2 ms·
"I'm not interested in rehashing those emotional arguments" A nice attempt to inoculate your argument against reasons you don't like, but not relevant - the ar
by onion2k 13y ago
"I'm not interested in rehashing those emotional arguments"
A nice attempt to inoculate your argument against reasons you don't like, but not relevant - the argument against what the NSA has done is emotional, specifically ethical, and you can't just dismiss that offhand by saying you're not interested.
Quite possibly limitations on further actions from the NSA, and GCHQ in my country, will put our respective nations at a disadvantage economically, strategically, and industrially, but that disadvantage is considerably less important than the freedom of citizens to live without oppression.
To wander freely down the argument ad absurdum road: should a government decide to enslave its entire population in forced labour camps so they could proudly say they're a global economic superpower, that would be wrong, even if other nations did it as well.
- anigbrowl 13y agoEthics are not a subset of emotions.
- dmschulman 13y agoI think we'd all agree that the information we've learned since June is "upsetting". I make that distinction in my thread because I want to have a rational conversation about the NSA as a tool of the state and not devolve into the simplistic responses: "NSA bad!"