You guessed right. On March 2006 Computer magazine the author's letter was posted stating it was a fake. <quote> The reviews, I will state outright, are ficti

You guessed right. On March 2006 Computer magazine the author's letter was posted stating it was a fake. <quote> The reviews, I will state outright, are fiction, but with a twist: Most of the observations and attitudes they convey came from actual reviews (either of my own papers or of papers by my colleagues) that I found to be of unacceptably low quality. </quote>