6 ms·
Banks Say No to Marijuana Money, Legal or Not
- argumentum 13y agoBitcoin to the rescue .. ?
- polarix 13y agoThe BTC ATM market is ready to heat up in a big way.
- gargarplex 13y agoAre your initials GP?
- smtddr 13y agoFirst thing that came to mind. This is one way bitcoin helps people; when banks start refusing to allow you to use your money how you want. Remember when wikileaks couldn't get donations because "pressure" was put on paypal, mastercard & visa not to process those payments? Bitcoin. Wanna donate to the piratebay? Anonymous? ...bitcoin. Megacorps wanna donate to a political campaign without being found out later on? ....bitcoin.
- kungfooguru 13y agoYea, put your companies capital into a volatile, non-FDIC insured, commonly robbed medium. Genius.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Sambdala 13y agoWhen the subject at hand is about companies that don't have an option?
- cowsandmilk 13y agoI don't see what problem bitcoin solves for these businesses. The first example in the article is having to take $51,000 in cash to pay the company's taxes to the state. Bitcoin does not solve this in any fashion. I really struggle to find the problem that bitcoin solves in this situation.
- waterlesscloud 13y ago"Commonly robbed" is an exaggeration.
- azernik 13y agoThat's the beauty of it - you don't need to use bitcoin to store your capital. Just use it to get money from your customers to a hard-currency account, which I would guess is easier with BTC than with large quantities of physical cash. There's risk in the movement of a day's cash flow by BTC, but probably not much higher than the risk of transferring cash in your personal car.
- maqr 13y agoIt's really important to understand that bitcoin is not anonymous by default, and it might well be less anonymous than cash by default. I know there are solutions to anonymizing BTC, but for the average person who bought some BTC from a service online and used it to send a transaction to a political campaign or TPB or wherever, I wouldn't call it any more anonymous than paypal.
- spikels 13y agoExactly right but these buyers & sellers don't care about anonymity too much. It is the banks who are worried. If governments were really devious they would replace their cash with a non-anonymous cryptocurrency like BitCoins. That would make it hate for the underground economy to avoid the police or taxation.
- asperous 13y agoThe services online aren't broadcasting the names of the people using their addresses- so it's basically anonymous to the common person. It's true that without using a mixer (aka "money launderer") Big Government could seize the service to get your name... but what about https://localbitcoins.com/ https://localbitcoins.com/ ?
- Crito 13y agoHow do these businesses cheaply, regularly, and reliably turn large amounts of cash into bitcoins, without going through somebody that is spooked by the Federal Government? Asking their customers to do it for them is unrealistic. Their target audience is not "HN techies", but rather "general population". Maybe in the future having the customers do it will be a realistic solution, but maybe in the future it will be fully legalized anyway...
- lukifer 13y agoIt would be a smart move on the part of stores to operate aggressively-priced LocalBitcoins sales on the side, to reduce their cash on hand.
- natrius 13y agoRaise prices for dollar purchases and discount Bitcoin purchases. After three weeks of that, 90% of customers will be paying with Bitcoin.
- rmc 13y agoYou presume every shop in the town/city will accept this BitCoin plan. If not, then punters will just switch to the shop that operates with dollars, and accepts the risks/drawbacks the shops in this article do, and you're business will fail.
- debian69 13y agolol but hsbc says yes to organised drug money!
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- spikels 13y agoSo true but HSBC's standard cartel account minimum balance is a billion dollars.
- wavefunction 13y agoNot just HSBC, Wells Fargo and Bank of America among others. Apparently domestic pot growers don't murder and rape enough to warrant service.
- dublinben 13y agoMore seriously, they don't have the kind of capital that warrants that level of service. Unsavory characters with billions of dollars are almost always able to find willing banking partners. The same isn't true of those with thousands of dollars.
- 1qaz2wsx3edc 13y agotl;dr; Banks are federally insured, marijuana is still illegal at the federal level. Policy must change.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- danso 13y agoThis is a critical distinction, and one that applies to virtually every kind of rule and policy that affects our lives. Does anyone seriously think that bankers have a moral objection to taking in money from legal pot growers? That the banking profession is in the pocket of the tobacco industry? They are reluctant because of the strange legal situation that the federal government has allowed to exist...and yet it's so tempting to yell at the banks for being unfair. Cathartic, yes, but if the situation is to be remedied, they aren't the ones who have the most leverage to effect change.
