7 ms·
How the Drug War Disappeared the Jury Trial
- will_brown 13y agoI thought this was an interesting article, but the following jumped out at me: >Ronald Thompson’s case, and so many others, reveals that prosecutors don’t think that twenty-year sentences for shooting into the ground constitute justice. Why else would the plea bargain stay on the table. The reason (in a majority of cases) plea bargains stay on the table is not because the prosecutors don't think the mandatory minimums constitute justice, rather the prosecutors do not have an incentive or otherwise want to go to trial. Therefore, they dangle the carrot and stick in front of the defendant (e.g. in this case, take 3 years or roll the dice and if convicted serve the minimum 20). So why don't prosecutors want to go to trial? Because the have extremely large case loads, they could not possibly take them all to trial, but to even take one to trial requires exponentially more work than getting the defendant to accept a plea. Additionally, if a prosecutor does all the extra work required with going to trial (win or lose) they do not get paid for all the extra work.
- res0nat0r 13y ago> Why else would the plea bargain stay on the table. > So why don't prosecutors want to go to trial? Because the have extremely large case loads, ... These two items can both be true in the eyes of the prosecutor yes?
- TeMPOraL 13y agoThe problem appears when no. 2 is true, but no. 1 is not. Now we have a conflict of interests.
- elipsey 13y agoI gather that in some legal systems, the German system for example, mandatory prosecution of every crime is required because of this problem. It seems worthwhile to ask what a good incentive for prosecutors would look like. For example, an incentive that rewards winning a trial more strongly than excepting a plea.
- iwwr 13y agoThe penalties are just too large and so very few are risking going to trial. Also, if prosecutors were actually forced to prosecute every case in court, it would either block the criminal justice system, or force politicians to drastically reduce penalties (and look "soft on crime").
- warfangle 13y agoOr dramatically increase taxes in order to pay for more prosecutors and judges and courtrooms.
- bradleyjg 13y agoFrom friends in state prosecutors offices in a couple of states, I understand that there is a professional incentive to try cases on a fairly regular basis. Even though the office as a whole benefits from plea bargains, it's trial work that is apparently most respected and taken into consideration for promotions and the like. I personally find the German system preferable, I think there is something very sick about a system that has so many cases it is in danger of collapsing under its own weight. Rather than striving for efficiency short cuts, like rampent plea bargaining accomplished via the lever of over harsh trial sentences, we should step back and figure out why there are so many alleged criminals to begin with.
- pyre 13y ago> why there are so many alleged criminals to begin with. Obviously because we're not being harsh enough on them! /s
- awjr 13y agoI'm guessing due to prohibition aka War on Drugs. I'm rather in favour of legalising and taxing all drugs. Then releasing all prisoners convicted on drug possession/supply.
- socialist_coder 13y agoI'm an American living in Germany now but I have no clue what the German system is. Can you enlighten me or share a link that explains it well?
- rhizome 13y agoAs the Kelly Thomas case illustrates, it's also possible that some prosecutors are not good at winning jury trials. Additionally, if a prosecutor does all the extra work required with going to trial (win or lose) they do not get paid for all the extra work. So much for civic duty. :/
- vdaniuk 13y agoI really can't imagine a prosecutor to be compassionate or caring for civic duty.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoWhich explains why prosecutors tend to be extremely vindictive when they are forced to take a case to trial, seeking extreme sentences which pervert justice (but which also serve to further encourage other defendants to pursue plea bargains).
- wavefunction 13y ago"vindictive" sounds nothing like "professional"
- smsm42 13y agoAnd they have extremely large case loads because Congress creates over 60 new federal crimes every year, and because the same prosecutors prosecute thousands of acts that harm nobody and should not be prosecuted. If they were made to actually work for prosecuting them, then maybe they would wake up to the reality of over-criminalization and asked for a reform. However, if they can just make a conveyor belt type system where they just can quickly extort plea bargains and move on, of course no problem for them.
- joshontheweb 13y ago60 a year? really? Im genuinely interested in this. do you have a source?
- smsm42 13y agohttp://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2008/06/revisiting-the-explosive-growth-of-federal-crimes http://www.heritage.org/research/reports/2008/06/revisiting-... I miscalculated the average a bit: it's 56.5 per year, not 60 (I thought it is 7 year period but it was 8 years). The growth of federal crimes continues unabated. The increase of 452 over the eight-year period between 2000 and 2007 averages 56.5 crimes per year-roughly the same rate at which Congress created new crimes in the 1980s and 1990s.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- unabridged 13y agoThe most important check on prosecutorial power is the grand jury, where they decide whether or not a prosecutor can even bring charges against someone. But in the last 100 years the power of the grand jury has been dissolved entirely and now merely exists as a tool of the prosecutor.
- rayiner 13y agoI can't stress enough how damaging the drug war has been to our justice system. It's not only unfair to the (mostly poor minorities) that get caught up in the war, but is unfair to everyone else that receives slower service from the federal court system as a result of dockets clogged with drug cases. That said, the lede of the article is dumb. The article complains about the drug war and plea bargaining, but Ronald Thompson's plight is not the result of those things, but rather of an overzealous gun control law: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/10-20-Life http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/10-20-Life. Under this Florida law, the fact that Thompson fired a gun during what was otherwise a felony assault resulted in a mandatory 20 year sentence. Indeed, the fact that many people who would otherwise oppose the drug war support gun control laws like this shows a deeper problem with American society than just the drug war. Whether we're calling for longer prison sentences for bankers or people convicted of gun crimes, we just love putting people in prison.
