5 ms·
Don't Ignore the Trolls. Feed Them Until They Explode.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThe article is ridiculous: Criado-Perez's crime? Advocating (successfully) for Jane Austen to appear on a £10 banknote...Doesn't she know that money is man-paper!? A woman is already on every piece of British currency that I can find in my pocket. https://www.google.com/search?q=british+money&source=lnms&tbm=isch&sa=X&ei=n9_PUuGYLsrF0QWph4CQDw&ved=0CAkQ_AUoAQ&biw=1534&bih=793 https://www.google.com/search?q=british+money&source=lnms&tb...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- CJefferson 13y agoAssuming you haven't read about this story previously, it is true that the current monarch, who is indeed a woman, appears on all currency. However, there is also a set of other people, who rotate over time and is changed. This set ended up with no women in it, and many people (including myself) considered this unacceptable.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoYes, there clearly is some substance to the complaints, it's merely the Jezabel writer who is clueless. As for the money thing, Elizabeth Fry (who?) was replaced by Winston Churchill. I don't know the criteria, but that hardly seems to be an unreasonable choice. Could you explain why it's unacceptable? Last I checked no individual (besides the Monarch) has any right to be on the money, so I don't see why any group of individuals would have the right for one of their members to be on the money. (I also freely admit I find the whole royalty thing ridiculous. But I'm a Yankee, so when I see the British hereditary monarch visiting other hereditary monarchs, typically Arab dictators, I just don't get it.)
- drcongo 13y agoIt may surprise you to know that roughly half the population of the UK is female. So doesn't it strike you as odd that off the people featured on the reverse of UK bank notes, we had a period where 100% of them were male? Surely I shouldn't need to explain this to someone in 2014.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI don't understand. There are many "odd" facts (by which I assume you mean "improbable"?), but I see no compelling reason to alter them. For example, suppose there was no one on a banknote with a last name starting with a letter from N-Z. The population of people with such last names might also be 50% of the UK. Would this situation also require changing? (Incidentally, I find it less than odd, because I'm choosing a more accurate reference class. The notable enough to be put on a banknote population of the UK is probably far less than 50% female - for example, Thatcher is the only female PM. Scientists like Newton/Darwin go on money, but there are no females of their caliber.)
- aaren 13y agoYou mistake the population of women for some arbitrary selection. I don't think that your N-Z population will be suffering from systemic oppression. Perhaps your interpretation of uk history under represents the achievements of women? We are in a transition between a past where women are under-represented and a future in which women are well-represented equal members of society. This transition is not guaranteed to happen. Small things like ensuring the representation of women on bank notes are seen as helping this transition to occur.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI don't "mistake" women for some arbitrary selection, I don't know what principle to use to distinguish between women and other subsets of Britain. Can you explain this principle? I'm not sure what "systemic oppression" is. If "systemic oppression" simply refers to individual bad acts that apply to some subpopulation at a disproportionate rate, here is a recipe for cooking up other "systemically oppressed" subsets: choose a group of 90% people who have suffered individual bad acts, throw in 10-20% more random people. You now have a group who has suffered individual bad acts at a disproportionate rate. How does your morality/political philosophy distinguish women from other statistically similar subsets? (Note that if it does not distinguish between such groups, you get an intractible ideology - there are more subsets of Britain like the one I described than there are atoms in the universe.)
- aaren 13y agoWe don't get to choose whether the queen goes on or not.
- jessaustin 13y agoSure you do; many nations have made that choice. Of course, it might not help the gender ratio on your currency. The only money I can find with a feminine picture is a dollar coin with a Native American woman.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mdisraeli 13y agoLeaving aside views on who should or should not be featured historical people rotated in and out of currency print runs, how does this one matter render the actual topic, inappropriate harassment on the internet, ridiculous? The harassment here wasn't simple disagreement, we are talking about people who considered it appropriate to make death threats, suggest Criado-Perez should actually be raped, and similar. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-25641941 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-25641941 The argument is that automated report response systems, as social media necessitates, can easily be abused to actually attack those who are undeserving of being banned. It doesn't pose a solution, however, as the world is, well... a bit shit and near-impossible to fix.
- barry-cotter 13y agoIt is a pity that the internet is full of assholes and that they send deeply vile and abusive messages. Even Gawker Media employees don't deserve that kind of shit. That said this was very funny. I'm trying to think of an instance when anonymous women descended, spewing violent rape or castration threats, upon a man for expressing an opinion as innocuous as Criado-Perez's. I can think of instances of funny, political, retaliatory trolling—like when Twitter feminists co-opted the #INeedMasculismBecause hashtag, or when Rick Perry's Facebook page was deluged with questions about menses. But those are not examples of aggression, they are self-defense. They are not analogous to "I will rape you in an alley" or "Don't leave your phone at home, sweetie." They are reactions to misogyny—the same brand of misogyny that fuels internet trolling. They are women speaking to power—the same power structure that empowers and perpetuates anonymous trolls.
- StavrosK 13y agoNo true Scotsman? If women trolling is by definition self defense, you won't find any examples of women trolling, no?
- broolstoryco 13y agojezebel on HN
- bcraven 13y agoWell observed.
- deveac 13y agoCould you put your point on HN as well?
- DanBC 13y agoIt's a shit source for a shit story that attracts a bunch of shits posts from people who I would describe as utter shits. There is nothing interesting in this submission. Perhaps so ething mily interesting wod be how they were caught, or how some company is trying to stop attacks like that, or etcetc. But this?
- cLeEOGPw 13y agoIt is just trying to appeal to feminists and white knights.
- deveac 13y ago>It's a shit source for a shit story that attracts a bunch of shits posts from people who I would describe as utter shits. I came to HN for the tech news, but stayed for the intelligent and insightful commentary.
- michalu 13y agoIt's a shame such a boring writer is to replace Charles Darwin. I can think of many women who I would like to see on a banknote other than Jane Austen. Funny enough one of the 2 abusers is actually a woman.
- j2kun 13y agoBut in her time Jane Austen's prose was considered assertive and radical, wasn't it? Just because you think her writing is boring today doesn't make her any less significant in historical context.