6 ms·
Obama presents NSA reforms with plan to end government storage of call data
- acabal 13y agoWow, this is a whole lot of nothing. Instead of recognizing the problem of having secret Star Chamber-ish courts in the first place, he just says "yeah we're just really going to make sure the NSA goes to them first." Mass storage of phone conversations doesn't appear to be ended, just shuffled off to some private contractor instead of being NSA-internal. Phone records aren't even the biggest concern in the first place. The real scary thing is their Internet firehose taps at places like AT&T room 641A and their Utah datacenter built to store exabytes upon exabytes of data. Put two and two together--that's the worry. Not a peep about that. This is literally nothing. None of the core issues have been addressed. He's just changed the window-dressing.
- Theodores 13y ago> Mass storage of phone conversations doesn't appear to be ended, just shuffled off to some private contractor instead of being NSA-internal. Exactly. Except it is not going to be 'some private contractor', it will be dream come true for Lockheed Martin. Or, if it is not them then it will be some other military contractor because otherwise people will cotton to the fact that, for all intents and purposes, the NSA is Lockheed Martin. At least the NSA is theoretically accountable to the government, and the people by proxy. A private company is all about shareholder value. So, strip away the presentation by the cuddly President and you get yet more privatisation/outsourcing of the military-industrial complex.
- latj 13y agoNo, its something. Its saying the U.S. spymasters will not spy on Germany's spymasters without getting the approval of the secret U.S. kangaroo court. I dont know about you but I'm feeling more confident in the system already.
- tzs 13y ago> Wow, this is a whole lot of nothing. Instead of recognizing the problem of having secret Star Chamber-ish courts in the first place What specific problems do you see with the FISA courts that would not also be present if these cases were heard in regular Federal district courts?
- streetnigga 13y agoHere is a quote from a NYTimes article from 2011 that sheds light on the targets of the military industrial complex at the end of 2010[1]. The industries various components don't always align to the governments side, more towards the interest of profits and profit interests: 'The e-mails include what appears to be an exchange on Nov. 9, 2010, between Aaron Barr, HBGary Federal’s chief executive, and John W. Woods, a Hunton & Williams partner who focuses on corporate investigations. Mr. Barr recounted biographical tidbits about the family of a one-time employee of a union-backed group that had challenged the chamber’s opposition to Obama administration initiatives like health care legislation. “They go to a Jewish church in DC,” Mr. Barr apparently wrote. “They have 2 kids, son and daughter.”' So we are told to believe that this sensitive national security data that is our collective communications will be safe in the same hands that not only had the tools they were given access to leaked, but who also had their correspondences plotting to attack dissidents leaked. This is so fucked up on so many levels. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/12/us/politics/12hackers.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2011/02/12/us/politics/12hackers.html...
- ck2 13y agoRight after they close gitmo. He completely ignored all the recommendations of the panel he appointed to give him recommendations.
- streetnigga 13y agoSo the data will be handed over to the likes of Booz Allen Hamilton, who as Snowden showed have a stellar record at keeping secrets. Bullcock.
- patrickmay 13y ago"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized." The data shouldn't be collected in the first place.
- rayiner 13y ago"Second, even if petitioner did harbor some subjective expectation that the phone numbers he dialed would remain private, this expectation is not 'one that society is prepared to recognize as 'reasonable.'' Katz v. United States, 389 U. S., at 361. This Court consistently has held that a person has no legitimate expectation of privacy in information he voluntarily turns over to third parties. E. g., United States v. Miller, 425 U. S., at 442-444; Couch v. United States, 409 U. S., at 335-336; United States v. White, 401 U. S., at 752 (plurality opinion); Hoffa v. United States, 385 U. S. 293, 302 (1966); Lopez v. United States, 373 U. S. 427 (1963). In Miller, for example, the Court held that a bank depositor has no 'legitimate `expectation of privacy'' in financial information 'voluntarily conveyed to . . . banks and exposed to their employees in the ordinary course of business.' 425 U. S., at 442." Smith v. Maryland, 442 U.S. 735, 743-744 (1979). Now, as a general principle, just because the Supreme Court has said something it doesn't mean they're not wrong, but the 4th amendment's use of the word "unreasonable" which is historically a signal indicating the need for judicial line drawing, puts this particular bit of line drawing peculiarly within their purview.
