This is a pretty terrible analysis. It completely ignores that things might, just MIGHT actually be built correctly this time. Ignores that the developers redo

This is a pretty terrible analysis. It completely ignores that things might, just MIGHT actually be built correctly this time. Ignores that the developers redoing the code might know the problem domain better. Ignores improvements in the quality of the development teams. Ignores far too much and then advocates staying with a bad solution out of fear that it might not go well.