2 ms·
What? You still believe in Hollywood-style good guys and bad guys? Do you think that the Japanese believed then that they were the bad guys? What a boring, pre
by nl 13y ago
What? You still believe in Hollywood-style good guys and bad guys? Do you think that the Japanese believed then that they were the bad guys?
What a boring, predictable response, that missed the whole point.
Of course I don't believe in Hollywood-style good guys vs bad guys.
But I used to believe that the US saw themselves as "good" and that self-image acted as a self-imposed limiter on deliberate policies that the US would enact.
For example, one could argue that internment of people of Japanese background during WW2 was evil. However, there possibly is an argument that some of them may have had mixed loyalties, and that acted as justification.
One might also argue that incidents like the deliberate infection of native Americans with smallpox were evil, but they localized incidents, and not something that was endorsed at the highest levels of government.
I don't agree with either of these excuses, but I see that there is an argument one could make.
But to stoop as low as a policy of deliberate torture and pretend that is justified is beyond my understanding. I cannot see how anyone can truly believe in their justifications for that - except if they believe those that are being tortured are less than human.
- arethuza 13y agoI remember being slightly puzzled by a line in Cryptonomicon where the Colt 45 was described as being created to stop some particularly tough Philippine rebels - I remember wondering who they were rebelling against... I found out recently (yesterday) that the US occupation of the Philippines in the Philippine–American War was particularly brutal - here is a clipping from the NY Time describing the "water cure": http://query.nytimes.com/mem/archive-free/pdf?_r=1&res=9F07E3D61130E132A25757C0A9639C946397D6CF&oref=slogin http://query.nytimes.com/mem/archive-free/pdf?_r=1&res=9F07E... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philippine%E2%80%93American_War http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Philippine%E2%80%93American_War
- soperj 13y agoExcept that US didn't just intern US citizens of Japanese origin. They interned Aleutians as well. They also went up and down the continent collecting Japanese & German citizens of Latin American countries so that they could trade them for POWs. This led to problems after the war because Peru didn't want them back, and so they had to stay in the internment camps indefinitely. This continued on until an american citizen actually sued to have them be granted citizenship. They were in camps for over 3 years after the war had already ended. The only reason any of these people were interred was racism, plain and simple. Farmers in California didn't want them owning the land.
- mixmastamyk 13y agoNot the only reason, history is always more complex than we'd like it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Niihau_Incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Niihau_Incident
- soperj 13y agoThere is always justifications for racism. 3 people helping someone out before the U.S had even declared war on Japan doesn't really seem like a very good reason to intern native americans, does it?
- mixmastamyk 13y agoHindsight is always 20/20. Yes, I'm able to say in perfect safety 70 years after the fact that it was a mistake. If I had been alive and asked on Dec 10, 1941 the same question, I doubt I'd give the same answer.
- soperj 13y agoI understand where you're coming from, and I think that a lot of people would(and do) agree with you. But it's the same as standing up now and saying that the NSA spying on ordinary citizens is wrong. If it's wrong, it should be wrong, and nothing can justify it.
- mixmastamyk 13y agoOk, but the original question was not whether it was wrong, but rather was it "the only reason". Didn't mean to imply it was ever right.
- WalterBright 13y ago> One might also argue that incidents like the deliberate infection of native Americans with smallpox were evil, but they localized incidents, and not something that was endorsed at the highest levels of government. This is more myth than fact, and also predated the US by decades: http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/1088/did-whites-ever-give-native-americans-blankets-infected-with-smallpox http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/1088/did-whites-eve...