2 ms·
What are a startup's ethical responsibilities to the open source community if your startup is based on an open source stack? I'm going to go with "None whatsoe
by patio11 17y ago
What are a startup's ethical responsibilities to the open source community if your startup is based on an open source stack?
I'm going to go with "None whatsoever".
I think Zed has a point: Why aren't they open sourcing more of it?
Isn't this "Why aren't you releasing code with a license more conducive to meeting my needs?", just coming from the other end of the table?
When a startup exits, should they contribute financially to the open source devs that helped them build that startup?
A copy of my software costs $30. It would not be possible without the support of: Nginx, Firefox, Firebug, YSlow, Ruby, Rails, Prawn, Java, the Apache Commons HTTPClient library, Google Charts, the Ruby Google Chart API wrapper, Wordpress, six wordpress Plugins, Netbeans, Eclipse, Ubuntu, the whole Linux toolchain, launch4j, JarBuilder, the hominid gem, InnoSetup, and the guy listed in the credits who wrote the font selection dialog whose name I can never remember but who licensed it under the condition that I put his name in the credits.
[Edit: In five seconds since posting this I have thought of at least six projects omitted above. Do I need to remind people that I sell a freaking bingo card maker? A full accounting would sound like I, Pencil: 2009 edition, and if I had to do it for a more technically involved project my head would explode.]
Do you have a sane scheme for identifying a fair way to distribute $30, or $3 million, between all of the individuals and corporations who cooperated in the release of the above? If you do, your scheme left someone out. By what basis have you decided that their contribution is morally less important than those of the people who you included?
If you want to get money from the people who use your software, charge the people who use your software money.
- davidw 17y ago> If you want to get money from the people who use your software, charge the people who use your software money. Sure. But money isn't the only currency. "Thanks!" is a really good start. It makes my day when someone says thanks for something I've done. Beyond that, actually contributing a little bit here or there, where possible, is really appreciated too.
- ErrantX 17y ago> In five seconds since posting this I have thought of at least six projects omitted above. I think your misconstruing the point. Indeed most of the projects you listed can hardly be considered crucial or core technologies :) I think the main point here is if you take a core code base, say Lamson (seeing as Zed is the source of this whole debate :D) and built a popular enterprise mail server/client (say something like Kerio Mail Server) out of it. Is it not "good form" to perhaps put some obvious credit "built with the cool lamson". Or perhaps offer Zed a bit of cash to iron some bugs you found. Or farm back bug fixes into the Lamson source. 90% of companies probaboly wont bother - and they should, right? :) I also think you assuming the idea is distribute cash according ot some scheme or other. As I see it the point is that it would be "nice" if more companies considered it good form to show appreciation for the core technologies that make their businesses tick :) (in whatever form they can afford / deem appropriate).
- daleharvey 17y agoI think you are mixing up ethical responsibilities with legal ones. I dont think its plausible to tie in a bunch of red tape around open source that makes attribution / repayment a legal obligation, but I do believe in karma (in a practical sense, not mythical) If I heavily benefit from open source, while I dont have any legal obligations to do anything about it, I believe the right thing to do is to contribute back to the community, upstream patches, new tools, promoting it etc etc.