3 ms·
Why do you care what kind of car someone else wants to drive? Is it this: Among a few dozen who commented last spring when legislators were debating the fee, m
by ams6110 13y ago
Why do you care what kind of car someone else wants to drive? Is it this:
Among a few dozen who commented last spring when legislators were debating the fee, many cited the environmental benefits of cars that produce zero tailpipe emissions
What's the environmental impact of a reasonably new gasoline car with catalytic converter and other emissions controls vs. the impact of coal-generated electric power for an EV? I don't know, but I would not be surprised if the EV was worse.
- brc 13y agoIf you're going to go down that route, you have to look at total vehicle ownership. That includes the manufacture and trasnport of components, total vehicle miles and costs, and many other factors. IMO the dicsussions of the benefits of electric cars should be done at the local level - where it matters. The other problem is so intractable and remote it will never be agreed. Does a Prius generate less total emissions per mile driven than a Diesel VW? That is virtually unknowable, though I am sure many people try, usually finding a result consistent with their viewpoint. The benefits of electric vehicles for local issues are: less noise and zero tailpipe emissions. This is where people should focus their attention.
- hobs 13y agoThat's an interesting question, however there is no inherent need for the electric power to be generated via coal power, whereas the gas car cannot get away from burning said fossil fuels, even though it can be made more efficient. I did some googling and there are a number of arguments on the internet about comparing a coal generated power plant's electricity emissions to a gas powered car's emissions, and I think depending on your average consumption either side could win that argument. However if the electricity was generated in not the dirtiest possible way we know how, gas car seems to lose every other time.
- lucisferre 13y agoNot to mention electric drive motors are vastly more efficient than internal combustion. So much so that even line losses and other non-arguments often cited by anti-EV people wouldn't make up the difference. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_car#Energy_efficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electric_car#Energy_efficiency
- salmonellaeater 13y agoFor half the US population (those in regions that use more renewable power sources), electric vehicles are equivalent to about 70mpg in terms of emissions, so they're a clear win. In the regions that use mostly coal, it's more like 35mpg, so a really efficient gasoline-powered car is a better choice.[1] However, I'd argue that even a car that gets 35mpg is better than average and its use should be encouraged. [1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2013/07/21/are-electric-cars-really-that-polluting/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2013/07/21/are-electr...