3 ms·
"The obvious method" Using a cesium time standard and an atomic force microscope figure out the half life of individual atoms of 14C (or something more fun/sho
by VLM 13y ago
"The obvious method"
Using a cesium time standard and an atomic force microscope figure out the half life of individual atoms of 14C (or something more fun/shorter) then define a kilo of 14C as a pile of 14C generating X decay events per whatever interval calibrated by our cesium time standard.
(edited to add the point is you can watch individual atoms with the AFM and see which ones disintegrated in the past since the last scan, and its no great trick for a century or so to detect individual decays using a geiger counter. Also 14C is no fun for this task. Try a shorter halflife)
- bcbrown 13y agoThe half-life is statistical, not mechanistic, so there would be an inherent variability in that definition. The larger the radioactive mass and the longer the time period, the less variability, but it's still variable.
- jjoonathan 13y agoThe fact that it's variable isn't a valid criticism on its own: there is uncertainty in every standard we use, and the objective is to minimize that uncertainty. It's quite possible that the practically achievable error bars from this method would be thinner than the practical error bars of another method. Besides, the fact that you can arbitrarily increase the precision of this method without hitting any hard physical limitations is a solid selling point.
- bcbrown 13y agoYou are right that there's always going to be uncertainty. Perhaps it turns out that in practice, the uncertainty with this method is less than other approaches. The point I was trying to make was about the different between incidental uncertainty due to imprecise equipment, and more fundamental uncertainty due to physical laws. For example, other intrinsic uncertainties are the Planck resolution for time and space, and the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle for certain combinations of information. Similar to those, radioactivity has a fundamental limit. We cannot predict when an atom will emit radiation, all we can do is make a statistical prediction.