4 ms·
Will universal health care motivate the 'job-locked' to start businesses?
- dan_the_welder 17y agoOh I hope so. This is an excerpt from a blog I wrote on this exact issue. It was on Myspace which I don't expect anyone to want to log into to so I have just copied and pasted. " As an immigrant to the US, it took me years to realize that many Americans stayed in shitty jobs because they were afraid to lose their health care. Well, it's almost 20 years later and I have had health care for about two of them, none recently, and I still won't keep a shitty job over health care. In fact I have owned my own business for the other 18 years and … wait for it…..STILL DON'T have health care. Why? Because it's a bad deal. A sucker deal, because it's not really health care, it's insurance and insurance companies are money grubbing, fear mongering scumbags. I used to have affordable product liability insurance, and then they tripled the price post 9/11, because…….terrorists were gonna, what, ummm, file frivolous lawsuits? Please, that was the last straw. Insurance sucks. It costs a fortune, health, auto, liability, property, it's all a bad deal, if you self insured on most of them or just absorbed your losses. On an actuarial basis 99 percent of people would come out ahead, vs. paying premiums their whole lives. That one percent? Well in my world, we have benefits and it seems to work out. But, that's too scary if you grew up with "The Fear" that every American gets indoctrinated with. I'll probably die of untreated cancer which is just a guess at this point, but the freedom I have now by not having to pay for all that insurance is worth it. Don't misunderstand, some I legally have to have, auto, workers comp, but the rest I let lie. In exchange for taking this risk, I have been able to pursue my not so lucrative dreams. I would love to see nationalized health care, not so much for myself, but just to see my friends be able to leave "The Fear" behind and be able to follow their dreams. I love America. Here's to better times. Soon."
- biohacker42 17y agoAs an immigrant to the US, it took me years to realize that many Americans stayed in shitty jobs because they were afraid to lose their health care. I second this personal anecdote. I bet other can say the same. I vague recall a study about this, but google fails me.
- profquail 17y agoAs much as I disagree with the unbridled spending that has been going on in Washington recently (but is just continuing a trend from the past several administrations), I just don't see any non-selfish reasons why someone would argue against having universal healthcare. I mean, it's the 21st century! We were supposed to have flying cars and such already, but there's still tens of millions of people in our country that can't get treatment for even minor illnesses (which, untreated, can worsen and bring on deadly complications). The only thing that I'm afraid of in this case (other than the cost) is that the system becomes too bureaucratic, where most people continue to use private doctors simply because there's too much "red tape" to get treated in a public facility.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI just don't see any non-selfish reasons why someone would argue against having universal healthcare. How about "my kids can't afford it" Or "increasing demand while keeping supply constant will NOT lower costs" Or "I should have the freedom to come up with a million-dollar-per-ill cure for cancer and not have the government take it" None of these are selfish. I've got others, if you'd like to hear them.
- profquail 17y agoI never said the costs would be lower. In fact, the cost issue is the only real argument I see against it. Why not offer incentives (tax breaks, for example) to coerce the system into the right state? For example, if you go to medical school or nursing school and graduate in the top 50% of your class (from any accredited school), you would be automatically reimbursed for the entirety of your tuition by the government. This would create an incentive for more students to become doctors and nurses, which is sorely needed today; at the same time, it reduces the barrier to entry (the cost), creates motivation to do well, and also keeps the price of service (what the doctor charges you) down as well (since they're not having to pay back $200k in student loans). At the same time, the system should require everyone to get certain tests on a regular basis (e.g. a yearly physical). If you don't take care of yourself at some kind of baseline level (the doctor should be able to tell from your charts), then you will be charged a "surplus" fee since you will be requiring more medical care down the road (e.g. heart disease due to lack of exercise). This would motivate people to get in shape, or at least they'd be paying for the extra costs of their own care. So, essentially, it's free as long as you play your own little part in the system. On another note, all the people that I've heard argue against UH have all said that they don't want to pay for someone else's healthcare. While I understand where they're coming from (I hold mostly libertarian political views), you have to remember that the 'healthier' our society becomes (due to UH, or simply lifestyle changes, etc.), the "cost" per person is reduced. This is because healthier people are more able to contribute to society, rather than unhealthy people who must survive on the contributions of others.
- roc 17y agoYou sound like a good guy. I hope you never get sick while uninsured in America. I too have spent a majority of my life without health insurance. I just haven't been as lucky. The Fear is truly unfortunate, but there's a reason people have it and it's not blind indoctrination.
