3 ms·
Toast might not be 'worth' $4 to you, and certainly the raw materials of toast don't cost $4, but that doesn't mean it doesn't provide $4 of value to the person
by onion2k 13y ago
Toast might not be 'worth' $4 to you, and certainly the raw materials of toast don't cost $4, but that doesn't mean it doesn't provide $4 of value to the person buying it. That's what you have to measure. To me, a good cup of coffee and a nice breakfast in a quiet cafe with friendly staff is worth at least $4. And I choose to spend my money that way.
Valuing toast especially highly is not the problem with the tech industry.
The problem is inequality. While tech generates huge returns for investors people in tech will earn a lot. What needs to happen is that money paid needs to be spent - on toast or anything really - rather than being further invested. By spending, money moves around the system, gets taxed, gets redistributed between everyone relatively fairly. If tech workers earn more than they can reasonably spend then they end up investing it in houses and companies, meaning the money stays with the few and pushes the poles apart - the poor get poorer and the rich get richer. That's the problem.
If everyone bought $4 toast then all the coffeeshop workers would earn more and the tech workers would have less to spend on houses. That would be a good thing.
- oleganza 13y agoLets also not forget that Fed prints tens of billions of dollars per month. All this money has to go somewhere and today a good chunk of it goes to all sorts of investors buying stocks and pre-IPO shares of tech startups. That's the only logical explanation for crazy valuation of profitless Twitter, Instagram, Snapchat and others. Also, the only explanation for why most people producing real goods on factories and farms in US and all over the world are getting poorer while guys coding services that waste money for years still get huge salaries. I'm not saying that all of Silicon Valley is producing worthless stuff. I'm saying there is a distortion on the market caused by "free money" (compared to money that has to be saved and withdrawn from others, less profitable activities). Without it SV would still be a great and pricey place, but not hugely at the expense of everyone else like it is today. PS. Before we start a flame about "crazy libertarians", consider what's more crazy: me questioning Fed's policies, or the fact that war in Iraq costed $6 trillion and killed 1 mln people (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_cost_of_the_Iraq_War http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_cost_of_the_Iraq_War). That wouldn't be possible at all if the Fed couldn't create money out of thin air. Once you deal with morality of this situation, only then please criticize me about my opinion on QE and other monetary policies in general.
- BadassFractal 13y agoMan, think of everybody else we could blame for this. Why limit it to just the Fed? Let's be more generous. The 1%, the poor, the black, the racists, the gays, the Jews, the immigrants, the socialists, the liberals, the neo-cons, the Kochs, the healthcare cartels. Everybody's at fault.
- w0utert 13y agoThat's a bit of disingenuous strawman comment. No matter what you think about the price of coffee and toast in SF, you'd have to be blind, in denial, or suffer from amnesia if you think valuations of stocks in general and tech stocks in particular are based on anything else but free money funneled into a system that would collapse without it.
- justincormack 13y agoThis fairy story about all the money coming from the Fed's printing press is basically a misunderstanding. The money was all created by the banking system via leverage before the bubble, and the Fed basically stopped all that money being destroyed at once via defaults. letting the people who got the money created (printed if you like) by the private sector keep it.
- oleganza 13y agoAs far as I know, Fed prints around $80 billion since 2012 and does it today. All this money does not just sit somewhere, but is being "invested" to "stimulate the economy". Sources are listed here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantitative_easing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantitative_easing Then, you ignored the fact that existing Fed policy made possible murder of 1 million people over several years at a cost of $6 million per person. There were no taxpayers or private investors who'd save that much money to invest in a large scale murder operation. It was all possible because of Fed, legal tender laws and tons of regulations that make sure people have to accept USD as money. I think it is important to understand that to see the power that the Fed has and how much lives are affected by that power. It just gives the proper context.
- r0h1n 13y ago> If everyone bought $4 toast then all the coffeeshop workers would earn more and the tech workers would have less to spend on houses. That would be a good thing. No offense but that's just naive and wishful thinking. Instead, the increased prices would inflate corporate profits even more without having any impact on real wages: http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2013/05/05/wages-job-growth/2134207/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2013/05/05/wage...
- yummyfajitas 13y agoTech workers funneling high wages into consumption (thereby raising prices) is precisely what all the people whining about the changing character of SF are complaining about. Consumption simply does not reduce income inequality. All it does is reduce wealth inequality (since a dollar spent is a dollar not invested) while increasing consumption inequality. And consumption inequality is what most of the anti-tech activists are complaining about.
- sanoli 13y ago> To me, a good cup of coffee and a nice breakfast in a quiet cafe with friendly staff is worth at least $4. Sure, but that's based on what you earn. If you earned a quarter of what you earn now, would it still be worth 4 dollars? Plus, if everyone bought $4 toast, the cafe's that cater to the wealthy would soon have $8 toast.