3 ms·
If nothing else, they are implying that they are entitled to living there indefinitely.
by adamnemecek 13y ago
If nothing else, they are implying that they are entitled to living there indefinitely.
- chrislgrigg 13y agoAre they? I'm not so sure. They have a right to feel upset that money has disrupted (and not in some cool buzzword startup kind of way) their way of life by driving up the cost of living without trickling down to them. A lot of what was written struck me as sour grapes, frustration at the ease with which some people live while they slave away, but it doesn't change the fact that gentrification can destroy communities and culture.
- fennecfoxen 13y agoSociety has a variety of ways to entitle people to live somewhere. One involves purchasing the property. You could also enter into a lease with your landlord that gives you the right to renew for a very, very long time (which you'll pay for, of course, if you get it.) Now, if you want to talk about rising property taxes driving people out, that's a legit thing to talk about, but really more of a NYC problem than SF.
- sophacles 13y agoUm, that is exactly the same claim the counter arguments are making: "we're entitled to move in wherever we want" I know I'd be pissed if my community - not the place I happen to live, but the actively built relationships I have with people in my neighborhood (years of freindship, acquaintance, understanding and so on) - were disrupted because a bunch of new people showed up and forced that community to be scattered by mechanisms such as "we can't afford the rent anymore". There is a lot of value that is destroyed. It isn't monetary, but it is a form of wealth. That is a real problem. I get that a lot of people don't give a shit about interpersonal things, and think the notion of community is pointless. But a lot of us do care. Basic decency should suggest paying attention to this sort of thing. Just because you have more money than someone, doesn't mean you get to kick apart their world. Building a new community for oneself, a deep one anyway, is not easy, and gets harder when you have to keep doing it - you start to say "what's the point - I don't have enough money and time to do this again the next time the better off need a new playground".
- ameister14 13y agoYou can protect your community. If you have something valuable, people are going to want to purchase it. Decline their offer. If you don't actually own the thing, but the person that does is a member of your community, persuade them not to sell. What you don't do is break the valuable thing hoping the would-be buyers go away, or blame them for wanting the thing you value.
- sophacles 13y agoThis is a beautifully off point solution! Should my community start getting disrupted by higher rent, (half my neighborhood is long-term tenants, there is not rent control here, or anything like that), I will surely tell the people who don't own the apartments they rent to not sell!
- ameister14 13y agoWho owns the apartments? Talk to them. If they're not members of your community, work with your city council to pass ordinances making that arrangement more difficult. Why would the rent be higher if the people that own the apartments didn't raise it? They have a choice in this; they can live the way they did two years ago.
- sophacles 13y agoThese things are shown time and again to not work for many reasons: * landlords just want the rent, and any "scum" (by which I mean employed and decent tenants that don't pay as much) need to get packing. * city councils want the higher taxes. Good citizens just don't count unless they pay more. * the police get in on the act and start hassling people who don't look like they belong (aka not in the new, higher class) * cost of living goes up even if half the old population stays there. new businesses are forced in by crazy eminent domain tricks. It's the same old gentrification story: some new folks with more money want it, so they take it without regarding that they are displacing a whole bunch of good people (along with some bad ones) who are now force to rebuild their lives. I'm not against progress, I'm against "progress" that disrupts people who did nothing wrong for reasons that are basically needless.