- dan_the_welder 17y agoMe too, and I am sorry for whatever you have had to deal with. It is an embarrassment that you have had to deal with potentially huge financial repercussions in one of the richest and most technologically advanced countries in the world. I agree that there are reasons to have the fear. Don't get me wrong, I have Alzheimer's and some interesting cancers in my family history, so I have some of the fear. I don't exactly know how to phrase this, but did you actually have a choice, either financially or in terms of being true to your desires? Do you have regrets?
- mattchew 17y agoNot to be rude, but it doesn't look like you have been paying much attention to what Universal Health Care in the U.S. will actually mean. I legally have to have, auto, workers comp [...] And now you will legally have to have health insurance. Insurance sucks. It costs a fortune, health, auto, liability, property, it's all a bad deal [...] You have a bad attitude, but the health insurance companies won't have to worry about it much longer. You'll be paying up with the rest of the citizen-units. Well, you thought you wanted Universal Coverage. You got it. Go America! Land of the free!
- dan_the_welder 17y agoYes, I am going to be pissed if we end up with the Massachusetts solution. Just curious, are you working a job or are you making a go of it with your software biz?
- mattchew 17y agoThere was never any doubt about what "Universal Coverage" would mean, not to me. The popular view is that health care reform was about taking care of the American People. My view, health care reform was always about taking care of the health care interest groups (insurance at the top of the list). I don't have a job, but I pay the bills from contracting, not from Homeschool Day Book. (So far I have not marketed it very well and don't have many sales.)
- crux_ 17y agoI'm not advocating getting health insurance, exactly, but your life as you know it will end if you get seriously sick or injured. (Exception: if you have millions in the bank you're probably just fine.) Personally I'm paying for health insurance, but only the bare minimum (rather high deductible). I consider it my rock climbing tax: insurance can give you some freedoms (the freedom to take a bit of extra risk, in this case) as well as take them away.
- theoneill 17y agoDoesn't seem to in Europe.
- jrbedard 17y agonor as in Canada!
- myth_drannon 17y agoThe same applies to Canada. I don't think canadians are more enterprenual than americans
- cperciva 17y agoI don't think canadians are more enterprenual than americans Perhaps not; but we might be even less entrepreneurial without universal health care. I know I would never have started working on tarsnap if I was living in the US.
- r7000 17y agoI'd have been in a lot of trouble. I was very sick in my early 20s and from a not so well-off background. The doctor that got me back on track is world-renowned and I was able to waltz right in his office and see him for "free" like anyone else. If I lived in (most?) states I'd probably never even think of quitting my job.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- dan_the_welder 17y agoGuess no one likes my sarcasm. I still feel like an alien in the US and I feel like an alien in Canada when I go home. It's lonely being an entrepreneur.
- tptacek 17y agoApples-to-oranges. Most European countries have many other obstacles to starting a business. It can be almost impossible to fire workers. Some places have mandatory short work weeks. France apparently has special police that monitor them! There have been onerous regulations about running small businesses from your house. The tax code is different and often less favorable to small businesses. And the cultural climate is "famously" hostile to entrepreneurs. You can't extrapolate the outcome of universal health care in the States from Europe's experience. The conclusion that universal health care would hurt entrepreneurship (or even fail to help it) remains counterintuitive.
- roc 17y agoStart businesses? Probably not. That's something a minority will ever do. But -join- small businesses? Yes. Labor will become far more mobile and small business will be on more-equal footing if they aren't forced to pay more for competitive benefits packages. That's A Good Thing(tm).
- profquail 17y agoI think more people would start their own businesses (not many, but more than now), simply because they could continue to work part-time somewhere to bring in money while growing their business. Part-time jobs usually don't offer health care benefits, so as of now it's either: (a) stay at current job full time for health benefits, and work on the business after hours, or (b) quit, have no health benefits, and work full time on the business in order to get up and running as quickly as possible (potentially at the cost of skipping important parts of the development process, marketing, etc.)
- dan_the_welder 17y agoLabor mobility is broken and it is a huge problem with American capitalism. Working for a small business is great, I have enjoyed and learned at everyone that I have worked for. Now that I am the small business owner, my employees are my family. If I were to behave like a corporate employer I would be a lonely man.
