3 ms·
> why the hell they aren't raising that money by, perhaps, taxing Google. Perhaps because Google hides most of its income from the US and California government
by falcolas 13y ago
> why the hell they aren't raising that money by, perhaps, taxing Google.
Perhaps because Google hides most of its income from the US and California governments through various international subsidaries.
And perhaps also because the moment they worked around all these loopholes and actually started to get money out of Google, Google would simply up and move away, making things worse.
Google, Twitter, and companies in general, should have some duty to their communities, if only out of gratitude for providing an environment in which they could thrive. That they don't speaks volumes on their corporate values.
Personally, I think it's a problem with the "profit for shareholders above all else" which dominates the discussions about corporate values.
- Crito 13y agoThey may be hiding most of their international income in Ireland or wherever, but San Francisco does not need access to most of their income, do they? Tax the portion that they are able to tax. If the tax avoidance becomes or is excessive, you refocus your efforts above local government to seek a solution. "If we increase taxes they'll leave, so there is no point even trying" is a defeatist attitude. And assuming that is how Google really does operate, then expecting charity from Google is ludicrous anyway. (And you are still ignoring the fact that Google is not in a position to do anything besides provide money anyway. Your local government is the one that can actually do something with that money to combat this problem.)
- greg83 13y ago"They may be hiding most of their international income in Ireland" Bermuda[1]. Google does its best to avoid paying tax in Ireland too. [1] http://arstechnica.com/business/2013/10/to-reduce-its-tax-burden-google-expands-use-of-the-double-irish/ http://arstechnica.com/business/2013/10/to-reduce-its-tax-bu...
- eloff 13y agoIt's a competitive environment, you take every advantage you can get, because so will the other guys. A public company in case you forgot is an institution designed to create value for share holders. So the fault is not with these companies but squarely on the idiotic governments with their ridiculous tax codes. They deserve everything they get as, to a lesser extent, do the people who vote for them.
- dictum 13y ago> A public company in case you forgot is an institution designed to create value for share holders. I don't know much about US law regarding this, but I thought the only thing a public company shouldn't do is destroy value. I don't think a company has the obligation to specifically pursue the cheapest/fastest way to do something. Directors and executives have some freedom to run things as they see fit, but won't abuse their freedom to not be voted out of the company; not because the courts would punish them for it.
- dkuntz2 13y agoA public company's only goal is to create value for its share holders. While I personally believe things should be different, they aren't. A company that doesn't make money is useless to it's shareholders, and typically shareholders vote to make sure a company makes as much money as possible. There is no natural pressure on a company to care about other things, which is why we have laws to try to get them to care a little bit.