- guard-of-terra 13y ago"The Controlled Substances Act, enacted in 1970 classifies marijuana as a Schedule I drug" I wonder what people who underwrote it are doing now. (Most of them are dead for good, sure)
- lucb1e 13y agoReading this, all I can imagine is them saying to each other in a satisfied voice: "Who's making laws now, eh?" Just like with Visa blocking Wikileaks months ago and banks presently blocking Bitcoin (the Rabobank in the Netherlands leaked memo a few weeks ago that they should not facilitate Bitcoin traders), I'm not sure I like these practices. Not to mention PayPal's draconian policy. Controlling people's money is a nice power to have... (So, Bitcoin anyone?)
- pyduan 13y agoIn this case: the federal government. The banks didn't randomly decide they were against marijuana, they're just reluctant because while marijuana is legal for medicinal or recreational use in a few states it's still a Schedule I drug at the federal level, which makes it legally tricky to handle the proceedings from the marijuana business.
- Eliezer 13y agoI don't think much of Bitcoin but even I tend to read this and think, "Well, screw the banks, we have Bitcoin."
- javajosh 13y agoIf FDIC insurance is the issue, then simply offer uninsured accounts. I don't see why this is an issue.
- justincormack 13y agoIts not the issue, the issue is that these are, Federally, proceeds of crime, and could be seized by Federal law enforcement and the banks charged for money laundering offences.
- olefoo 13y agoAnd that right there is why legalization will be an unsure thing in this country for at least the next decade. If you are going into the marijuana business get good legal advice and have a competent defense lawyer on retainer. There could quite easily be a crackdown if the next president wants to revert things or is too heavily beholden to the parts of federal law enforcement that benefit from the drug war.
- nightski 13y agoWhat about the sales tax that is being collected? Is there any precedent for that?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- minimax 13y agoNot sure that really helps. They are worried about their security because they don't want to get robbed. If I can break in and hold a gun to your head until you irreversibly transfer me all your bitcoins then you have basically the same security problem. If your response is that they should keep all their bitcoins in a safe place then maybe we can think about what sorts of safe places you can keep items worth tens of thousands of dollars and then I think you basically end up back at banks.
- acd 13y agoWell a small supergroup of financial companies rules the world through central banking creating money out of thin air. Check page 4/36 http://arxiv.org/PS_cache/arxiv/pdf/1107/1107.5728v2.pdf http://arxiv.org/PS_cache/arxiv/pdf/1107/1107.5728v2.pdf
- elviejo 13y agonot all banks... just ask HSBC ;-) "Matt Taibbi: After Laundering $800 Million in Drug Money, How Did HSBC Executives Avoid Jail?" http://www.democracynow.org/2012/12/13/matt_taibbi_after_laundering_800_million http://www.democracynow.org/2012/12/13/matt_taibbi_after_lau...
- falsestprophet 13y agoBanks aren't the only place to safely store money and transmit money. Is there any reason an armored car service can't pick up marijuana industry cash and sell these businesses cash equivalent securities that are not at risk of being stolen (like short term federal or Colorado bonds)? It could be that insurance companies would not cover armored car services for marijuana industry clients, but presumably it would be possible to raise rates to cover expected losses (FBI data shoes that only 7 armored cars were robbed in 2010). edit: This sounds vaguely like a valid business plan. One could start a Colorado-only Colorado-regulated bond broker-dealer. This broker dealer could cooperate with armored car services to move cash from marijuana industry clients to the broker's bank (or to the State of Colorado as payment for bonds). Marijuana industry clients would be unburdened from carrying large physical cash positions and free from a great deal of counter party risk because the marijuana industry clients would own liquid bonds.
- gloverkcn 13y agoThe problem is that armored car companies currently have no have no ability offer that service. All pickups are settled through settlement accounts at banks. You cannot take deposits without falling under federal regulatory compliance. The state needs to pass laws creating or making possible the creation of a state approved depository. This could begin to undermine the power of the fed and start a. It states rights battle
- adekok 13y ago> You cannot take deposits without falling under federal regulatory compliance. It sounds like there's a need for a "safety deposit box delivery" service. They'll deliver a safety box to you, which you fill with whatever makes you happy. You close it, and they pick up the filled and locked box. It then gets stored in a secure vault. That would avoid a lot of fear surrounding the personal transport of money. It sounds to me like a business ready for disruption.
