6 ms·
Google Shuts Down Schemer
- Theodores 13y agoNever heard of it. To me this is not comparable to the tragic slaying of the RSS Reader. We will live.
- cbhl 13y agoIs this just an acqui-hire?
- jmaha 13y agoIt was a Slide project I believe. Slide was shuttered a few years ago, along with some gift/pet apps, but Schemer came out the tail end of it and survived for a little bit. It was never promoted or associated with Google much, so there's really no sense in keeping it around.
- dobbsbob 13y agoSame, another Google product I've never heard of. When I read the headline I assumed it was some PaaS for Scheme. Guess I'll have to make due with Racket on Yandex cloud.
- JD557 13y agoNever heard of it, although it seems like a nice project. Is there any alternative out there? I would like to try it out.
- prezjordan 13y agoLift maybe? https://lift.do/ https://lift.do/
- sahaskatta 13y agohttp://upout.com http://upout.com
- jlees 13y agoFor couples, http://www.howaboutwe.com http://www.howaboutwe.com is actually pretty fun. If you live in SF.
- nobodyshere 13y agoAs of lately, Google has only been good at shutting down things.
- qntmfred 13y agoThat and making money.
- hypotenice 13y agoAnd attracting trolls evidently.
- VLM 13y agoA traffic graph would be interesting. It was incredibly popular fad about a year ago for about a week, then crickets.
- martindale 13y agoGreat chance to check out Offline! I use it pretty regularly for things here in the Triangle: https://www.get-offline.com/ https://www.get-offline.com/
- RankingMember 13y agoRequires a facebook account? C'mon fellas.
- AbraKdabra 13y agoI can't imagine what was going on the devs head when they decided this would be a good idea.
- eropple 13y agoPerhaps that basically everyone has a Facebook account and that catering to people who don't or who make a big deal about using it to connect within a social environment are probably not a worthwhile target market? Or maybe they're tragically out of touch. (I'll go with the first one.)
- shalalala 13y agoI would go with tragically out of touch, but then again maybe I'm sane.
- Corvus 13y agoGlad to see it go. I signed up a while ago and soon deleted the app; 99% of the "schemes" it sent me were pure advertising. E.g. "Eat at this restaurant", "Go to this casino", "Donate money to this charity", "Book a trip with this travel agency for 10% off!".
- blake8086 13y agoSeems like gwern predicted this: http://www.gwern.net/Google%20shutdowns#predictions http://www.gwern.net/Google%20shutdowns#predictions
- nadaviv 13y agoI wonder why, in the least risky list, he puts Translate before AdWords. There's no way Google will shutdown their money making machine, much less likely than shutting down Google Translate. Am I missing something? What's so special about Translate?
- jfoster 13y agoHe used an algorithmic model (using factors like hits over lifetime) to predict the shutdowns. It wasn't that he decided on the ordering.
- nadaviv 13y agoAh, I see. I should've probably continue reading it before asking. However, it does say something about the algorithm if it scores Translate higher than AdWords (it should probably be first, even before Search - I think they're more likely to return results completely based on AdWords with no organic results at all than shut down AdWords and return only organic results).
- wodenokoto 13y agoNo, it says something about adwords compared to other google services. Normal predictors for shutting down google services doesn't apply to it, because it is very different in its behavior than other google services. That doesn't make it a bad algorithm.
- jfoster 13y agoStatistical algorithms that make predictions based on signals can't make good predictions about something that is unlike they've seen before. The algorithm being used does consider profitability. Even if you added "massive profitability" as a signal to AdWords, an algorithm would still struggle because it's the first and only data point like that for Google. They have decent other businesses (hosting, enterprise, etc.), but none in the same class as AdWords.
- spyhole 13y agoanother "Google's Schemer" has been set up! The time has come for Schemer users to save their data to http://www.huing.com http://www.huing.com