5 ms·
Alternate headline choice: Man with ability to research decides not to and is disappointed in purchase but offered full refund
by jonknee 17y ago
Alternate headline choice: Man with ability to research decides not to and is disappointed in purchase but offered full refund
- jasonlbaptiste 17y agoAlternate comment: How's about commenting on the actual substance and not whining about the headline? Sure, he's asking for a pony in some ways, but they're making pro machines with displays that don't do what they say or anything "pro" for that matter.
- stuff4ben 17y agoI believe that's what his alternate headline was doing. Saves you from also having to read the post unless you liked the constant whining and childish ranting from the blogger.
- dskhatri 17y agoThat's the problem. A lot of HN readers would look at the top comment to decide whether the article is worth a read. jonknee's comment does not provide much value in this regard. It's somewhat disparaging and reminiscent of comments you'd find from fanboys on Engadget or similar site. The author makes a point that it's hard to believe an extremely well-regarded company like Apple would fail to disclose the true color depth of their panels or that the millions of colors are generated by dithering rather than the native capability of the monitor. I do agree though that his article was rather long for the point he made. There was some entertainment value in the length but it was not value a typical HN reader would seek
- mhb 17y agoIt's not just the headline. Who makes a purchase decision base on a product being called "pro"? It must be very confusing for him when he visits a supermarket and encounters words all over the place like "new", "improved", "better", "more", "bigger"...
- anigbrowl 17y agoA lot of people do exactly that. Marketers use those those terms and graphical callouts because they work, not out of some altruistic desire to keep copywriters and graphic designers gainfully employed. I resent the time it takes to process all these claims when I go shopping, but people like you and me are a minority among the buying public.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- shiranaihito 17y ago> Who makes a purchase decision base on a product being called "pro"? Actually, as he explained in the article, he made the decision based on specs, and weight.
- mhb 17y agoOK. But he apparently had some expectation related to the Pro nomenclature: I complained that it was a Pro machine, and should be treated as such.
- shiranaihito 17y agoI'd say that the Pro nomenclature is meant to raise expectations anyway, and it's certainly true that Macs are used almost exclusively by his kind of professionals. Not an unreasonable expectation then.
- jm4 17y agoThat's not entirely fair. The specific information he was looking for is not made available to the public by Apple. He was only able to find the information after getting the model number for the display and checking with the vendor. There was no way of knowing exactly which display was used without access to a MacBook Pro because that's not information made public by Apple, either. It's an awfully roundabout way of finding out how many colors can be displayed. In hindsight it's easy to say he could have done the research ahead of time, but think about this: 1) It's called a MacBook Pro and is marketed at more demanding users, i.e. professionals, 2) Apple advertises it as being able to display millions of colors despite the fact that it really only displays 262,144. Under those circumstances, it's probably easy to take a look at the specs on the Apple site and feel confident that it's the right product. There's still the matter of Apple refusing to disclose which of its products do, in fact, display millions of colors as advertised. At least they offered him a refund in the end, but in my opinion the whole thing sucks. I don't have a problem paying more and getting my money's worth, but they're clearly skimping on parts for products directly targeting the most demanding users.
- jonknee 17y agoHe seemed to have very specific requirements, doing a bit of research isn't out of the question. I knew about the color situation (and don't care!), it has been well publicized. A class action law suit about this issue was filed last year, it's not exactly breaking news. http://www.dailytech.com/article.aspx?newsid=11348 http://www.dailytech.com/article.aspx?newsid=11348
- JimmyL 17y ago>>It's called a MacBook Pro and is marketed at more demanding users, i.e. professionals Which "professionals"? 8bit color is important to pretty much one professional group: graphic artists/designers (maybe two, if you include people doing video work). For the vast majority of people - "professional" or otherwise - 6bit vs. 8bit color doesn't matter. It looks good, it's fast, it runs what they want. Those are the things that matter. As a developer, I consider myself a "professional", and my life is fine with 6bit color. My roommate is a screenwriting "professional" and they're fine with 6bit color. Presumably an 8bit color display would cost more, and hence would reduce the number of people who could afford the machine, at the expense of pleasing one small market segment. Bottom line is that if a feature (any feature) was important enough for me that it would make or break my decision to buy the underlying system, I'd explicitly confirm its existence (in a way more rigorous than "millions and millions", which sounds like marketing-speak), and I'd get reviews from my peers who would have the same interests. In this case, the author did neither.
- DanielStraight 17y agoI could've written the letter myself in the time it took to read that. I say write the letter and address it to Steve Jobs. See what happens. It's worth a shot.
- Automatt-2 17y agoI agree. I've written to SJ twice and gotten follow up phone calls from the right people within Apple both times.
- derefr 17y agoI would have taken my refund and used it to pay a notebook repair tech (perhaps an Apple one, off-the-job) to swap out my 6-bit display for an 8-bit one.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- keltecp11 17y agoHonestly that was just annoying... and yet for some reason I read most of it.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]