- acgourley 13y agoHow do you insure such a black box?
- sxp 13y ago>While they are active, however, these accounts may have informal restrictions placed on them — some self-imposed — so they do not draw the scrutiny of bankers who may file suspicious-activity reports or would be required to report deposits over $10,000 in cash. The account holders may make only small deposits, and only at night and at certain branches. Mr. Kunkel of Seattle has such an account. That's not a good thing to admit to a newspaper. Even if the federal rules allow legal marijuana sales, he could still be in trouble for structuring: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structuring http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Structuring
- socrates1998 13y agoThe irony that banks take a stand against these small time shop owners is ridiculous, they are all guilty of laundering billions of dollars. I can see smaller credit unions being genuinely concerned, but big banks? Really? It allows them to claim they follow the rules without actually hurting their bottom lines.
- sergers 13y agoi live in vancouver BC canada. nearly every medical marijuana dispensary i have been to have been accepting DEBIT/INTERAC/MASTERCARD/VISA etc without any issue for about 2 years now
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- refurb 13y agoThe thing that helps in Canada is that the medical marijuana legislation was done at the federal level. Banks don't have to worry about violating any laws in regards to working the with medical marijuana businesses.
- memracom 13y agoReading between the lines, it seems that US Federal law is driving the creation of an alternative banking system. This would not be a bad thing considering the amount of concentration in the banking system and how that led to the recent big banking bust.
- asdkl234890 13y agoWell there is no such thing as federally legal marijuana yet, right?
- Crito 13y agoThere actually is, but in an extremely limited form. There are currently four living people that receive medical marijuana from the federal government. They were grandfathered in after the Compassionate Investigational New Drug program was closed to new applicants in 1992. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compassionate_Investigational_New_Drug_program#Remaining_patients http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compassionate_Investigational_N...
- Zenst 13y agoSad fact is this will either impact or open up a new market to some 3rd party to offer what the banks will not. Then once estabilished and working the banks will either compete or borg the company. Profit for banks has a dynamic moral, wait and see.
- llcoolv 13y agopun aside, but don't these precautions seem a bit too paranoid or is it just me? :D
- auntienomen 13y agoImagine that you're known to be regularly moving around in an unarmored car with $50K. Would you take a chance that you get the robber who won't just shoot you dead?
- JosephHatfield 13y agoJust saw a recent news post reporting the executives at High Times are about to start a private-equity fund called the HTG Fund that will provide and cash and credit to cannabis-related businesses. Wonder if they'll also be able to provide advice on handling large amounts of cash.
- Freestyler_3 13y ago> advice on handling large amounts of cash. I will always be willing to accept gifts. Hey if there is a topic about drugs on a tech forum, I don't think the established ethics apply.
- briandear 13y agoThe irony here is that HSBC escaped criminal prosecution for laundering cartel money. There was a recent rolling stone article about it. The solution might be for these places to use offshore banks, but then you add another layer of complications.
- VladRussian2 13y agothe moment somebody comes with a real solution for marijuana sellers may happen to be an "Ice Age" style crack in the banking business. Forcing people to invent ways to workaround the system may be not good for the system in the long run.
- patio11 13y agoIt's curious how HNers can simultaneously say "Serves those banksters at HSBC right -- finally, the government decides to fine them a billion dollars for laundering drug money" and then "Pfft, getting your bank accounts shut down for being in marijuana is a silly problem to have -- here, I'll describe a foolproof money laundering strategy which could get seen through by an eight year old. That should keep things square with the banks and their regulators, wink wink."
- gaius 13y agoTo be completely fair, HSBC didn't launder anything - they were used to launder money, and were fined for not detecting it. I do wonder if the average HNer hasn't really thought this through. It's no different from the govt fining Google because they didn't flag up people discussing drugs in their GMail.
- anonbanker 13y agothey should all start banking in Canada. Water's fine here.
- chaostheory 13y agoTDLR > Though 20 states and the District of Columbia allow either medical or recreational marijuana use — with more likely to follow suit — the drug remains illegal under federal law. > As a result, banks, including state-chartered ones, are reluctant to provide traditional services to marijuana businesses. They fear that federal regulators and law enforcement authorities might punish them, with measures like large fines, for violating prohibitions on money-laundering, among other federal laws and regulations.