- jobu 17y agoUntil recently, Labor Mobility was helped greatly by the housing boom - anyone could sell their house with little economic impact and move to a better job in a different area. Now we have the double-whammy of a housing bust and astronomical health care costs. Cobra helps, but it only lasts 18 months, and that's definitely not long enough to build a successful business.
- tptacek 17y agoThe argument isn't that a majority of people would start small businesses with health insurance. It's simply that more people, in absolute terms, would. Again, I don't see how this could not be the case. The same dynamic that keeps the head of a family of 4 from joining a startup keeps that same person from starting a startup. There are fewer start-ers than join-ers, but they face the same obstacle.
- thelonecabbage 17y agoIf you start with 3 other co-founders, you can get the same deal (mostly) that your employer gets. Also HSA's and high deductible health plans are likely to cost less than paying out for "Universal" coverage. Best yet, is that these solutions don't suffer from a tax-drag on entrepreneur ship that the article is so concerned with.
- DenisM 17y agoHow would you go about finding such coverage (for 3 founders)?
- davidmabe 17y agoJust call an insurance broker. I recently went shopping for health care coverage expecting the worst and was pleasantly surprised how close the quotes were to my employer provided plan. I took away from it a feeling that I am less stuck than I thought I was, even before universal health care.
- utnick 17y agothat works as long as your 3 co-founders are relatively healthy and have been healthy their whole lifes, if one of them develops a problem you can expect your premium to skyrocket into unaffordability
- thelonecabbage 17y agoGroup health care plans (what your employer gives you) are given largely without consideration for the health of the individuals involved. Basic tests, like making sure you don't have a major heart problem and pee tests are involved but thats it. Friends of mine who have a business with only 3 employees listed me as one of their employees to get the number up to four. Some how I was registered whilst living in another country. And I believe there are already laws on the books about pre-existing conditions (assuming you have continuous coverage)
- CWuestefeld 17y agoIt's worth remembering that the relationship between health insurance and employment is entirely due to government meddling in the first place. Up through the fist half of the 20th Century, medical expenses were generally paid individually, or through mutual-aid groups such as churches or fraternal societies. This began to change when the government instituted wage freezes. In that environment the only way for an employer to attract superior talent was to offer non-salary benefits, and the tax advantages of health care made that an attractive one. Thus, American employers began to offer health insurance as a way to better compensate their workers when the government was trying to interfere with the labor market. As the practice became more common, it increasingly became a point that job hunters would look for. And the rest is history. If you think that the results of this meddling are undesirable, then you might think twice about giving the same meddlers the authority to muck things up further. Edit: here's a bit on FDR's wage freeze and its effect on health insurance: http://faculty.smu.edu/tmayo/health%20care%20timeline.htm http://faculty.smu.edu/tmayo/health%20care%20timeline.htm
- jfoutz 17y agoCan you elaborate more? A (cursory) google search didn't really come up with anything about US wage freezes. there was a bit about price controls for 90 days when we came off the gold standard... that doesn't seem like the kind of problem you're describing. fwiw, it looks like white male lifespan went up a ton in the first half of 20th century, 48 to 66, 37%! vs 66 to 74, just 12%. I'm pretty sure each 1 percent is exponentially harder than the last though.
- ckinnan 17y agoThe change came from wage controls during the Second World War. Ever since, employer-provided care is paid with pre-tax dollars while most private insurance outside of the workplace is paid with after-tax dollars. That's a huge penalty. http://books.google.com/books?id=_TRBtKwBr4oC&pg=PA261&lpg=PA261&dq=health+care+employer+tax+deduction+history+world+war+two&source=bl&ots=Od1d2u7dhn&sig=oFinS_bnjZrfAjMxkCf7L4eZpjE&hl=en&ei=_xFeSs7IEYvmMfeK-L8C&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=4 http://books.google.com/books?id=_TRBtKwBr4oC&pg=PA261&#... It is also illegal to buy health care insurance across state lines, so it isn't a competitive national marketplace. We need to make health care more market oriented, not less.
- drawkbox 17y agoHealthcare needs to be an independent insurance that companies will pay you in salary to get on your own. Right now do companies or governments pay your auto insurance? How about home insurance? Why health insurance? It is a tired and wrong way to do things, it removes the cost of insurance and medical care from the paying customer and it is the major reason there is a huge healthcare bubble in cost. We would see a very fast cost correction in healthcare if we treated it like other insurance. I truly believe if health insurance moves like retirement, away from the employer, then we will have a much more agile workforce and the walls to move around more and be more entrepreneurial will be removed.
