5 ms·
Dear designers: COLUMNS DO NOT BELONG ON THE WEB. If you want a thin column for design reasons, hey, go for it, but I hate scrolling down, then up, then down,
by jerf 17y ago
Dear designers: COLUMNS DO NOT BELONG ON THE WEB.
If you want a thin column for design reasons, hey, go for it, but I hate scrolling down, then up, then down, then up, then sideways (in my browser there's a horizontal scroll on that page right now). ONE thin column. ONE. I should be able to read your page with my hand on the space bar and nothing else.
Think of this as the equivalent of the suggestion that no matter how awesome your 10" x 15" design may be, when it needs to fit on a 8"x11.5" paper it doesn't work. Jamming columns into this medium is simply bringing over old, inapplicable biases to a new medium; work with the medium, not against it.
- blasdel 17y agoYou're right, tall vertical columns are total shit on a screen. But fixed-height horizontally scrolling columns are AMAZING: http://amarsagoo.info/tofu/ http://amarsagoo.info/tofu/ -- they work so perfectly on a screen when done well, better than anything else by far. The lines always stay in the same vertical alignment, and the columns in the same horizontal alignment, eliminating jitter -- the text changes without moving shit around.
- jerf 17y agoInteresting. I'd like to see a video of that in action. I'm skeptical still, but I'm also a person who has no problem with the current status quo. I was reading books on my 160x160 Palm Pilot with little objection. This appears to make me an outlier. (I think it may because I started on the Commodore 64 on a regular television; against that reading experience, a clean 160x160 is still an improvement!) Properly done that could work. Do you use it? When you scroll over one or more columns, the system jumps column-wise, right? Not like a scrollbar would on a normal web page, which wouldn't jump to columns at all, and would have problems with half-displayed columns (which are useless).
- blasdel 17y agoI used to use Tofu incessantly when I used Macs at home + work, I've been meaning to write a clone in some X toolkit or XUL for a while. You have it exactly right, it jumps one column at a time XOR one screen's worth at a time. When you first set it up you tweak not just the font + colors, but the width + padding of the columns. I used to use it on my 12" PowerBook all the time, set up with one of the Vista fonts in light lavender on very-dark gray, with two columns fit onto the 1024x768 screen with the window maximized. I read millions of words that way, it's easily the fastest and least-fatiguing reading method I've used, though the ergonomics of the laptop ain't great.
- psadauskas 17y agoI've been wondering lately if there shouldn't be two ways to do page layout. CSS + HTML is awesome for documents, which 99% of the web is. However, it seems like lots of people really want "brochure"-type pages, with crazy fonts, specific positioning of boxes of text and images, and lots of graphics. From looking around, it seems like every single one has to go through some horrible contortions of CSS and nested wrapper divs. I'm not sure which is the best approach, you either end up with a page looking like 37signal's landing page, or you have 8MB of images and 30 absolute positioned divs, ala CSS Xen Garden. I'm a programmer, not a designer, but every time I try to put together a front page that looks good, both to the user's eye and to the HTML maintainer's, I feel like I'm really fighting the natural way of doing it. I wish it was better, but I'm at a loss as to how.
- DrJokepu 17y agoIt's called pdf and it's there. Adobe Reader supports all sorts of webbish features such as hyperlinks or JavaScript. For some reason, it's not very popular as a hypertext document format (and neither are MS Word documents, an other similar contender)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- malkia 17y agoI hate when I read .ps/.pdf formatted files in columns. I have to rotate my MacBook Pro to read them in one page :)
- anigbrowl 17y agoYeah, that pretty much destroys their design cred straight away. Putting the close icon on the top-left of the popup boxes removed all doubt. Good web design is very precious. Unfortunately, so are many less-skilled designers.
- DrJokepu 17y agoDunno, it's a pretty subjective thing, isn't it? Maybe the target audience of their design on this site wasn't programmers (who all love nitpicking on usability issues) but other designers, maybe future employers who care for different things than someone with a techical or engineering background would.
- greyfade 17y agoQuite, indeed. These pussyboy designers need to go shoot themselves. It's bad enough @font-face exists now, but to tout its virtues on a completely unreadable website? Come the fuck ON.