5 ms·
"...nice places to live...why my freedom is suddenly so limited don't seem like they would really impact me all that much" Economic freedom, that is the freedo
by mpweiher 13y ago
"...nice places to live...why my freedom is suddenly so limited don't seem like they would really impact me all that much"
Economic freedom, that is the freedom of companies to do as they please, is often in conflict with individual freedom. For example, I find myself with much greater freedom as an employee or as a consumer in Germany than in the US, because the inherent imbalance in power between the two parties is leveled by regulations curtailing the corporations' freedom.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Retric 13y agoMonopoly's and collusion are a clear counter examples where individual freedom and institutional freedom are at odds.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- tolmasky 13y agoI'm not really convinced of this at all. Especially since the fear of monopolies seems to magically vanish when its monopolies the government creates (and no I'm not talking about the water plant or whatever). For example, for all the fear mongering about Microsoft's monopoly in the 90s, the reality ended up being that the free market is a fickle mistress and Microsoft's power dwindled pretty quickly when mobile and web came around and changed the game on them (see: innovator's dilemma). Another great example is AOL/Time Warner. All those lawsuits and extensive government intervention were complete wastes of money, and I wouldn't be surprised if 10 years from now all the current "dominant players" have been overrun as well. Compare this to the monopolies granted and supported by the government in the form of patents and copyrights. Disney, while gaining its early success from taking from the public domain, enjoys Congress' approval to basically get indefinite copyright extensions and never have to relinquish any of their work. We the tax payer get to subsidize reducing Disney's competition. And hopefully here I don't have to go into the details of how detrimental technology patents have been to both consumers and new businesses (and arguably even the companies that hold the patents!). In other words, I'm actually not that scared of "natural" monopolies: i.e. monopolies that get to where they are legitimately through actually convincing 100% of consumers to buy their product, vs. by filing paperwork to the US government and then sending cease and desist letters to competitors. I also believe it would be much harder to attain such a "natural" monopoly in a patentless world. What scares me is the interaction between corporations and governments to establish monopolies that legally cannot be challenged, or alternatively, to augment their monopolies by influencing high ranking members of congress. I'd gladly trade the risk of doom-and-gloom potential monopolies for eliminating patents.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- brc 13y agoExactly. I have never had anyone show me an example of a monopoly that didn't have a supporting government framework. Even in a patent-filled world, nobody is getting to a monopoly state, because nimble entrepreneurs will find a way around. I also find it very odd that people develop a government-monopoly blindspot- Microsoft monopoly = bad and evil, Government monopoly =benign and good. Both are just groups of people, and subject to the same capture by good or bad intentions.
- brc 13y agoBut monopolies can really only exist through regulation, which is low economic freedom. You will have most economic freedom where the existence of monopolies are the lowest. Existence of monopolies is one of the strongest arguments for limiting the size of government, which limits the size of regulations.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- brc 13y agoEconomic Freedom is the freedom for you as an individual to follow your own path. It has nothing to do with individuals vs corporations. Regulations do not make you free. How free are you to start up a company in any given field? To earn income doing a task of your choosing? To spend your income on items of your own choosing? That is the essence of economic freedom. In the details it shows that the USA is still very high in certain areas - like personal freedom in labor mobility - but is getting marked down for continued and excessive debt. I think the list is somewhat imperfect (Hong Kong is no longer a country, despite it's commendable history of low taxation and personal freedoms, now lost to being a chinese micro-state). The discussions around healthcare seem to muddy the waters - although it is a hot topic I don't think it really counts for much as most of the countries above the USA have much more regulated or state owned health care.
- Jare 13y ago> Regulations do not make you free Regulations prevent more powerful others from removing my own freedom as they want.
- brc 13y agoSee my other reply, but the only 'more powerful other' that has the ability to remove your economic freedom is a government. A large corporation cannot remove your ability to change jobs, spend your income how you like or start up a new business unless they do it through the government. Microsoft or Apple can't prevent me from starting up a new company or buying some other product unless they get the government to regulate my other choices out of existence - which means they can only harm me by decreasing my economic freedom. The exact opposite to what people seem to be trying to say here.
- twobits 13y ago"Economic Freedom is the freedom for you as an individual to follow your own path. It has nothing to do with individuals vs corporations." On the right, we have the toddler. He is 2 years old. On the left, we have the heavy weights world champion. Ladies and gentlemen, please make your bets. The fight is about to begin!
- ahomescu1 13y ago> Economic freedom, that is the freedom of companies to do as they please, is often in conflict with individual freedom. These seem orthogonal to me. You can have individual economic freedom.