6 ms·
$90 million in maintenance per year for healthcare.gov
- jayd16 13y agoMisleading title. The $90m cost is a 12 month contract with a new company, not the amount it might cost each year indefinitely.
- hga 13y agoBingo. Given how bad the system still is (e.g. 5% error rate in sending info to insurers http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2014/01/09/a-health-industry-expert-on-the-fundamental-problem-with-obamacare/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2014/01/09/a... and also see his very high signal to noise ratio blog: http://healthpolicyandmarket.blogspot.com/ http://healthpolicyandmarket.blogspot.com/), and how much of it is left to be done (paying insurers, change in status updates, etc. etc. etc.) this is not just cheap, but some are suspecting that when Accenture fully takes over, right at the end of the spring enrollment period, they'll just throw much or most of the existing system away and start with what they did for California, which isn't hardly as bad.
- spikels 13y agoKeep in mind $90m Accenture contract is only part of the annual cost - there are other contractors as well as the cost of HHS itself. While we don't have the Accenture contract terms the renewal cost is usually the same (or slightly higher for inflation). This contract is only about 1.5% of HHS's $7.5 billion technology budget.
- cryoshon 13y agoPolitics, bureaucracy, mismanagement-- this policy has been a failure. Time to join the 21st century and push for universal healthcare.
- whatevsbro 13y ago> Time to join the 21st century and push for universal healthcare. No it's not. Source: I'm a Finn. Compare two scenarios: A) Healthcare is run with money that's just taken from people. B) Healthcare is run as a business, with people paying for it voluntarily. Which one do you think will be better quality? Suppose you're running a car repair shop, but your "customers" are just forced to come to you and pay for your services. Are you motivated to: 1) provide them with good service, 2) keep your costs low, 3) maintain high standards? The obvious answers are: No, No, and No, and that's exactly what happens with everything that's run by any government, because it's always with someone else's money and the "customers" aren't actually customers - they have no choice. It's rather unsurprising, then, that Finland's public healthcare system is of poor quality, and that we have to wait for weeks or months for an appointment.
- nwh 13y agoI live in Australia, our healthcare is universally free and of very high quality. I don't have a problem walking into any clinic in my area and getting free, prompt medical service. Just because yours sucks doesn't mean it's a bad idea to begin with.
- whatevsbro 13y ago> Just because yours sucks doesn't mean it's a bad idea to begin with. I didn't say it's a bad idea because ours sucks. I said it's a bad idea because if you're using money that's just taken from other people, you're not motivated to provide them with good service, and so on. The factors I listed cannot be escaped. You can rest assured that your system is slowly turning to shit too.
- angersock 13y agoWhat if your motivation is to care for other people and to provide the best service you know how to? Your model is flawed.
- whatevsbro 13y ago
- Guvante 13y ago> Politics, bureaucracy, mismanagement-- this policy has been a failure. So you are saying the governments attempts to do this have failed for historical reasons. > Time to join the 21st century and push for universal healthcare. And now you are saying that the government should have a bigger part of the industry, by absorbing it completely. This logic is faulty, you cannot use a failure to recommend an entity takes a bigger part in something. Additionally how well the website for finding healthcare works is unrelated to whether or not we should have universal healthcare. Heck the $90 million maintenance is not unheard of for a $400 million+ product, nor is it a lot in the scheme of a government program.
- jayd16 13y agoThe logic in this sense would be that universal healthcare removes layers of bureaucracy.
- Guvante 13y agoMy point was that you cannot point out a failure as a reason, nothing more. You can't say "because they failed at X they should do Y" and then later make up a reason why doing Y makes sense, doing so does not change the validity of your original argument.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- winslow 13y agoHaha remove bureaucracy when universal healthcare would be a bigger project. I doubt it.
- beat 13y agoObservation shows that the current American health care system is by far the most bureaucratic in the world. Any computer programmer should know that if you can take a many-to-many relationship and reduce it to a one-to-many, you've simplified the system. Countries like Japan and Switzerland offer systems that rival the US system in every way and usually exceed it, for far less cost and bureaucracy.
- spikels 13y agoHow would universal healthcare reduce politics, bureaucracy or mismanagement? I'm sympathetic to arguments for universal healthcare but after the way the ACA was both designed and implemented I have little confidence our leaders wouldn't make things even worse. I'm sure many people share this view. The key lasting impact of the ACA may turn out to be delaying more meaningful reform of our broken healthcare system for decades.
- Bluestrike2 13y agoThis isn't just a healthcare thing. It's unfortunate that the fallout over healthcare.gov hasn't been more directed towards the problems with federal IT contracting in general rather than just this specific incident and "Obamacare." It's a case of not seeing the forest for the trees. No matter the specific project, or what sort of healthcare system we're looking at, these sorts of problems affect them all. And they'll continue to do so long into the future unless something drastic changes in how federal IT contracting is handled.
