2 ms·
I don't think that makes much sense. Besides trying to understand what "best" means, what does "have a king" mean? Does the UK's queen count as still having a k
by dalke 13y ago
I don't think that makes much sense. Besides trying to understand what "best" means, what does "have a king" mean? Does the UK's queen count as still having a king? What about Canada's queen?
Let's take Spain as a sample. The king abdicated in 1873, with the First Spanish Republic (parliament) until the end of 1874. Then was the Bourbon restoration where the king first had parliament, but later backed a dictator) until 1931. Then the Second Spanish Republic until 1939 and the rise of Franco's dicatorship, until 1976, followed by a transition to parliamentary democracy, with the first elections in 1977.
That's 3 different transitions to a republican form of government. Two were not successful.
Or, how do you count the English Civil War and the brief Commonwealth of England in the 1650s?
What of the short-lived French Republic? The result of the Haitian Revolution? The democracy of Iran overthrown in 1953 by royalist forces supported and funded by CIA and MI6, and then the monarchy overthrown in 1979 by the Iranian Revolution?
Or Weimar Republic Germany, after the imperialism of the First World War. It famously had to deal with hyperinflation from paying war reparations. In 1930, President Hindenburg assumed dictatorial emergency powers, leading towards the end of the constitution and the start of Nazi Germany in 1933. The belief in Germany at the time, I'm told, was that the Weimar era showed that democracy was a failure.
Also, what's your baseline reference? "Is it best to have a king first then later transition to democracy" compared to ... what?
- argonaut 13y agoDon't get distracted by unimportant semantics. OP could rephrase the point as "strong central leader with absolutist powers vs. democracy." The fact that some of your examples fall on somewhere on a linear scale between the two doesn't really detract from your ability to evaluate the point.
- dalke 13y agoYes, that is one of the several possible interpretations I thought of. My goal was to point out that the query, as given, is too ambiguous for a meaningful response. In US history, this is our second organizational system. The Articles of Confederation was too decentralized, so we decided on a stronger federal system. So if the US system is judged as "the best", then it's an example of where a more decentralized form of government is better than going from a centralized power. The Swiss confederation might be another example. But change the meaning of "the best" slightly, perhaps so that Iceland tops the list, then there will be totally different answers.