3 ms·
I think granting "do whatever we want to citizens of other countries when they are in their home country" as a part of sovereignty is bizarre. We are not sover
by dllthomas 13y ago
I think granting "do whatever we want to citizens of other countries when they are in their home country" as a part of sovereignty is bizarre. We are not sovereign over that territory.
- dictum 13y agoYou could say that the US government can do whatever with the data of citizens of other countries that flows through US networks, but that still wouldn't justify the NSA tapping on foreign-only networks on grounds of do-whatever-we-want sovereignity, would it?
- rayiner 13y agoSovereignty means total freedom of action except perhaps what you bargain away. And even then, in the absence of some higher jurisdiction to enforce them, agreements between sovereigns are only binding out of politeness and convenience. In other words, to say that the U.S. can't say tap international fiber cables and record all French traffic, you must be able to point to a treaty where we agree not to do that. And even then, since nobody can enforce that treaty against us, we follow it only to the extent we find it convenient. Sovereign nations exist amongst themselves in a state of nature, and those are the rules of nature.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y ago> total freedom of action except perhaps what you bargain away. Sovereignty and the lack of some treaty preventing some behavior X does nothing to prevent other sovereigns from becoming angry and or retaliating in kind. Doing something 'because we can' does not make it wise.
- rayiner 13y agoSure, the other sovereigns are welcome to retaliate, mope, etc. But there is a huge difference between "should not" and "can not." It's also fundamental that "should" is determined by democratic process, while "can" may be subject to legal constraints that override democracy.
- dllthomas 13y agoBut we were discussing "should not". If all sovereignty means is, effectively, "you can do whatever you can get away with" then "it's our sovereign right" conveys no moral force. We can and should curtail our "sovereign rights" and everyone else's whenever it aligns sufficiently with our interests and ideals.