- jgalt212 13y agoThat may be a lot of money, but it's way cheaper than Nest. http://news.cnet.com/8301-11386_3-57617153-76/google-to-buy-nest-for-$3.2-billion/ http://news.cnet.com/8301-11386_3-57617153-76/google-to-buy-...
- joelrunyon 13y agoI have zero technical skills and I would do this for a mere 85 million. I'm pretty sure for 85 million, I could assemble a crack team of devs to knock this out as a more competitive price.
- whatevsbro 13y ago> I'm pretty sure for 85 million, I could assemble a crack team of devs to knock this out as a more competitive price. Of course. Anyone could, but you see, this is not about using your money or getting the job done well. The $90 million is going to companies that have bribed politicians appropriately, and are now reaping the returns on their investments.
- Guvante 13y agoThey probably based the amount on the cost to create it. 25% of upfront costs for a year of maintenance is incredibly common.
- pinaceae 13y agonope. this is highly sensitive data, you can't treat it like a private business does, say like Target. this needs to survive countless audits, from code, to docs, to various accessiblity and other norms. a large number of data interfaces in the background to byzantine and opaque systems. etc etc etc. COMPLIANCE is the cost driver. and not necessarily for a bad reason.
- erichocean 13y agothis is highly sensitive data, you can't treat it like a private business does, say like Target. You're joking, right? Because the lack of care that was put into security is WIDELY documented. They couldn't even get internal signoffs on security and decided to launch anyway. It's simple, really: the government doesn't care if they break their own laws. The laws are for everyone else.
- pinaceae 13y agothat's launch, in a rushed way. political decision. but as you see, highly visible. some new business site/app does not fall under the same public and governmental scrutiny. the ones that do with the same scope as this site - cost as much.
- pmorici 13y agoThe really disturbing thing is this is almost certainly _not_ an isolated incident. It's just that this is the first time that a government IT project has received so much scrutiny. Makes you think when politicians insist that taxes and fees need to be raised.
- VladRussian2 13y agowell, the healthcare.gov project being the spearhead of the most important policy push by the current President and his party - i'd guess that it is actually the most efficient (less than half a billion) and successful (developed in 2 years, fixed in 3 months) one among myriad of government projects and budget sinks, most of which isn't auditable and hasn't been in years (for example, see Pentagon budget audit (i.e. lack of it))
- DanBC 13y agoHn readers might be interested to read about some of the UK government IT projects. I'm sure some of them went well, but many had huge budgets and were then scrapped because they were useless. http://www.computerweekly.com/blogs/public-sector/2013/05/pull-out-and-keepyour-guide-to.html http://www.computerweekly.com/blogs/public-sector/2013/05/pu... Connecting for health cost £11bn - billion - and is in various states of abandoned.
- 3pt14159 13y agoI once worked on a project for the American government. The company I was working for was the 4th and last in a line of companies. We were the ones actually writing the software and it was still 5 times more money than I thought was reasonable.
- Aloisius 13y agoSometimes I think about creating an organization that's sole purpose would be to enter bids in on government tech contracts with upper and lower cost estimates. It wouldn't actually do any of the work (to maintain neutrality), but at least put in a reasonable set of figures for how much a project should cost. Or maybe just a company that reviews proposals for local/state/federal government agencies to ensure they aren't being ripped off. Frankly, tech contracts aren't the only thing that goes wrong. Civil engineering contracts are just as awful with people underbidding and then having massive cost overruns because there was no expert there to say, hey... this isn't reasonable.
- negamax 13y agoI wonder if right way of doing this would be to crowdsource it like robotics/technology challenges with very large bounty? On another note, Obama administration should have assembled team of developers from challenge.gov with track record/history etc.
- VladRussian2 13y ago>Sometimes I think about creating an organization that's sole purpose would be to enter bids in on government tech contracts with upper and lower cost estimates. It wouldn't actually do any of the work (to maintain neutrality), but at least put in a reasonable set of figures for how much a project should cost. Or maybe just a company that reviews proposals for local/state/federal government agencies to ensure they aren't being ripped off. so one more consulting participant and review layer to dig teeth into government money without actually delivering on the project? And with the best intentions like everybody else :)
- yogo 13y agoI think it's the job of the buyer (the gov in this case to find out what is reasonable). Companies, just like individuals, should be able to bid whatever they like. If you are looking to have software built and one person quotes $200/hr and someone else quotes $75/hr, you can't go saying $200/hr is unreasonable. The developers can quote whatever they think their time is worth, it doesn't mean you use that particular developer/provider.
