3 ms·
In the US you have the right not to answer questions (yes, occasionally you don't, but in most cases you do). The police is free to take possession of everythin
by toyg 13y ago
In the US you have the right not to answer questions (yes, occasionally you don't, but in most cases you do). The police is free to take possession of everything you have, sure, but you can't be forced to answer questions about it, at least in principle. I believe this applies to other legal systems. No such luck in the UK, and not just about passwords.
- rayiner 13y agoIn the U.S. you can, under the threat of contempt of court, be forced to hand over keys to storage lockers, access to financial accounts, and things of that nature. Passwords are an unsettled issue in the U.S. On one hand, it's like furnishing the keys to a lockbox, which the police can compel you to do. On the other hand, it arguably involves testimonial actions, which the police cannot compel you to do.
- DanBC 13y agoI'd be interested in someone knowledgable writing a comparison of the UK & US systems. For example, do judges need to issue the paper work or can a senior police officer do it?
- rayiner 13y agoIn the U.S., it would have to be a judge.
- toyg 13y agoYes, but (afaik & ianal) this sort of compelling power refers to stuff that authorities already know you have, and there are clear limits to what can be asked for which type of investigation. An encrypted drive could contain documents of completely unrelated nature, but this is not contemplated by this UK law: it's all or nothing. This is what tripped this particular case here, and tbh I think it also wasted time for anti-terrorism authorities, who spent weeks trying to crack a useless USB stick. Had the defendant got a chance to negotiate immunity for unrelated charges arisen by disclosure, he'd have fessed up straight away and saved everyone some precious time.
- hippich 13y agoJudge still can order you to disclose password or put you in jail for contempt of court.