3 ms·
That is all well and good but consider this: not only had this patent passed muster as being non-obvious with the USPTO on its original filing but it had also b
by vacri 13y ago
That is all well and good but consider this: not only had this patent passed muster as being non-obvious with the USPTO on its original filing but it had also been found to have been non-obvious on two separate patent re-examinations before that same body and by a string of U.S. district court judges before whom the issue had arisen.
Passing muster with the USPTO is not hard. I read my company's patent with them, and despite there being heaps of prior art (known to any casual web user) and me knowing exactly what the patent was referring to, I could not make heads or tails of the description. My housemate tells me of a radio interview where they read out a patent to a senior engineer, and he couldn't figure out what it was for - it was the patent for the project he'd worked on for the past 10 years. "It passed the PTO" is an absolutely meaningless statement for originality; it just means you know how to fill in paperwork.