3 ms·
It's still ludicrous. I'm not a civil engineer, but I was discussing this with my friends who are. In summary, the amount of damage that a vehicle does to a roa
by kstrauser 13y ago
It's still ludicrous. I'm not a civil engineer, but I was discussing this with my friends who are. In summary, the amount of damage that a vehicle does to a road is proportional to the fourth power of its weight.
A Nissan Leaf weighs 3,291 pounds (source: http://www.nissanusa.com/electric-cars/leaf/versions-specs/ http://www.nissanusa.com/electric-cars/leaf/versions-specs/). A GMC Yukon Denali weighs 5,491 pounds (source: http://www.gmc.com/yukon-denali-luxury-suv/features-specs/capabilities.html http://www.gmc.com/yukon-denali-luxury-suv/features-specs/ca...), or 1.67 times more. It should do approximately 7.75 more damage to the roads it drives over than the Leaf will.
At an average of 15,000 per year, the Yukon owner getting 16 mpg (source: average of 14mpg city and 18mpg highway from http://www.gmc.com/yukon-denali-luxury-suv/features-specs/powertrain.html http://www.gmc.com/yukon-denali-luxury-suv/features-specs/po...) will burn about 950 gallons of gas per year. At $0.563 per gallon tax (source: combined state and federal taxes from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_taxes_in_the_United_States http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_taxes_in_the_United_States), that owner will pay about $550 per year in taxes.
If NC is being honest about their reasons for taxing electric vehicle owners, then the Yukon owner is being subsidized about $225 a year (should pay: $775, will pay: $550) for driving a more polluting, more damaging vehicle. That's assuming that electricity is completely untaxed in NC so that the Leaf driver is paying only that $100 tax.
TL;DR This isn't about fundraising. It's about protecting gas-burning vehicle markets.
- maxerickson 13y agoRoughly 0 people that are presently considering an electric car are concerned about $100 a year.
- sgustard 13y agoThey might care because (1) a $100 tax can quickly grow to several times that, and (2) it's a slap in the face for doing the right thing.
- maxerickson 13y agoSo do you think it is going to stop a lot of people from buying electric cars or are you just being picky? Because I meant that it probably wasn't really going to stop very many people from buying electric cars (so it is then strange to assume it is about protecting the market for ICE cars).
- bri3d 13y agoI do generally agree, but it's worth noting that in many states (including Colorado, a state which also charges a $50 EV fee), registration cost is based on vehicle weight and so the Yukon owner will pay a (still disproportionately low) greater amount.
- rbritton 13y agoIn more northern states tires play a huge factor in road damage as well. The most noticeable road damage here in the Washington/Idaho/Montana area is from studded tires. The ruts from those tires are often an inch or more deep when they finally start repairs.