- gamacodre 13y ago> we just love putting people in prison. I think this is happening because of a general perception that too many people are "getting away" with breaking the law. It doesn't seem to matter that we're criminalizing everyday life and that many of the folks who actually deserve these penalties are untouchable due to money or politics, the sense of injustice is enough to make you want to just clamp down on everything. This means that for the few people that can exercise influence over the police and judicial system, the upside (votes, funding, whatever) from damaging it further far outweighs the miniscule chance that they themselves will get caught up in its workings. It seems like it's caught in a death spiral. And it bothers me tremendously that, as a decent guy, I'm actively afraid of our judicial system.
- rayiner 13y agoThere's no reason to turn everything into some "untouchable due to money or politics" angle. There is a simple reason why people perceive that harsh response to crime is necessary: http://www.volokh.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/vcrime500.jpg http://www.volokh.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/vcrime500.j.... The violent crime rate in the U.S. peaked in the early 1990's at about five times the per capita rate in 1960. Florida's law was passed in 1997 or so.
- tethis 13y agoWe just had a ruling a couple months ago, up here in Canada, that a 3-year mandatory minimum sentence involve possession of a loaded firearm was unconstitutional as it is considered "cruel and unusual punishment". Is such a challenge possible in the USA?
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoNope. The US justice system is simply insane, and I've no idea what will bring it back.
- davorak 13y ago> Nope. I am missing a legal nuance? It seems like a challenge along these lines is possible but unlikely to go very far.
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoIt's possible in the sense that you can submit anything you want. It's not possible in the sense that it'll be dismissed out of hand.
- nknighthb 13y agoThe Supreme Court has upheld three strikes laws that put people in prison for life for low-value non-violent thefts. No number of years for a crime, no matter how minor, seems to be too much. The only challenges that succeed are challenges to unusual applications of the death penalty.
- genwin 13y agoWell 3 years of imprisonment and torture before an indictment isn't considered unconstitutional in the US, apparently (e.g. José Padilla). So we're a long way from Canada's state of enlightenment.
- KaiserPro 13y agoI know this is pernicious, but I'd suggest that disappeared isn't a verb
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoI think that it is. http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/disappeared http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/disappeared
- syllogism 13y agoSurely you mean isn't a transitive verb? Anyway, it's rare but well attested: https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=disappeared+it&year_start=1800&year_end=2000&corpus=15&smoothing=3&share=&direct_url=t1%3B%2Cdisappeared%20it%3B%2Cc0 https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=disappeared+it...
- DavidWoof 13y agoCheck the details on that ngram, it doesn't capture "disappeared" as a transitive verb. Virtually all the examples are variations on "Once the item had disappeared, it was never seen again."
- dragonwriter 13y ago“Disappeared” in the sense used here refers to domestic opponents being covertly kidnapped—and usually murdered—by their governments; a usage that originated in connection with Argentina's “Dirty War”, but which has been used for many other situations since. The use of “disappeared” this way here I would say I is very conscious commentary in itself.
- testrun 13y agoIt is, for instance 'he disappeared into the night', but how it is used here sounds strange to me.
- pyre 13y agoIt's used in the same sense that people would say that the KGB 'disappeared' people.
- higherpurpose 13y agoThis is why bad laws must be fought hard before they get passed. Because after, people forget about them, since "it doesn't directly apply to them", and they remain as laws for decades, ruining many people's lives. I also find the American system of adding up charges incredibly stupid, and extremely easy to abuse by prosecutors, way more than any positives it may have (although I think he has none, especially with such high minimum sentences for most crimes).
- ihnorton 13y agoFor example, when United States Army veteran Ronald Thompson fired two warning shots into the ground, he intended to scare off his friend’s grandson, who was attempting to enter her home after she denied him entry. He never imagined his actions would leave him facing decades in prison. So, `stand your ground` only kicks in when the purported assailant is shot dead? Words fail.
- InclinedPlane 13y ago"Stand your ground" isn't magic, it's a legal defense like any other. Everything hinges on what the jury finds, and in this case it seems as though the prosecutor was persuasive. Also, if you mean to draw a comparison to the Trayvon Martin case, "stand your ground" wasn't relevant to that case.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- wavefunction 13y agoThe Stand Your Ground laws are highly relevant to the Trayvon Martin case, since they provided cover for local law enforcement to initially decide they wouldn't be pursuing any charges against Zimmerman. Which led to the outrage and the public court trial.
- commandar 13y agoThe SYG statutes I'm familiar with only apply if you would be legally justified in using deadly force. Warning shots generally don't meet that standard. EDIT: Which is to say, the bar is usually something like reasonable belief that your life or the life of someone present is in imminent danger.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoQuite so. Warning shots are never a good idea. The 20 year prison term was nevertheless not warranted. Had he been a gang banger convicted of an actual homicide he would, on average, have gotten a lighter sentence.
- woah 13y agoWhat kind of evil motivates these prosecutors? These people are a danger to the community.
- midas007 13y agoStats, for one. And possibly getting re-elected.
- llamataboot 13y agoIncidentally, this is one reason why some activists insist on jury trials for even the smallest forms of civil disobedience. We have created a system that /counts on/ the fact that most cases will never go to trial. Insisting on a trial is one way to use significant resources of that system to make a political point.
- tob_h 13y agoThe linked site as is (whether intentional or not) contains an annoying spam script that periodically redirects to some spam game on the iOS AppStore. I can't find a "flag" or "report spam" link, though, which is why I'm posting this as a comment.
- smoyer 13y agoInteresting article but not so surprising after the revelations of how Aaron Swartz was harassed. More interesting (to me) is that using "disappeared" as a verb (in this tense) has made it to the headline of an article.