5 ms·
> 2033: 100 per cent of our energy from solar If he means solar becomes economically competitive for general purpose household and industrial power generation
by Zigurd 13y ago
> 2033: 100 per cent of our energy from solar
If he means solar becomes economically competitive for general purpose household and industrial power generation in most places on Earth by 2033, ok, but that's just the starting line for an incredible amount of capex needed to replace fossil fuels.
- joosters 13y ago100% ? Does he really think that people will abandon geothermal and hydroelectric power where they are already freely/easily available?
- Zigurd 13y agoHydro power is proven economical, but it can be, approximately, tripled worldwide IF you displace tens of millions of people. In North America only small increments can be added.
- a-priori 13y agoI don't understand why 100% solar would be a good thing. Sure, it could hypothetically meet our daytime demands, but what about night time? There's only two options there: import power from another time zone where the sun shines, or store the energy during the day. The first is very lossy: HVDC is the most efficient way to transport bulk electricity, and it loses 3.5% per 1000km. You would need to transport electricity about half the way around the earth of the earth's circumference, or about 20,000km, meaning you would lose about 50% in transit. So this would depend on a drastically more efficient way of transporting power (superconducting power lines?). The second is not possible with current battery technology. And that still doesn't answer why this arrangement would be better than a nuclear (base load) + solar (daytime variable load) + natural gas (nighttime/cloudy conditions variable load) mix.
- VLM 13y agoBinary thinking... option 3 don't use electricity (at least not much) at night. It may be that aluminum electrorefineries and data centers simply have to be installed next to hydro plants instead of solar plants. And CNC machine tool plants will only operate when the sun is up. So be it.
- pilom 13y agoStorage on this scale is almost never done with batteries. Today its done with pumping water up to a reservoir while we have power and then letting it flow back down through generators when we don't have power. This is know as "Pumped Storage." Current best efficiencies are around 75% (you get out 75% of the energy you put in). The problem is that there are only so many places on earth where you can build these dual reservoirs on the scale required because of geography. Good discussion on this: http://www.withouthotair.com/c26/page_189.shtml http://www.withouthotair.com/c26/page_189.shtml
- a-priori 13y agoI didn't include pumped storage because I figured the scale of the facilities required to store one night's power demands for the continental US (for example) would be infeasible. I just did a quick calculation in Wolfram Alpha and found that (assuming perfect efficiency), to store enough energy to power the United States for half a day would take 713km^3 of water raised 1km. That's about half the volume of Lake Ontario pumped up one kilometre during the day, and down again at night. I guess that's theoretically possible but it would be a hell of a megaproject, and for what?
- kamaal 13y ago>>it would be a hell of a megaproject, and for what? Imagine some one using an oil lamp in the pre-electricity era saying this. Would it even make any sense at all to replace a perfectly working oil lamp/candle with a light bulb at the expense of century worth mining of copper, putting down massive infrastructure, setting up dams for just glowing this small time bulb? The widespread use of electricity or trains or airplanes or dams or any major paradigm changing invention in human history requires mega engineering projects for a very simple reason. You have to deliver at scale. If one can go totally without fossil fuels chasing such projects makes all the sense in the world.