8 ms·
I like the use of short 2-5 second videos instead of pictures. They did it tastefully and made it useful. I never thought I'd see a good use case for auto pla
by mrfusion 13y ago
I like the use of short 2-5 second videos instead of pictures. They did it tastefully and made it useful.
I never thought I'd see a good use case for auto playing videos.
(It kind of reminds me of Harry Potter too)
- theallan 13y agoPossibly, although I'm not that keen on my CPU fans spinning up just to scroll through a web-page.
- larrydag 13y agoI wonder if that could be optimized if they were compressed GIFs.
- corresation 13y agoh264 videos are generally significantly smaller than comparable resolution animated GIFs, not to mention being much better quality: It is a very good thing that the era of animated GIFs is drawing to a close, and the pace with which MP4 is supplanting animated GIFs is quickly accelerating. Having said that, an h264 source can have magnitudes more complexity for playback, and generally the greater the compression the higher the playback complexity. Having five or so high profile multi-MB decorative videos autoplaying on a page is excessive. They shouldn't use autoplay. They shouldn't even initialize until scrolled into view. They shouldn't all play at once. Their bandwidth usage is going to be enormous from this HNing, a single page impression pushing 15MB+ (EDIT: I hadn't really delved into it at the time given the display issues, however I grossly underestimated when I said 15MB).
- simoncion 13y agoIf they used GIFs, rather than h264 videos, what would that do to their bandwidth usage? Wouldn't it be substantially higher than if they used videos?
- ricardobeat 13y ago@simoncion you've been hellbanned in this thread for some reason.
- simoncion 13y agoThanks for the heads-up. Not that I want to learn anything about HN's ban system, but it's interesting to see that the hellbanhammer can be wielded on a per-thread basis.
- boristhespider 13y agoApparently [1] MP4s (at least their file sizes) can be optimized much more than animated GIFs, although it doesn't seem like that's been fully done here. [1] http://gfycat.com/about http://gfycat.com/about
- corresation 13y agoOn a well-equipped i7 Windows 7 x64 machine, this web page brought Chrome 32 to an absolute crawl.
- ANH 13y agoWorks great on a i7 Ubuntu 13.10 x64 machine under Chrome 31.
- XorNot 13y agoi5 Mint 16 with Chrome 31 - worked great, no fan speed ups for anything.
- jrabone 13y agoWorked well for me on same hardware / software - suggest your video drivers aren't, er, driving...
- corresation 13y agoFWIW it runs fine on Chrome Canary (currently 34). CPU/GPU is still excessive for videos that people might not even want to see, but the videos all run smoothly and the browser remains responsive. Not sure what the Chrome difference is for that.
- simoncion 13y agoIt works just fine for me on Chromium 31 and Chrome 32 on Linux, using the open-source Radeon drivers. It would be interesting to see what the common factors for others who are reporting poor performance is.
- kdot 13y agoWorked so well that I didn't even realize this was video, thought they were GIFs
- 13y ago
- bluefinity 13y agoOh, I was wondering what those were. They just appear as black boxes on my tablet. I guess they're flash?
- davb 13y agoMP4 using HTML5 <video> tags.
- peterclary 13y agoWhat's your tablet?
- bluefinity 13y agoNexus 7 (2013) -- running Android 4.4.
- corresation 13y agoDifferent person, but the videos do not load in either the iPad (iOS7) or Nexus 7 (Android 4.4) for me. As mentioned in another post, the content-type being returned is wrong for video/mp4, at least from the S3 servers I am hitting. Perhaps this varies and is correct for some, but it seems to be the reason for so many varied experiences -- some clients just ignore it, others seem to choose render paths based upon it, and others refuse the content because of it.
- teh_klev 13y agoI'd rather I it didn't auto-play and let me choose whether I want a page to swamp my bandwidth and CPU. Even over an 8Mb/s ADSL connection on a quad core Xeon workstation with 12GB or RAM and fairly decent video card this page is one of the worst behaved I've encountered in a while. Sadly I won't be reading any of the content because even after five minutes it's killing my browser. To the spark.io blogging team, please don't assume unlimited wads of broadband. Let the reader decide whether they want to play your videos, and you know, I can only watch one video at a time on that page, so why start them all playing at once? This is no better etiquette than CNN or MSNBC or an adware farm where they start playing videos at you upon arrival. It's very rude.
