7 ms·
What's expected of us
- pattisapu 13y agoTed Chiang's Predictor would be quite the expansion pack for Hermann Hesse's Glass Bead Game.
- svermeulen 13y agoAnyone that liked this should definitely check this one as well by the same author: http://infinityplus.co.uk/stories/under.htm http://infinityplus.co.uk/stories/under.htm
- friendcomputer 13y agoI highly recommend Ted Chiang. I really enjoyed "Story of your Life" available in this short story collection of the same name: http://www.amazon.com/Stories-Your-Life-Others-Chiang/dp/1931520720 http://www.amazon.com/Stories-Your-Life-Others-Chiang/dp/193... Some of the stuff is a but uneven but he's written some of the most thought-provoking sci-fi I've read in some time.
- pattisapu 13y agoLooks like "Story of Your Life" is going to be made into a movie. http://www.tor.com/blogs/2013/10/ted-chiang-story-of-your-life-film-adaptation http://www.tor.com/blogs/2013/10/ted-chiang-story-of-your-li...
- friendcomputer 13y agoHmm. I'd like to say I'm excited but I really don't see how they will capture that story effectively in film.
- dvanduzer 13y agoI last heard his name when a good friend recommended "Hell is the Absence of God" to me. I later tried to recommend it to my mother, but found myself incapable of doing so.
- lmm 13y agoCan you explain Story of your Life? To me it just doesn't make sense, our consciousnesses don't work like that - which undermines any point it might be making.
- eloff 13y agoThe predictor already exists, there's a common FMRI experiment in neuroscience where with about 80% accuracy the scientists can predict you're about to push the button about one second before you decide to do it. Someone no doubt will post a link, I don't have time to Google it now. I'm guessing it's the inspiration for this story. I'm more curious about what you guys think. I've long thought the arguments against free will are much stronger than those for it, but it's an unsettling idea to live with.
- dangrossman 13y agoIt'd be a "predictor" if an FMRI could predict that the neurons are about to light up a second before that happens, rather than just measure the delay between neuron activity and conscious perception or conscious motor control. Regardless, if anyone finds the thought that an FMRI can detect you making a decision a significant amount of time before you're aware of making that decision particularly interesting, this book dives into that research and much more about the nature of consciousness from a neuroscience and information theory POV: http://www.amazon.com/The-User-Illusion-Cutting-Consciousness/dp/0140230122 http://www.amazon.com/The-User-Illusion-Cutting-Consciousnes...
- diydsp 13y agoYes, loved the User Illusion. Fascinating Stuff. Also, lately I've been hearing a lot about http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Happiness_Hypothesis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Happiness_Hypothesis in which the brain is likened to a person riding and elephant. We can train the elephant, but mostly the elephant repeats its program. It's billed as about "happiness," but imo that's only one slice of it. It applies to all habits, including eating, exercise, improving sw development skills...
- dullcrisp 13y agoInteresting. If the observers were to play a distracting tone every time they predicted that you were about to decide to press the button, would you never experience deciding to press the button?
- return0 13y ago
- sarreph 13y agoI love pieces of writing like this. Determinism isn't something I've explored quite satisfactorily enough just yet, and reading articles such as this one sends me straight back into the depths of the literature.
- rzimmerman 13y agoThis reminds me of the Isaac Asimov spoof article "The Endochronic Properties of Resublimated Thiotimoline" which describes "experiments" on a substance that reacts so aggressively with water that it reacts before the water is added. Can't find the text unfortunately, but Wikipedia has a summary: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thiotimoline http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thiotimoline
- troymc 13y agoI just read about that in Asimov's autobiography. He wrote it when he was a grad student at Columbia and was worried that it (a satire of chemistry papers) might harm his chances of passing his final (oral) PhD examination. His examiners never mentioned it until the very end... when one asked him what he knew about resublimated thiotimoline, at which time Asimov burst out in a fit of nervous laughter. He passed.
