4 ms·
"Paste and match formatting" shouldn't be necessary for most programs, and isn't a platform standard. Yes, it is. https://developer.apple.com/library/mac/docum
by Someone 13y ago
"Paste and match formatting" shouldn't be necessary for most programs, and isn't a platform standard.
Yes, it is. https://developer.apple.com/library/mac/documentation/UserExperience/Conceptual/AppleHIGuidelines/KeyboardShortcuts/KeyboardShortcuts.html https://developer.apple.com/library/mac/documentation/UserEx... says "Table A-2 lists the system-reserved and commonly used keyboard shortcuts mentioned in the rest of this document."
Table A-2: contains ../art/ks_option_2x.png ../art/ks_shift_2x.png ../art/ks_command_2x.png V
Apply the style of the surrounding text to the inserted object (equivalent to the Paste and Match Style command). See “The Edit Menu.” That links to https://developer.apple.com/library/mac/documentation/UserExperience/Conceptual/AppleHIGuidelines/Menus/Menus.html#//apple_ref/doc/uid/TP30000356-TPXREF127 https://developer.apple.com/library/mac/documentation/UserEx..., which describes the command, too.
I disagree with the claim that this is a bad choice, though. It may not be optimal if starting from a tabula rasa, but Apple did not do that when it introduced the combination, five years ago or so, in my memory. By that time Command-V has done styled paste for about 25 years, making it difficult to dethrone.
We must be glad that we have a standard for this, not angry that it may be a bit complex to type.
- podperson 13y agoOK I didn't know Apple had made that a standard -- so I agree with the GP that it's dumb. If I can't easily type a shortcut with one hand, it shouldn't be a standard shortcut. I'm suggesting the standard paste should behave as expected, not adhere to some literal definition the user doesn't care about. If I copy a passage of text from one document and paste it into another, I generally want it to look like it belongs in the destination document but I don't want to lose obvious intentional styling such as italicization. The common case should be the easy case. Instead we have the common case and the four-fingered shortcut both doing the wrong thing. Awesome.
- Someone 13y agoI think implementing "obvious intentional styling" is an AI problem. Suppose you copy a header, click in a normal paragraph, and paste. Keep styling information? Case 2: copy styled text from Keynote, and paste. Keep styling? Maybe, the logic in a word processor should be to keep character styling, but not paragraph styling, but I think there will be many edge cases (for example, the user might be using the word processor as a document layout package) I doubt those edge cases can be programmed away; user intervention is required. Microsoft solves that after the paste. That may be the better solution.
- podperson 13y agoYou can't program away edge cases, but the current standard behavior fails in the bog standard common case.