- tptacek 17y agoYour analogies are all faulty. You can avoid paying car insurance by not driving. You can avoid paying homeowner's insurance by renting. There is nothing you can reasonably do to ensure that you won't break your leg, lose your appendix, or develop a lymphoma. Meanwhile, you can't simply buy health insurance. Under our current system, any insurer can refuse to cover you for any number of reasons, or assign calamitously high premiums to you. The medical pretexts required to do this are numerous and opaque. Ask any 30 year old woman who's tried to buy health insurance if you need convincing. Many people with families simply cannot start or join startups in this climate, because there is no feasible way for them to cover their family. Without health insurance, you can be bankrupted by relatively minor health events; more importantly, you put your family at risk for receiving inferior care, particularly on the preventative side.
- dantheman 17y agoOf course if you are a risk then you should pay more. The correct answer is for those people to rely on public charity to help with their medical bills. What you're advocating is just forcing people to subsidize others. At least with private charity people: 1st are thankful, and realize that others are helping them, and 2nd are controlling how their money is spent. Insurance shouldn't cover preventive care, it should be insurance. You don't have car insurance that covers getting your oil changed, why should your health insurance cover your doctor visits?
- yummyfajitas 17y agoAn additional problem is that large numbers of people are 'job-locked' by their need to have a regular paycheck. I wonder if people would also be encouraged to start businesses if we came up with a universal paycheck program. [edit: could anyone downmodding me explain why? Just curious.]
- dan_the_welder 17y agoSounds too much like welfare in thread that is already driving the free market "I'll get mine" types insane already.
- nkurz 17y agoI downmodded you because at a glance fell into the category of 'dumb joke'. The conversation at the top of the page is interesting, and I want to keep this at the bottom so as not to interrupt distract from the useful discussion. If you intend this as a real insight, please flesh it out with more explanation.
- tome 17y agoYou sound a little trollish: "universal paycheck program" sounds like a thinly veiled dig at "socialism" (For the record: I upvoted you)
- yummyfajitas 17y agoMy specific point: people are "job-locked" by a desire to keep getting the compensation that their job provides. One form of compensation is medical insurance, another form is pay. Is there any legitimate reason to single out medical insurance as a particular cause of job-lock, rather than pay, corporate gym membership, etc?
- tptacek 17y agoAnecdotally, I can't see how it could not be the case that universal healthcare will promote startups. In '05 and '06, we routinely lost candidates because they were married and required health insurance. If you've never tried to buy private health coverage for a family of 4, you may be laboring under the delusion that it's possible to actually do that. Is there a difference between starting a company and joining a small startup? Sure. But the same obstacle confronts any family that wants to start a company. How could removing a huge obstacle to entrepreneurship not help?
- TheCondor 17y agoNo question about this. It potentially can help any industry where the healthcare costs are high in relation to other costs, this include heavy manufacturing where there are pensions to pay. All provided the tax burden doesn't out weigh everything else. If the collective tax rate was doubled, then that will kill the start-up market.
- tptacek 17y agoWhen you talk about tax rates and health insurance, it's important to keep in mind the shadow tax paid in the common case by families and businesses that employ them today. Privately-run health insurance is expensive, and there's an inherent adverse selection problem because coverage is discretionary.
- lsc 17y agohang on there; how come a higher tax rate would kill the startup market? A more complex business tax regime, sure, but you are only taxed on your profits and what you pay yourself. You don't pay much in taxes until your company actually starts making money. Especially considering that capital gains is treated differently (and taxed less) than income, it seems to me like the most advantageous course to take in a time of high taxation is to start a business, and re-invest as much of your profit as possible. Then, at some point sell it and pay capital gains on your winnings. (or perhaps sit on it until tax rates go down a bit.) Now, obviously a high tax rate will cause people to spend less, but that's going to hurt all businesses, not just startups. From where I stand, as a small company, it seems that I am much better positioned to compete on price than larger companies in my market.
- sunir 17y agoFrom doing a lot of customer dinners in the United States with FreshBooks customers, the absolute top of the list with a bullet number one reason Americans don't quit their day job and start freelancing or start a business is lack of health insurance. I'd bet most of our customers don't have health insurance, and that's why we push them to professional organizations like the Freelancer's Union and AIGA. My personal beliefs: It seems counterproductive to me to make citizens risk their entire future just because you wanted to be innovative or fill an unserviced need in society.