- _sabe_ 13y agoEven if we were free thinking individuals, able to make rational decisions on our own, we base those decisions on past events and the current situation. So even if you get to choose, you'd probably make the same rational choices as long as your past experience and the environment is the same. This would be true one second ago, and a second ago this would be true about the second before that.
- mnemonicsloth 13y agoHere's a similar appearance by Vernor Vinge: http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v407/n6805/full/407679a0.html http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v407/n6805/full/407679a...
- throwaway7808 13y agoThat reminds me of Feynman's Thesis and his (failed) attempt to build his Feynman's Radio...
- jaw 13y agoSadly we're not informed what happens if you program a robot to press the button at fixed intervals unless it observes a flash.
- dullcrisp 13y agoOr, for that matter, a human.
- ksmiley 13y agoSome simple resolutions would be: a freak lightning strike disables the robot's button-pressing hardware. Or a cosmic ray flips a bit in its machine code, causing it to shut down. Or the robot's designer suffers a heart attack before turning it on. These may seem like contrived examples, but when you eliminate all outcomes that aren't self-consistent, it may be that _all_ the remaining possibilities are contrived. Probability gets weird when time travel is involved.
- jrlocke 13y agoDoes such a detector imply that there is no freewill? Would determinism imply it? Imagine the predictor works, what does that mean? One second prior to the action, the course you would take is set. This is actually probably a point in favor of the possibility of freewill; humans are course-taking machines, we have a whole life (and our evolution before that) to acquire dispositions that will one day help us survive. What kind of freewill do we want? Do we want to be "free to dodge a brick when thrown at us" or "free, one second before the brick arrives, to duck or not duck". Which of these is the important one? The kind of freewill we really want isn't the kind where we are free floating actors, it is the kind where our history, personal and evolutionary, dictates our present. The point is, real freedom is not about being without limits, it is about having sensible responses to ones environment; creatures evolve the freedom to avoid being eaten, the freedom to anticipate others' actions, the freedom to manipulate other agents with our clever words. Dan Dennett makes a better case for this than I, please look into his wonderful books on the topic. Daniel Dennett: --Elbow Room --Freedom Evolves
- gbrandt 13y agoRelevant: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timequake http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timequake
- marmaduke 13y agoThis is known in the dynamical systems literature as strong anticipation: http://digital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/7493/2/Dynamical_mechanism.pdf http://digital.csic.es/bitstream/10261/7493/2/Dynamical_mech... http://www.haskins.yale.edu/Reprints/HL1521.pdf http://www.haskins.yale.edu/Reprints/HL1521.pdf
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- poorelise 13y agoI think you are fooling yourself by constructing a more complex scenario that is therefore more impenetrable. The story already says that the light flashes one second before you press the button, or rather no matter how hard you try, you can't press the button sooner than one second after the flash - consequently you wouldn't be able to knock the device away. You could already say "if the light flashes, you press the button within 0.5 seconds, therefore the story can't be true". But the story says you can't do that. So by inventing your mechanical device you haven't added any information to the puzzle, only confusion. I think Searle's Chinese Rooms employs the same fallacious way of thinking to refute strong AI.
- tomp 13y agoOh my... another meditation on the issue of free will, and the existential angst we would experience if we learned that our choices are deterministic. Personally, however, I think that the whole question of free-will vs. determinism is a false dilemma. For me, another issue is more important: Determinism vs. randomness. If my choices are not deterministic, they must be random. I would rather be deterministic than random. In any case, if they are random, it means that I don't have free will either. I like to think that all my choices are a result of the past; my genetics, my childhood upbringing (that I don't even remember, but which formed the neural pathways in my brain), my early memories, my environment, education, experiences, friends, knowledge that I have absorbed from the world... In each and every moment, I make a choice, which is the best choice I can make given my brain power/structure, my motivations and the external constraints given (is it raining? can I fly? when do I need to pay the rent). Even my motivations are largely determined by my genetics - avoid pain, strive for pleasure. I definitely hope that my choices are not random. How does morality come into play, if our choices are deterministic? It doesn't - my morality is my internal concept that I use to make choices more quickly/easily. I don't impose my morality on other people and I don't really care how they make their choices, but I support different forms of punishment that modify the incentives of other people so that the society can function. Finally, I don't think that the future is predictable, even though it is deterministic. Like you don't know what 1048936701349 * 13046871435 is before you calculate it, like even the computer cannot predict the result before calculating it (i.e. the fastest calculation algorithm is also the fastest prediction algorithm), the same way we cannot predict the future before it happens, i.e. before the universe "calculates" it.