- 13y ago
- negamax 13y agoIt's the same story everywhere. Heard this anecdote about installation of ERP in one of India's major ports. The programmers were paid in gold to delay project just so old ways of funnelling money remains intact.
- guelo 13y agoI wonder if they also fired the government people that insisted that the site had to use a weird proprietary XML database called MarkLogic, which apparently was one of the reasons for the concurrency problems. (As described here http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/23/us/politics/tension-and-woes-before-health-website-crash.html http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/23/us/politics/tension-and-wo...) A SQL server, probably Oracle, should almost always be the answer for a large bureaucratic product like this.
- hga 13y agoI find it difficult to judge the quality of the database given what we've learned, especially since the initial provisioning was entirely inadequate for any database; about when that article was written it was moved off government's Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services' (CMS) shared VM infrastructure to 12 dedicated servers. However, there's absolutely no doubt the contractors weren't familiar with it and its paradigm. A SQL RDBMS, which pretty much everyone is familiar with, would have been a much less risky bet. But the CMS had had success with the XML database, and since they arrogated to themselves the roles of general contractor and system integrator (and in fact were "fired" about the time that article was written), the consulting companies had no choice but to use it. See my other comment where people are suspecting Accenture might just throw away a lot of the current system and replace it with what they did for California. EDITED: to make more clear the distinction between the unit of the Federal government CMS and CGI Federal, the fired contractor.
- rhizome 13y agosince they arrogated to themselves the roles of general contractor and system integrator ...and also attempted to arrogate to themselves those future roles. Would that there were taxpayer protections against that kind of anti-competitive (on face, at least) strategy.
- hga 13y agoNot entirely sure that's necessary when those who do it fail so hard, i.e. there's at least some feedback in the system. The other exchange example where this happened is Oregon, which isn't even pretending that their site works.
- cjoh 13y agoThe problem here isn't with "government," but with the failed ERP-style methodology of development that federal and local governments, along with very large corporations use to develop technology. Hewlett Packard, Hershey, along with a string of other large corporations have lost billions in value from these kinds of integrations. Hershey even missed Halloween one year because of a failed integration. And while Silicon Valley and the startup community has largely moved away from this methodology, large bureaucracies, ever afraid of risk, seem drawn to them. But as far as I can tell, this idea that "nobody ever got fired for choosing IBM" is a function of marketing, not of a track record of success (IBM's latest for the feds: http://sam.gov http://sam.gov. $171 Million). What we can do to solve this problem isn't to scoff and laugh at government. While some want larger or smaller government, we all should want it to do what it is doing affordably. The opportunity for smart technologists to take on the idea of working with government commercially is the next step in the Civic Hacking movement. I hope those invited to go to their next hackathon for the city or invited to give their free advice and labor to the city out of a sense of civic duty, begin to ask the question: why are you asking me for stuff for free with one hand, whilst handing out million dollar contracts with the other. How can you fix procurement in a way that allows me to compete for the serious work, so that I can save you from this mess?
- skywhopper 13y agoI'm surprised Philip Greenspun is acting so naive here. "If it works, why will it take $90 million to keep it running?" This from a computer scientist? Software is never "done", and maintenance on existing computer systems is quite often far more expensive than the initial development. Do you want it to keep updated with correct information about the various plans that are available? To keep up with new tweaks to the regulations? To address new bugs that come up when it's annual renewal time? To stay secure over time? All of these things require a lot of work. And how about fixing the bugs that still remain? Or improving the system? Yes, government projects of this sort are inevitably going to cost far more than a startup company, and mistakes will be made. But $90 million out of the federal budget isn't even worth blinking at. The Defense Department spends that much in about an hour and a half. But if you really want to save money in this area, you should argue for eliminating the exchanges and healthcare.gov altogether. Just sign everyone up for Medicare. Save a few hundred billion over the next few years give or take.
- nikatwork 13y agoEverytime there's a "government app costs $x million" story, someone always chimes in with "Lol I could build that in PHP for $2." It seems a fair percentage of HN'ers have not experienced the sheer Khafkaesque deadlock that is a large corp or govt department. The cost is not in the dev effort, quite often there is actually a very small team of devs doing the "real" work. Outsourcing the dev work is not going to help because it is the massive bureaucratic pyramid which is crushing the devs, and that pyramid can't be outsourced. This is not a technology problem. It's an enterprise management problem.
- beat 13y agoWorse, it easily enters Mythical Man-Month territory where more staff (especially more managers) are thrown at the problem, which actually makes it worse.
- shit_parade 13y agowhy anyone believed the government could sell a product is beyond me. It's as if all the tech professionals have a blind faith untested by reality.
- semerda 13y agoWithout knowing what lies beneath the mess.. isn't $90m in maintenance fees extremely excessive? Or have they factored in a full rewrite? What are the typical gov tech maintenance fees?