3 ms·
Calling the posters propaganda would be true before 2001, but today I would not call it that. They simply represent a simplification of how an NK conflict with
by belorn 13y ago
Calling the posters propaganda would be true before 2001, but today I would not call it that. They simply represent a simplification of how an NK conflict with the U.S. army would look like.
For example, U.S. Soldiers don't use pliers for torture. They chain civilians to prison ceilings instead and beat them to death. Alternative they use simulated executions, rape, or sodomized civilians like in Abu Ghraib.
The posters about U.S. soldier executing Korean civilians is also a bit off. Using guns to terrorize a population is slow and ineffective, as a 24/7 aerial presence that can at any point send a explosive missile (like onto a wedding) will have better effected on the population.
Not that it takes anything away from the message the documentary gives. Seeing how bad NK has become is important, as most people seem to think that all that horribleness went away after ww2/cold world.
- tptacek 13y agoInteresting. What other North Korean state messages do you believe to be, at root, basically true and honest?
- belorn 13y agoInteresting question. Just my belief here, but I would think that a violent paranoid state with multiple grave human rights violations has likely a few enemies in the world. As such, several countries would likely feel much safer without the current government in NK.
- steveklabnik 13y agoThe state-run media actually puts out their daily articles in English, they're pretty interesting to actually read. Here's an example, from today: http://rodong.rep.kp/en/index.php?strPageID=SF01_02_01&newsID=2014-01-15-0006&chAction=T http://rodong.rep.kp/en/index.php?strPageID=SF01_02_01&newsI... > Above all, one must learn to see through the true nature of the freedom > and democracy of the Western style. In a word, it is a sham democracy > and sham freedom. They are but a fig-leaf to cover up the reactionary > nature of bourgeois dictatorship and anti-popular character of the > capitalist system. > > Much vaunted democracy of American pattern is no more than a slogan > for world supremacy, aggression and intervention. And their so-called > freedom gives a handful of the privileged a free hand to squeeze and > lord it over the majority of the popular masses. I don't find this to be too particularly different from what many in our Left say, except maybe in degree. I remember reading another one recently discussing poverty statistics put out by our government, and they were source accurate. You just won't hear our media saying "16 million children live in food-insecure households," generally speaking. The spin is different, but the numbers are the same. I'm not saying that I find broad agreement with the DPRK, but I do think that I tend to _also_ read what they have to say about news stories that involve, and it's fascinating.
- tptacek 13y agoThe Nazis also had some mean things to say about the US, too.
- belorn 13y agoAnd? Just the regular "the nazis is bad, so what ever comment I now associate with it must be equally bad"? Okey, lets talk about Nazis and World War 2. If the US would had used torture, strip searches at the border, and a spy in every product and phone, I am sure the Nazis would have a bunch to say about the US. Their news information about bombings of civilian targets was surely not too far off from the truth (the US used the same old argument that the enemy are hiding under hospitals, schools and weddings then as now). But thats all ancient history. Instead Lets ask us a simple question: If you were a POW, under which countries would you fear for your life? The U.S. Is to me on that list, which has some clear implication on the words like freedom, democracy and "the good side".
- tptacek 13y agoGiven a choice between being a POW in the US or NK, your choice would be a coin flip?
- belorn 13y agoPlease don't try use informal fallacies as a way to move the discussion. Such arguments do not belong here, do not become you, and when ever one is written a kitten cries somewhere in the world. If my choice is between being a POW under the "care" of US, NK, China, Russia, Belgium, Norway and Iceland, I would not pick the US. Would you? Why asking such questions when the answer is obvious? It doesn't contribute anything to a civil discussion. If the choice is between a country that torture, and a country that do not, the choice is obvious. If one is asked to pick between two countries that both perform torture, the obvious answer is to not pick either. The US has condone acts of torture. When it has not condone it officially, they often refused to use the full force of the law against people who has committed illegal, immoral, and plain evil acts against prisoners and civilians. Read the legal actions against those responsible for the Abu Ghraib torture, and compare that to trials of personal who participated in Nazi army and conducted similar act of torture and violent acts. How many people in the world has just got a few years in prison for pleading guilty to torture, in a place which deaths was ruled as homicide from torture?
- elipsey 13y agoThese are good points. I suppose I was referring to the style and motivation of the material rather than it's factual content. Must propaganda be factually false or grossly misleading? I don't know...