3 ms·
While I agree we need to come up with an answer within the context of our legal system, I really see the bigger problem as the false responsibility claims our l
by curiouscats 13y ago
While I agree we need to come up with an answer within the context of our legal system, I really see the bigger problem as the false responsibility claims our legal system encourages.
Many times there are negative results that should not result in wasteful legal proceedings but our system is so focused on pining the blame on someone to write a check that it accepts blaming x person because there isn't anyone else to blame. Often that is a bad outcome. I would welcome us examining the assumptions about everything needing to be blamed on specific parties.
I do agree there is a benefit to accessing pentalites to culpable parties. I think our current system needs to accept that complex systems often have bad results that should not be handled the way we do now.
The whole issue is very complex but I think there is a need for much better decisions about blame being made in our legal system. It requires much more understanding of science, engineering, statistics etc.. And less overly simplistic blaming based on over simplified models.
My father was a professor of statistics/industrial engineering/chemical engineering and worked some trying to get a better understanding of cause and effect into the legal system decades ago, for example http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00031305.1983.10483147#.Us90gPbxRBk http://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00031305.1983.104... I think we need to do much better in this area.