6 ms·
Nintendo acquires "troll's" patent portfolio after legal victory
- jmaygarden 13y agoIs the patent troll moniker appropriate in this case? Wasn't IA Labs actually building and trying to sell similar products?
- eloff 13y agoNot really a patent troll. Too aggressive in defending their patents, yes, but will within their rights to try. Especially as it appeared to them that their ideas had been ripped off after they pitched them to Nintendo.
- egeozcan 13y agoA patent troll is a company with the sole purpose of, well, patent trolling (Collecting patents, waiting for a successful target and suing them for profit, not for keeping competitive advantage) In this case, I don't see that. They may be called over-aggressive, evil even but not patent trolls.
- josephagoss 13y agoCome on! IA Labs built similar tech and met with Nintendo before the wii remote was announced, if I was in their shoes I would sue too. Unfortunately Nintendo had already created the tech and had evidence, so IA Labs run themselves into the ground. I would not label IA Labs a troll, thats not fair and misrepresents what was going on.
- Jormundir 13y agoIA labs developed their own technology and weren't just suing because they owned a patent, but because they thought their competitive advantage gained from development was being infringed upon. So they aren't a patent troll. This case does, however, seem to be a solid win for reasonable patent law enforcement. The precedence from this appears to be: if you over-step or over attack using your patent portfolio, you'll pay a big price. Hopefully this will help those defending legal disputes with real patent trolls moving forward.
- iwwr 13y agoThis will merely make trolls create shell companies for each individual lawsuit. If a shell loses a lawsuit (i.e. patent found invalid), the winner can just pick up a lot of nothing.
- kika 13y agoThis shell company can not own nothing, it have to own the patent(s) in question.
- sehrope 13y ago> This shell company can not own nothing, it have to own the patent(s) in question. Does it? IANAL but I believe it's possible to license the rights associated with a patent without transferring complete ownership. The shell organization would be a sub-licensee that does your dirty work.
- cbhl 13y agoIs it possible to license away the right to sue someone for infringing, though?
- kika 13y agoI believe it's called "legal representation" :-)
- mjolk 13y agoThink this through, why would someone licensed a piece of tech be able to use on its behalf? This is like saying that I have the rights to use the Unity engine, so I should be able to sue Microsoft for parts of Silverlight that I think are infringing and profit personally.
- sehrope 13y agoI'm not saying that all licenses have this property. I'm saying it may be possible to create a custom one that does. For example a "standard" software license (proprietary ... not OSS) does not include the right to sub-license but there do exist software licenses that include that right. Having a license doesn't mean you can sue. Having a "license to sue" might though! (if it can exist)
- paul9290 13y agoIt's pretty bad that this whole patents are evil moniker/sentiment has risen in the past few years. Seems to be great for page views! Not everyone with a patent is a troll, rather many are the little guy who were not able to win the race because A) they don't have enough resources or B) they couldn't rally enough troops to get behind them. Thus a patent is a way to stake a claim and protect their invention. If it's worth something then others will copy it and due to sheer luck make it a success. While you the inventor are left with an empty bag and oh a patent that you can try and use to be rewarded for your invention.
- nova 13y ago> Not everyone with a patent is a troll, rather many are the little guy who were not able to win the race because A) they don't have enough resources or B) they couldn't rally enough troops to get behind them In other words, the patent system benefits big companies with big lawyer armies and trolls with nothing to lose, and is useless for the little inventor who doesn't have the muscle to fight the legal war if someone copies his precious invention but now also have to worry to be the one being sued because of some obvious patent one can infringe just by breathing. But let's keep the fantasy that patents protect the little guy after all.