4 ms·
There's a subset of men who enjoy sending sexually explicit messages to strangers. This is not surprising. Depressing, but not surprising. What is slightly sur
by onion2k 13y ago
There's a subset of men who enjoy sending sexually explicit messages to strangers. This is not surprising. Depressing, but not surprising.
What is slightly surprising is that online dating websites, for all their sophisticated matching algorithms, haven't bothered applying some of the most basic anti-spam heuristics to the problem. The first dating site that does it, you'd imagine, would get a very good reputation very quickly.
Dating websites actually want people to stay single and remain on the site paying their subscription or viewing adverts, but an add-on that filters out the awful rubbish is surely something women would pay for.
- camus2 13y ago> There's a subset of men who enjoy sending sexually explicit messages to strangers. IMHO the majority of men. > but an add-on that filters out the awful rubbish is surely something women would pay for Most dating sites are free for women. In my experience, the most effective dating sites are social networks that are about anything but dating. Where you can meet somebody with whom you share a hobby or something like that. I met my girlfriend on a foreign language learning website and we are still together after 4 years. I guess it's more complicated to meet girls on a Java forum...but the fact that one engages a discussion without sex or relationship in mind can make a future relationship more genuine. EDITED! since I just found out this subject is a very "sensitive" one for some here. But i still stand by my point.
- vdaniuk 13y ago>I would say 95% of men on dating sites... Citation please or be responsible and remove this baseless claim.
- masklinn 13y agoAnecdote is not data, but see comments in the 2x thread which seem to indicate that 95% (of active male users) is — if anything — an understatement. E.g. > Out of over 300 messages, less than 10% were actual introductions rather than a plain 'hi' or some rude sexual commentary. I responded to every single one of them. 90% of those [nb: the initially actual non-sexual introductions] turned into something sexual in less than 8 back/forth exchanges. In the end out of somewhere around 340 first contact msgs received, only one guy actually carried on a normal, reasonable conversation longer than a few paragraphs, and even he made one or two not entirely subtle hints in the process.
- vdaniuk 13y agoAnecdote is not data. Period.
- reitzensteinm 13y agoEven if that were generally true, you can't just jump metrics from messages to men like that. People using the site respectfully could be the vast majority, but still be drowned out by a small subset of users who copy and paste the same messages to as many profiles as they can find. If I applied your same logic to my inbox, I'd conclude that 95% of online businesses are dubious Canadian pharmacies selling Viagra without a prescription.
- girvo 13y agoHow is a "hi" not an introduction? That means everything I've ever sent on online dating would come under their "crap" filter :/ I always start with a plain "hi".
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- wvh 13y ago"I'm a man. I haven't had sex in two days. It hurts. I need some. Badly. Where do I find women looking for a man? Wait... Of course... Dating sites. Surely if I message 100 women, at least one must want to have sex, just like me?" Statistics don't proof anything. A few rotten apples can cause most of the spam. Besides, I doubt there are many men who don't put at least some sexual innuendos into a conversation with a potential mate, even if they are really desperately looking for a serious long-term relationship. A relationship consists of 2 parties, both with equal rights to have desires and requirements, hopes and dreams. We're not getting anywhere by implying one side is all bad and wrong and disgusting. Your quote sounds more like a witchhunt on men than a (undoubtedly deserved) complaint about some of the more abusive "empty the uzi and see what got hit" Don Juans.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- vdaniuk 13y agoYour comment seems hypocritical to me. Ofc, you're bashing guys by stating that 95% of men on dating sites send creepy messages. And ofc, you're comparing those creepy guys to ethical self and stating emphatically: "I am NOT like them, I met my SO at a non-dating site". So yeah, you are here to bash guys. Concerning your "its just an opinion" defense, I'd like to share a quote by Harlan Ellison — 'You are not entitled to your opinion. You are entitled to your informed opinion. No one is entitled to be ignorant.' EDIT Took a look at your HN profile statement, now its clear that you have an agenda.
- Dewie 13y ago> I'm not here to bash guys , I am one. We've got to get rid of this misconception that if you're a certain gender, you can't possibly be generally hostile towards that same gender. Just a side-note about this in general.
- henryaj 13y agoAgreed. Wouldn't be hard, not least because (unlike email) the site has a god's-eye view of every message a user is sending, so can see if a person is just sending the same spammy message to everyone and penalise them accordingly. That, and minimum message lengths.
- jiggy2011 13y agoThe problem is making a filter than works for everyone. A 50 something conservative christian woman probably has different ideas about what constitutes as acceptable message to a 20 something liberal woman looking for a more casual fling.
- kaybe 13y agoWell, there's always filter settings.. let everyone rate a few messages into acceptable or not and go from there. (Maybe go from real inbox messages in case one wants to minimize additional exposure.)
- jiggy2011 13y agoYou need a pretty large corpus to train a filter effectively, so probably not practical to train on a per-user basis.
- loup-vaillant 13y agoThe filter doesn't need to be accurate right away to be effective. Also, you could design a training set that gives more information than something made up of random messages. Anyway, if the filter weeds out most spam without getting too much false positives, that's a win. Then, as you mark more messages as "inappropriate", you get less and less such messages.
- kaybe 13y agoAh, that's what I meant.. you don't use those user-classified mails only for training, but you use them to gauge the level they want their filter set to. Then you set the preexisting filter to that, which you have designed using a bigger training set.
- jiggy2011 13y agoAs anybody who's ever tried to train an email spam filter from scratch can tell you , the number of messages you need to classify in order to be useful is huge. With email spam, everyone can more or less agree on what it looks like so you can reuse other people's training data but by deciding on what is a "bad" online dating message is much more complicated.
- 001sky 13y agoYeah, the latest (undergrad) stats book I read used a simple spam filter as an application example. The downside to this is that the site will give off the impression of 'snooping' and adult/private conversations. A thrid-party app would make this service more arms-lenghth. But I don't know technically if the dating sites would allow you to build a filter/screen app on top of their system?
- jrs235 13y agoI would rather find out someone is obtuse sooner than later. Preferably before I've met them for a date. If such a filter you described was in place many would keep things clean to get through the filter only to behave poorly in person. No thanks.