thought the main technical challenge would be the machine learning, which I imagine was made more accurate by relying on data from groups of people rather than just the one household. Although for thermostats, I really would rather it just learn from me alone anyway.
- rhizome 13y agoFrom Nest's history of capitulation to the patent industry, I predict several roadblocks on the path to $50 versions at WalMart. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nest_Labs#Litigation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nest_Labs#Litigation
- smackfu 13y agoThat seems like they settled with one patent holder but are fighting several other lawsuits. I wouldn't describe it as a history of capitulation.
- rhizome 13y agoThat's only a matter of opinion. Regardless, their history appears to reveal facts of IP roadbumps in trying to do anything in the automated thermostat world.
- nostromo 13y agoDesign matters. I remember when the iPod was still crazy expensive and people were abandoning their much cheaper Rios in droves. Btw, I've purchased a few cheap home devices. For example, a few smart light switches. I've ended up switching back because they made my life more complicated and difficult, the opposite of the intended effect.
- pessimizer 13y agoThe iPod is an example of a prettily designed product that felt good in your hand, but that clearly made working with music "more complicated and difficult." At the time, it was clearly the worst of breed when it came to listening to music. Still is, in my opinion, but my perception is more than a few generations behind. I think that the lesson from iPod example would be: Marketing matters. Judging the quality of a tool by its price is the reason that Monster can sell $5 cables for $50. edit: I'd be happy to hear of any improvement that iPods made to mp3 players other than making them into expensive status symbols that refuse to play anything but a proprietary vendor format that all music has to be lossily converted to by a buggy, slow, invasive application (at the dawn of iPods, not whatever condition iTunes or iPods are in currently.)
- mikestew 13y ago> The iPod is an example of a prettily designed product that felt good in your hand, but that clearly made working with music "more complicated and difficult." Interesting, because the first iPods I bought for my wife and I were specifically to address the fact that everything else on the market that I tried at the time was a pain in the ass to use. I found the first-gen iPod Nanos in conjunction with iTunes to be the opposite of "more complicated and difficult". "Worst of breed"? I can name a half dozen examples that were far worse than anything Apple has ever produced. Obviously YMMV. > I think that the lesson from iPod example would be: Marketing matters. I often read the "it's all marketing" screeds as "a lot of people like this thing, and I don't. I am bothered by this fact. Therefore the only reason the sheep buy them is marketing." Could be that the sheep truly find that it's a way to trim their wool that suits them better.
- jcastro 13y agoThe tricky bit is the learning; the first few weeks or so with it I was adjusting it all the time, now I don't need to do that, it knows I prefer to go to bed warm and wake up cool and just sets the right temperature. I thought the phone app would be gimmicky, but it's nice to be able to get off the plane and un-autoaway the thing so by the time you get home it's comfortable.
- ghaff 13y agoMy problem is that I don't really have patterns. Sometimes work from home, sometimes don't. Do a lot of traveling. Hours vary quite a bit. The only thing that would tempt me about Nest other than general coolness is that I could remotely turn down heat when traveling if I forgot before leaving. But that's not worth $250.
- dclara 13y agoTotally agree with you. The down side is not only machine learning may not meet my satisfaction, it may make me annoyed. My current thermostat works pretty well for me if I need adjust not too frequently everyday. A scheduled plan should be good enough if we really want to improve this kind of devices. The second problem is that it's lacking of systematic design. Think about we are going to have some many "Intenet of the things" in our home or office, we have to download some man apps, each of them needs cloud services which usually not free. This is how they make money after the hardware sales. - Eggs should not be washed.
- pessimizer 13y agoI wouldn't imagine that the learning would be tricky for someone with familiarity with machine learning in general. There are more people who are familiar with machine learning than people who work for Nest.
- smackfu 13y agoThe only "tricky" part of the learning is that you need to put a CPU in that is powerful enough to run a program.