- pacmon 13y agoI'd have to agree. It's not the bandwidth that was the issue though. All those videos loading and playing at once crushed my poor browser (Waterfox 24) until I was able to slowly pause them one by one. This does, however, work mostly smooth on my version of Chrome (32).
- theon144 13y agoFirefox 26 with a shit-ton of privacy-related plugins on a budget $350 desktop, no slow-down at all.
- zsupalla 13y agoPerformance issues are resolved, now the site only plays the videos that are on-screen.
- kmfrk 13y agoIndeed; autoplay=true is stupid, but on the other hand, it's quite remarkable how it manage to bring my desktop PC to its knees. Maybe using whatever https://mediacru.sh/ https://mediacru.sh/ returns instead will help.
- Kliment 13y agoBluekitten, you are hellbanned for no apparent reason as of 21 days ago.
- ddoolin 13y agoAgreed. I had to open the source and see what they were using. Native video elements...I like it. I figured it was a nice GIF or something. Not sure what the others guy are talking about. Works fine on my MacBook Pro...not issues at all?
- selectodude 13y agoSame with Safari 7 on my MacBook Pro. Worked a treat, was a super cool concept. I'm surprised to see all the complaints with Chrome, I always took that browser to have the best support for this kind of stuff.
- ddoolin 13y agoI'm using Chrome and it works just fine. I'm actually quite curious what's causing the negative experience across equally capable machines.
- simoncion 13y agoMe too! I'm using Chromum 31 and Chrome 32 on Linux with old open-source Radeon-HD drivers, and ran that page without issue. shrug
- corresation 13y agoA different video card, codec chain, and on and on, can yield a very experience. Being an early adopter of many Harry Potter-esque moving pictures can yield nice content, but it will invariably cause client issues. As I mentioned in another post, it works fine in Chrome 34 on the same hardware that it struggles dramatically with in Chrome 32. Both of them have hardware decoding enabled, and so on. The Chrome 32 instance has no problems at all playing video anywhere else. Indeed, on that same line, the videos don't load at all on Chrome on the Nexus 5. The N5 of course supports h264, and has no problem on any other site that I've ever discovered. Maybe their server is now overloaded (EDIT: Okay they're using S3....going to be an ugly bandwidth bill from that...and it's fully responsive), but it also doesn't load on the iPad 3rd generation running iOS 7. Again just black boxes. EDIT: I wonder if it's because they're (s3) setting the content type to octet-stream, rather than video/mp4. Some clients seem to be going on alternate decode paths or are refusing to display it because of that. e.g. Content-Length:6915107 Content-Range:bytes 0-6915106/6915107 Content-Type:application/octet-stream There's a lesson in here somewhere.
- adventureloop 13y agoI like the idea, but the moving images in my eye line as I tried to read made me feel really queasy.
- pistle 13y agoAutoplay has been the devil for 15 years in UI. You don't repeat animation and you don't auto-start it unless that is the expected primary feature of the landing page.
- zz1 13y agoThank you for your comment: it allowed me to understand that the empy blocks I was seeing were meant to be videos (Firefox user here). It's sad to find out that they ignored that mp4 isn't supported by all browsers. I know: HTML5 video is just a PITA, and that's indeed a reason why so many still rely on gifs. I hope this project grows, and that they will care a bit more than they did here.
- michaelt 13y agoWorks for me on Firefox 26.0 on Ubuntu?
- maxerickson 13y agoFirefox only supports platform codecs for mp4. So, for instance, it doesn't work on XP.
- zz1 13y agoNeither on OS X
- cabalamat 13y ago> I like the use of short 2-5 second videos instead of pictures. I utterly disliked it. It made my browser slow and so I didn't read their page.
- rlpb 13y agoSo that's why I had a bunch of random gaps. Poor degradation to those of us running NoScript, there.
- jonathansizz 13y agoIf you run a browser extension that breaks the web, the web breaks. Maybe try something like DoNotTrackMe instead?
- FatalBaboon 13y agoI opened the page with Firefox and my (reasonably powerful) laptop started overheating instantly. Opening the page via eww in EMACS made it readable since it doesn't load videos if I don't ask it to.
- MereInterest 13y agoAs someone who often browses over remote desktop, it gets quite frustrating, since all of the sudden my connection, which is fast enough for static text, freezes.
- lukejduncan 13y agoI actually really disliked this. Too distracting for me. Maybe my tastes will change over time - but I stopped reading because I couldn't concentrate on the text.