3 ms·
Over the last 10 years, salaries have largely flattened out and while in increase in people in given area has meant demand didn't. Cost of living being high and
by bane 13y ago
Over the last 10 years, salaries have largely flattened out and while in increase in people in given area has meant demand didn't. Cost of living being high and getting higher and salaries aren't able to keep up means people don't move there.
Why struggle, working 16 hour days to move up in a career so you can afford the $700k 2000 sq ft home on a postage stamp sized property in a so-so part of town when you can move to Arkansas, work at a remote development shop and afford a $350k 4000 sq ft home in a gated community with and acre and a half of wooded property with an in-ground pool?
- jasonwocky 13y ago> Why struggle, working 16 hour days to move up in a career so you can afford the $700k 2000 sq ft home on a postage stamp sized property in a so-so part of town when you can move to Arkansas, work at a remote development shop and afford a $350k 4000 sq ft home in a gated community with and acre and a half of wooded property with an in-ground pool? That's a pretty big strawman. There are tons of other options for someone , and not all of us and our families need 4000 sq ft (or even 2000 sq ft) and 1.5 acres of property to be happy. I like living in densely populated areas rather than the equivalent of a personal ivory tower. I think that American dream of owning a big house with a huge amount of property has done more harm than good.
- bane 13y agoI'm just presenting a possible equation that describes the phenomenon in question. Lots of people ask themselves similar questions, but with different metrics. - Why live in an old 400 sq ft efficiency with exposed ductwork and pipes <80th st. Manhattan when I can live 15 minutes away in Williamsburg and have a modern 2 bedroom for the same price? - Why live in SF, making below market wages working for some startup, renting a bedroom in some guy's basement, when I could live in a deluxe 3rd floor walkup in Sunnyvale? - Why live in either place when I can take a dev job near Miami and enjoy round the year sun and beach, own a house and have a better cost of living anyway? I'm not saying I agree with these questions, or the motivations behind them. But then again, I live in a very walkable, high service suburb instead of the nearest big metro area also. But I'd just as happily live in a small 2 br in NY. I grew up pretty rural and remember asking myself questions like - Why do I have to spend 2+ hours a day driving to/from work every day? - Wouldn't it be nice if I could live in a place where I could walk 5-10 minutes to get any of my basic services taken care of? - Wouldn't it be great to live in a place where I simply didn't need a car? - I'd like to have more people nearby to associate with. - etc. So I get the desire both ways.
- autarch 13y agoYou seem to be suggesting that 2000sf is small, but to me that seems huge. I live in a 1200sf house in Minneapolis with my wife. When we move, we'll probably be looking at houses slightly larger (so we can fit a grand piano), but we definitely don't need 2000sf, much less 4000!
- bane 13y agoIt's amazing how big newer housing is, and in location that aren't that far from older, smaller housing that costs only slightly less. For example, in my area, there's a sizable development that was built during the 50s and 60s. The average home is under 2000 sq ft and pretty nice for the time (lots of split levels). 3 or 4 bedroom etc. Lots are .25 to .5 acre. But being older homes you can't, for example, fit a king bed in any of those homes. Or modern bathrooms, where 2 people can get ready in the morning at the same time don't exist there. You might be able to cram a grand piano into one of the larger basements, with nothing else, or replace the family room with it in a tight squeeze. The crime rate is up in this area, and last year a woman was found chopped up and stuffed into a set of suitcases that were dumped behind some dumpsters at the nearest McDonalds. Schools are old and run down, they just shut down the last remaining library, there's 1 public pool and though shopping is plentiful, it's all a 15-20 minute drive away. The next area over was built in the early 2000s during the boom and the town houses start at 2400 sq ft. It's almost insane. A smaller single family with a finished basement starts at around 3200 sq ft and the average size is pushing up on 4000 sq ft. Lots are about .25 acre. The difference in price between the two locations is $0 for the town houses and about $100-150 for the smaller single-family. I'd also add that the schools in the newer area are all new and very nice, shopping is better, there's convenient walking to local town centers, public transport to the metro system and the nearest cities. The neighborhoods are all fiber internet have in-neighborhood police/fire "public safety centers", several neighborhood pools and plentiful community activities -- among other amenities. So all things being equal, you may not be happier with the larger home, but it doesn't hurt, and the neighborhood is a lot nicer.