2 ms·
I think "ticking time bomb" analogies break down here, because the US made a deliberate policy decision at the highest levels to torture. To me, the analogy is
by nl 13y ago
I think "ticking time bomb" analogies break down here, because the US made a deliberate policy decision at the highest levels to torture.
To me, the analogy is more like this:
You are mayor of a town. There might be a ticking timebomb in a school somewhere in your town. Watches tell the time and are similar to what is used in timebombs.
Should you (a) torture everyone who looks at a watch, because they might know about a timebomb that might exist, or (b) NOT TORTURE PEOPLE.
To me there is zero justification for deciding (a) in that scenario.