- jey 13y agoYou seem to be assuming that "random" must mean "uniformly at random". A weighted die that 99.99999% of the time comes up "3" is still random, but not uniformly random. The outcome of the die roll is nearly certain.
- hmsimha 13y agoI think you misunderstood tomp's message. Certainly they didn't mean to imply there was the chance our actions are uniformly random. Rather, the question seems to be whether there is a truly random component to our decisions. The dichotomy lies in the contrast between determinism and the possibility of a truly random quantam process.
- warcode 13y agoI'd say this touches more on the mechanics of time travel than free will. So if this "predictor" is nothing more than a circuit that sends information to itself in the past, there must be a "me" that pressed the button without seeing the light, before the data is transmitted to the past to the "me" that then sees the light but at that exact point splits off into a separate timeline. And then I would have free will again. Of course I am assuming time travel where travelling forward in your own timeline is impossible, something the article seem to not really go into.
- poorelise 13y agoReminds me of Comed-Tea in "Harry Potter And The Methods Of Rationality": "If you drink it, something surprising is bound to happen which makes you spill it on yourself or someone else. But it's charmed to vanish just a few seconds later"
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoExcept of course, that was done via a cheap trick with minor prescience: the tea transmits an urge to drink into your mind when it detects that something funny is about to happen.
- poorelise 13y agoYou might want to add a spoiler warning to that, as the actual mechanism behind it is not immediately revealed in the story :-) Still, I don't see why the Predictor couldn't work in the same way - how would you determine that it doesn't?
- pyalot2 13y agoCool idea for creative writing class, would've helped in plausibility if they'd thrown a few nano and quantum randomly into the essay instead of "negative time delay circuit".
- wodow 13y agoMy predictor says that some of you will want to read The Hundred-Light-Year Diary by Greg Egan (in Axiomatic [1]) ... if you like this kind of thing. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axiomatic_%28story_collection%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Axiomatic_%28story_collection%2...
- afthonos 13y agoWhat I really hate about these sorts of stories and attending discussions is that we all pretend we know what "free will" is, when no one has ever come up with satisfying definition (just look at the Wikipedia page). My humble opinion: all hand-wringing about lack of free will should be put on hold until we can answer the following question: In what way will an entity that has free will behave differently than both a fully deterministic entity and an entity that is deterministic excepting occasional random events? I have yet to see either an answer to that question, or a definition of free will that leads to one. Until then, I consider all speculation and meditation on the "revelation" that we have none to be a tale full of sound and fury, signifying nothing.
- Kronopath 13y agoThe question of "Do we have free will?" always becomes a lot less confusing if you question the question itself, by asking what you mean by "free will" in the first place. There are some nice posts on Less Wrong that deal with this, they're worth a read if you're curious: http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Free_will_(solution) http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Free_will_(solution)
- super_mario 13y agoJust because you can predict what simple decision I will make before I am aware of it consciously, does not imply I don't have free will. All it says is that my conscious awareness of some other part of my brain making the decision is delayed by x milliseconds i.e. we are not making decisions in the upper layers of consciousness, but below it. When you think about it, it is what I would expect. Your awareness is the product of nerves firing, so they have to fire before it can be reflected in your consciousness. If you decide to recall some information, the neurons storing that information have to be activated (they have to fire). If you can create a device (and we have) to detect those nerves as they are firing you will know what person is trying to recall before (by some miniscule lead time) they are aware of it.
- nichtich 13y agoWhy is greater than one second is a problem? You can chain many predictor together using robots that when seeing a flash from one predictor presses another predictor. That way you can move the message back in time many seconds.