4 ms·
Steam can't be considered DRM free in many cases, for example because they don't let you backing up installers / packages, so if the service closes down you los
by shmerl 13y ago
Steam can't be considered DRM free in many cases, for example because they don't let you backing up installers / packages, so if the service closes down you lose your collection. The only completely DRM-free gaming distributor is GOG. Humble Bundle and Desura are mixed.
You are right in general though. Going DRM free not only won't hurt any publisher, it will only gain respect from customers and will improve the quality of their products in a sense of improved usability, because any DRM means a crippled product (i.e. limited platforms availability, inability to make backups and etc. and etc.).
The problem is, that most legacy publishers are rarely customer focused and think that DRM helps their profits. And unprincipled distributors like Netflix are ready to oblige. But the irony is, those publishers only hurt themselves by continuing using DRM. It's mostly innovative publishers, or self published studios (and crowdfunded projects) that have common sense and avoid using DRM. Luckily some distributors are also principled enough to reject DRMed products from publishers. But such are a minority still.
- darklajid 13y agoCan you explain the "no backups" part? I'm sure you know about the backups you can create in Steam itself, bundling the application. What is the missing detail? Being unable to extract the data again, without Steam? Is Steam unable to restore these bundles in offline mode?
- crowleysimon 13y agoCorrect. You can backup a game when offline, but steam wont allow you to restore one without being logged in.
- ekianjo 13y agoSteam will require you to be connected to their servers once in a while at least. There's no pure offline mode.
- gcb0 13y agosteam is just like any other drm system for your games. it phone home and prevents you from playing without a connection to the mothership. they just have saner fallback times than other ill talked solutions from EA. but besides its pretty eyes, its the same virus. good luck running online games as root.
- jeena 13y agoI once bought and downloaded SuperHexagon on Steam but didn't have the time to test it at home. Later on the train (I'm commuting for two hours a day) I wanted to test it. Sadly I wasn't allowed without a internet connection which was really annoying.
- jamesgeck0 13y agoSometimes the game executable doesn't actually require you to be online the first time you launch it, even though Steam does. If you launch the binary from Windows explorer, there's a chance it'll work.
- Svip 13y agoOnly for games that require Steam. A game bought through Steam does not necessarily require Steam. Europa Universalis III can be run without Steam running. Europa Universalis IV only requires Steam to be run once (and once for every DLC you buy, in order to activate it). These settings are up to the game developer themselves. You are right about the offline mode, but it does not apply to all games.
- shmerl 13y agoRunning the game and installing it aren't the same thing. Some Steam can can be probably trivially copied (the game directory), and are backup-able that way, but you never know which ones, and which require more steps for installation. Steam also doesn't mark any such details on the games before you buy them.
- luckyno13 13y agoI purchase whatever I like on Steam and still hate DRM. They make it worth while with the sales and convenience. My theory is that if Steam goes belly up, I can do a backup of my games, and use the same avenues pirates use to circumvent Steam. Hopefully they would release control of their games though if they went belly up. As far as poor customer service, I suppose I have been lucky so far.
- Semaphor 13y agoSteam is a distributor. If a certain games has the Steam DRM included or not is (though sadly not mentioned on the product page) up to the publisher/developer. On the GOG forum there is a (probably outdated) list [1] of those games. [1] http://www.gog.com/forum/general/list_of_drmfree_games_on_steam/page1 http://www.gog.com/forum/general/list_of_drmfree_games_on_st...
- shmerl 13y agoDRM proliferation is conducted in three steps: 1. Publishers decide to treat all potential users as criminals, and insist on using DRM in their products. 2. Distributors accept that, and help these unethical publishers to sell those products. 3. Users accept being treated as criminals, and buy these products from distributors. It starts from the publisher of course, but anywhere down the line, one can refuse to accept this. Distributor can refuse dealing with DRMed products from publishers. Users can refuse buying DRMed products from distributors. Any participation in that chain proliferates DRM, and one can't excuse this participation with the fact that it was initiated by the publisher.
- Semaphor 13y agoI wasn't making a statement regarding DRM, I was just refuting that all steam games have DRM ;)
- shmerl 13y ago> I was just refuting that all steam games have DRM Practically all do, I already explained above. Being unable to back up the installer is already DRM, and it's coming from Valve themselves, not from the publishers. Always on-line DRM and such is another level of nastiness, but the above is DRM too.
- Semaphor 13y agoYou can still backup the game files after installation.
- fafner 13y agoAnd GOG refuses to add GNU/Linux support. Considering that many GOG games run in DOSEmu anyway and some come with native Linux support this is not really understandable.
- shmerl 13y ago> And GOG refuses to add GNU/Linux support. Yes, that's one of their downsides. Even their reasoning is becoming less and less sensible. They claimed they still can't figure out how to offer long term support on Linux. May be Docker can help them.
- teacup50 13y agoShipping binary software for Linux is like playing a never-ending game of Space Invaders. GOG's position is totally understandable.
- shmerl 13y agoNo, it's not. Their position is (at least from their last status update): "we are trying to come up with a long term support methodology, and didn't find one yet". It takes them more than a year to design it. It doesn't sound reasonable to me.
- pquerna 13y agoShipping binaries on Linux is nearly impossible on a long term support basis. FatELF would of addressed at least some of these problems, but was largely rejected by the larger community of people not shipping proprietary products on Linux: https://icculus.org/fatelf/ https://icculus.org/fatelf/
- derefr 13y agoMight Docker containers be a valid solution to this? Shipping old games is a sorta-kinda-similar problem to shipping frozen versions of web-apps.