3 ms·
It seems most of them don't show any kind of remorse and instead insist they had been doing the right thing all along. For example, Erich Priebke, who died las
by bambax 13y ago
It seems most of them don't show any kind of remorse and instead insist they had been doing the right thing all along.
For example, Erich Priebke, who died last year, aged 100, always declared he was only "obeying orders" in setting up the massacre of 335 people (including children). Not only that, but his own son has always defended him and his actions.
This kind of attitude doesn't help much with forgiveness.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erich_Priebke http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erich_Priebke
- ItendToDisagree 13y agoNot defending Erich in any way, but the "obeying orders" excuse has been used by US Soldiers in Iraq (among other stories regarding previous wars in history and involving other countries' soldiers). Do you think they should be executed? The Nazi's were one of the first instances of prosecution for soldiers who were following orders when committing war crimes (in the case of concentration camps the scale may be the marker) so it is an interesting question. Seriously asking and not trying to be inflammatory. It is seriously just an interesting concern of where "following orders" stops being a valid excuse. For instance should drone operators controlling, attacks that kill a whole wedding convoy, be prosecuted for following orders? Weird world we live in. Again not defending Erich Priebke just a jumping off point for interesting discussion. Edit: Fix spelling
- bambax 13y ago> Do you think they should be executed? Yes. Not "executed", and not every soldier in every war; but torturers who hide behind orders should absolutely be brought to justice. Of course, if their country as a whole decides torture is suddenly ok, or even cool (see most recent TV shows), then that won't happen. The fact that it won't happen in the case of the US doesn't excuse the Nazis... or anyone, really.
- ItendToDisagree 13y agoI tend to agree. I really think there are two metrics. Genuine remorse and the ability to concede that the actions were wrong or misguided. I find it dismaying that currently our culture (most of the world, not just US) seems to have gone backwards in terms of recognizing torture/misguided killing/execution as a serious issue. There really is no excuse for such behavior, although happens in times of conflict, it should be accounted for at some point. The ability of a country or people to recognize the wrongs of their past and move forward, rather than denying that they were wrong, seems an important thing.
- hershel 13y agoPriebke is quite a unique example. Most nazi's who took part in such behaviors had other options: for example , many could have chosen not to be part of the "death squads". This might mean they would advance less in the ranks and might become regular wwii soldiers which isn't the best life. Priebke got hit orders from hitler. Altought there are a few who disobeyed a direct order from hitler and lived to tell about it, Priebke, in his a circumstances would have probably been executed.
- yetanotherphd 13y agoI don't see how that one single example can be counted as evidence that German who participated in war crimes were less apologetic than Japanese.