- res0nat0r 13y agoThis doesn't apply to data about you. It has been ruled legal that ATT / 3rd parties can collect and store who you call and when since this data belongs to them anyway.
- dllthomas 13y agoUnless it's covered by HIPAA...
- giardini 13y ago
- sschueller 13y agoProve it mr. president! How do we know the calls won't be stored? The stuff the NSA is doing is already illegal but I doubt anyone other than whistle blowers will go to prison.
- Pxtl 13y agoIf the executive really wanted this stuff to be closed, it would be closed.
- rasur 13y agoWell, of course the executive doesn't want it closed (for whatever reasons), this is all grandstanding to placate the simple masses.
- mindslight 13y agoOh no, I thought for sure he would fix everything after he found out about the spying. The NSA must be blackmailing him! Maybe the Supreme Court will swoop in and rescue us. Or maybe Hillary in 2016. Someone has to! I am on the verge of tears right now!! Let's start a Facebook group - Gmail me!
- Zikes 13y ago> Mounting a forceful defence of the NSA, Obama said: "They’re not abusing authorities in order to listen to your private phone calls, or read your emails." Yes, they are. http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/sep/27/nsa-employee-spied-detection-internal-memo http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/sep/27/nsa-employee-sp...
- knowaveragejoe 13y agoJust to play devil's advocate - I think he's talking about the NSA as a whole as a matter of policy, not these notably but otherwise isolated exceptions. It would simply be impractical and largely useless to listen to every average joe's conversations. Also, is there any respite to be had considering the IG was aware of that particular case? Isn't that ideal?
- eliasmacpherson 13y agoWhat's the IG and were they aware of? From what I can see there are no controls in place and the only transgressions that are found out are those that are investigated or freely admitted to.
- knowaveragejoe 13y agoThe Inspector General, in this case of the NSA. Basically an internal watchdog. They were aware of at least 12 cases of abuse according to the article.
- eliasmacpherson 13y agoHow did they come to be aware of them? The information was volunteered or investigations comissioned at the behest of victims.
- knowaveragejoe 13y agoSo... follow through with this. A significant portion of the NSA are abusing their powers to spy on average people?
- liquidise 13y ago"… because nothing in that initial review, and nothing i have learned since, indicated that our intelligence community has sought to violate the law or be cavalier about the civil liberties of their fellow citizens." - Obama I had a very hard time getting past this line he fed at ~11 minutes in. If that is the presumed mindset, you can draw some very broad (and i fear accurate) assumptions about the changes going forward.
- rayiner 13y agoThis isn't a line. Everything I've seen in the leaks indicates an intent by the NSA to try and stay within the contours of the law. They are allowed to collect whatever foreign data they want, and they are, at least based on reasonable interpretations of existing precedents, allowed to collect metadata about phone calls. You can certainly draw assumptions from that: they aren't going to back away from these very reasonable interpretations unless the Supreme Court makes them untenable by, say, rejecting the Third Party Doctrine, but given the law that's on the books, it's accurate to say that what has been leaked is not consistent with the NSA actively seeking to ignore the law.
- pyre 13y agoWhat about the interpretation that something that is illegal for them to do isn't illegal when a machine does it, but only becomes illegal when a human gets involved? E.g. they can collect every detail about a person's life in ways that are normally illegal, but it's ok because no person has looked at the data yet.
- rayiner 13y agoI think that interpretation is very weak, but as far as I can tell, it's not the basis for any of their programs, just an explanation offered to support their minimization procedures, which are probably inadequate. Legally, that seems to be the issue: they have procedures in place to try and only collect foreign data, but American data gets caught up in the net too and their procedures for filtering out American data aren't good enough. That's bad, but I don't think it evinces an intent to actively ignore the law.
- higherpurpose 13y agoBut Internet data is still fair game?
- lvs 13y agoHe boldly took no action to confront a problem he didn't want to confront at a time not of his choosing because of a person he doesn't like.
- herf 13y agoIf data like this requires a bureaucracy to generate, you might be able to protect it with a bureaucracy. If it's collected automatically and stored in one place, it is considerably harder to protect.
- nkvl 13y agoWhy would the executive branch curtail its own power?